Live data from Hacker News

Google is building a Chrome app-based development environment

thenextweb.com

21–30 of 102 posts

Re: Google is building a Chrome app-based development environment

#24

I don't understand Chrome apps. They require installation and only work on Chrome, so they come with none of the benefits of the web. They are slower and uglier than native Windows/Mac/Linux apps. What's the point?

The productivity of web-based development, with access to richer API's and local storage, on the reach and cross-platform of Chrome, with the visibility of publishing it on the Chrome Web Store, and only 1 browser to test it on = Win, Win!

Re: Google is building a Chrome app-based development environment

#26

Honestly, I don't see a point. Presumably, it originates from the belief that the the web is the future and that it will finally replace native platforms. I used to strongly believe in that too but now I don't think it will happen any time soon, if at all. Currently there are two kinds of platforms: the web, initilly intended for documents and native platforms, designed primarily for apps . Both have different streng…

You can try to get there by bringing the benefits of the web to apps, and by bringing the benefits of apps to the web. We're already seeing this with ChromeOS, FirefoxOS, Cordova, etc. on the web side, and various efforts to streamline app installation, add deep linking, and other things on the app side.

Personally, I think browsers can be a quite good application platform - they're basically a view hierarchy, with a layout and styling system, an event model, and scripting engine. With efforts like the *OS APIs, custom elements, asm.js/PNaCl/Dart, WebGL, canvas, Service Workers... there's a lot you can do, all in a stack that's easily accessible to millions of developers.

Re: Google is building a Chrome app-based development environment

#28

I don't understand Chrome apps. They require installation and only work on Chrome, so they come with none of the benefits of the web. They are slower and uglier than native Windows/Mac/Linux apps. What's the point?

> What's the point?

It's basically Java, but Google made it. Your Chrome Apps can run wherever Chrome does.

Re: Google is building a Chrome app-based development environment

#29

I don't understand Chrome apps. They require installation and only work on Chrome, so they come with none of the benefits of the web. They are slower and uglier than native Windows/Mac/Linux apps. What's the point?

> They are slower and uglier than native Windows/Mac/Linux apps. What's the point?

They are the "native" apps for ChromeOS that, incidentally, can also run anywhere else* that Chrome OS runs.

* except iOS

Post reply on HN