Live data from Hacker News

The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume III

feynmanlectures.caltech.edu

11–20 of 22 posts

Re: The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume III

#11
post #4

I'd love to be able to buy MP3s of his lectures for download. I have been unable to find them online, does anyone here have any pointers?

They were publish in audio CD format some time ago. They are available at the Santa Clara public library[1].

A subset of the collection is available on CDs from Amazon. [2]

I have found listening to them very interesting. I am just trying to grasp the concepts, so not being able to see the equations isn't that important to me.

[1] http://s831.us/1duD3P0 [2] http://www.amazon.com/The-Very-Best-Feynman-Lectures/dp/0465...

Re: The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume III

#12
post #9
post #2

Dear Feynman Lectures Forum Members, Since the release of the free online edition of FLP Vol. I in September many of you have written to ask whether we will publish the other two volumes of FLP online. Many have also asked whether we intend to publish PDF editions of FLP that can be read offline. In fact we originally planned to publish all three volumes online when our PDF editions became available, so we could use…

"download in secure PDF format" (from the ebooks.com page linked from feynmanlectures.info/docroot/buy) Is this some sort of DRM'ed format that's not readable on non-Adobe supported systems? And, if it is, is there a way to buy a non-DRM version?

Good question. I never buy DRM unless there's a powerful reason (and "I really want it" doesn't qualify).

Re: The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume III

#13
post #4

I'd love to be able to buy MP3s of his lectures for download. I have been unable to find them online, does anyone here have any pointers?

They were publish in audio CD format some time ago. They are available at the Santa Clara public library[1]. A subset of the collection is available on CDs from Amazon. [2] I have found listening to them very interesting. I am just trying to grasp the concepts, so not being able to see the equations isn't that important to me. [1] http://s831.us/1duD3P0 [2] http://www.amazon.com/The-Very-Best-Feynman-Lectures/dp/0465…

Thanks for this, I finally succumbed to the 20th Century and bought the CD off of Amazon.co.uk. Just need to dig out a cd player to rip it.

I remain surprised there isn't anyone offering these as paid for MP3 downloads. Seems like the right audience for that.

Re: The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume III

#17
post #10
post #7

http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/29355/reading-the... I do not think either of Ron Maimon's comments could be easily improved upon. This stackexchange has been cleaned up as per the "I deleted some old and/or off topic comments" if I remember correctly this article used to have some hilarious deletionist rant about historical physics texts being off topic for physics SE.

I agree; his comments really do cover why I am a huge fan of them. Feynman's lectures are less about the actual physics, and more a tour de force in how he approaches problem solving and intuition of problems. He just uses physics to deliver it (and in doing so, gives you an excellent primer to a large amount of physics topics at a level that an interested party could find accessible). Having done some tertiary level…

"intuition of problems"

I have read several of his books, both non fiction and the autobiography. Would you say intense focus on development of intuition is a Feynman thing or a physicist thing or a general trait of anyone who masters a topic (not mutually exclusive). He is the most persuasive author I can think of WRT his (correct) opinion that development of good intuition results in problem solving.

Re: The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume III

#18

Does anybody know why do particles spin in the first place?

I vaguely remember reading that in his book and was inspired to see if anything has improved since then. My interpretation is "no" nothing has improved on that very specific front since the 60s.

Note that you'll get plenty of replies about completely different question, like "does the math work without spin?" and the answer being "no". And some defeatist commentary (if you've ever heard of the "shut up and calculate" interpretation of QM...)

It intuitively seems to have something to do with symmetry and the finite speed of light and maybe dimensionality and the quantization of angular momentum. I have no intuitive explanation of the peculiar behavior of a spin 1/2 particle as it rotates thru 720 degrees. At least not in three dimensions.

There's been several Nobel prizes for the "what" and "how" and whoever figures out the "why" will likely get a prize someday.

Traditionally in physics new theories require what starts out as weird math at the time. So it'll probably come from automata theory or cryptology theory or whatever rather than yet another real analysis discovery or yet another statistical analysis.

If you want a spooky smoke and mirrors faith to latch on to, I am a big fan of "every form of Math ever invented can eventually be applied to Physics, even if it takes a couple centuries to figure out how". Nothing wrong with having peculiar faith based ideas as long as they don't interfere with life.

Re: The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume III

#19
post #2

Dear Feynman Lectures Forum Members, Since the release of the free online edition of FLP Vol. I in September many of you have written to ask whether we will publish the other two volumes of FLP online. Many have also asked whether we intend to publish PDF editions of FLP that can be read offline. In fact we originally planned to publish all three volumes online when our PDF editions became available, so we could use…

Would you consider publishing in an actual ebook format, that reflows? I read on Kindles, which usually don't do well with pdf's. That the pdf's also have some sort of "security" makes me think I can't convert it myself as well.

Re: The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Volume III

#20
post #17
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree; his comments really do cover why I am a huge fan of them. Feynman's lectures are less about the actual physics, and more a tour de force in how he approaches problem solving and intuition of problems. He just uses physics to deliver it (and in doing so, gives you an excellent primer to a large amount of physics topics at a level that an interested party could find accessible). Having done some tertiary level…

"intuition of problems" I have read several of his books, both non fiction and the autobiography. Would you say intense focus on development of intuition is a Feynman thing or a physicist thing or a general trait of anyone who masters a topic (not mutually exclusive). He is the most persuasive author I can think of WRT his (correct) opinion that development of good intuition results in problem solving.

I think it's a teacher thing. All the best teachers I've observed, both in my life and famous ones, have mastered the teaching of intuition. This is not limited to physics or even the hard sciences. I'd also say that there's a causal link between those who can teach material well and those who truly master a subject matter, so your latter statement is correct.

I've been doing 8.01x and 8.02x on edX - both are taught by Walter Lewin[1] and I have found him to capture the same principles of understanding intuitively the material. Indeed, reading the discussion boards of the subjects I routinely see people laud the homework material for being challenging but when they finally crack it, experiencing a deeper understanding of and insight into the fundamental nature of the subject matter.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Walter_Lewin

Post reply on HN