Live data from Hacker News

Why I Canceled Amazon Prime

tck.io

81–90 of 107 posts

Re: Why I Canceled Amazon Prime

#81
In these posts read the woes of what happens when a new system is created that does not reveal it's externalities - factors at first not noticed and that are not put into the cost equation but which, over time are revealed.

When I was a boy in a small town most goods were available in local stores. Local dealers maintained inventory. I could handle and inspect goods before buying them.

Some items were not available locally. I would call long-distance, order a part, give an address and a credit card number (or mail a check) and wait a week - what could be easier?

Today we order stuff on the Internet.

But is that better for the end-user? Although focused on delivery problems, many of these posts would suggest that it is not. And we haven't yet broached the subjects of expected vs received product, returns, overcharges, identity theft, etc.

Re: Why I Canceled Amazon Prime

#82
> You see, the problem with Amazon Prime is that you are shipping almost entirely via the USPS. Normally, I bet, in most of the country, this doesn't bode a single issue.

Nah, we have exactly the same problem here in Germany. I think that this will be one of the biggest challenges for Amazon in the coming years and can imagine them building their own delivery service for that reason.

Re: Why I Canceled Amazon Prime

#83
post #37

For the stuff you don't want the post office to touch / screw up / fail to deliver / whatever -- pay the $4 / item prime rate for one day delivery. No post office involved then. My only complaint with amazon using usps for the last-mile delivery (fedex smart-post, whatever ups's equivalent is) is that being just outside a good-sized city, fedex/ups will get it to their facility in a day or two, and then the post offi…

I love the $4 overnight. When I'm deciding whether to do 2-day or overnight, I always do a little thought experiment: If I'm sitting around tomorrow and wishing my new thing was here, would I open my wallet and shell out four bucks for it to show up today? You bet your ass I would! I'm an impatient bastard like that.

Re: Why I Canceled Amazon Prime

#84
post #22

In the UK Amazon has its own parcel delivery service that is used to deliver the majority of the larger parcels in my area. But it's not great. Some of the drivers decide they don't have time, or it's near the end of their shift, and log deliveries as no one home. I've had this confirmed by some of the drivers that do bother delivering. So while I've been home all day, I get an email (usually around 6pm) claiming no…

If you live north of Perth in Scotland and a parcel is sent via one of the big couriers it often gets subcontracted out to a local courier or franchised operator who can add another two to three days to deliver something that should be next day. I used to live in Perth and never had a single Prime delivery arrived next day as promised - in one ridiculous example, they shipped a parcel from their Greenock fulfilment centre to Perth and it took a week to arrive!. I ended up getting half the money back and cancelling Prime.

Four years later I found myself eligible for the free trial and have given Prime another shot, so far so good with 3 out of 3 orders arriving next day via Royal Mail.

"Some of the drivers decide they don't have time, or it's near the end of their shift, and log deliveries as no one home" - yes that is truly annoying and verging on fraudulent behaviour.

Re: Why I Canceled Amazon Prime

#85

Here in Amazon.com's home town of Seattle, Prime works flawlessly (no surprise there). Sometimes things arrive by USPS, but most often it's via UPS. Occasionally Amazon will even deliver package themselves. In fact, they once delivered a three item order to my house via all three methods in one day. I'm sure NYC is a big market for Amazon and no matter what the root cause is of the problem you are talking about, I'm…

Also in Seattle, and prime is great, except for when they use Ontrac. I once had a next-day shipment fail to show up, and on the third day I called Ontrac to find out why. The rep told me, and I'm completely serious, "the driver just decided not to do his job."

I actually appreciated the honesty, but I hope they fired the driver.

Re: Why I Canceled Amazon Prime

#86
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I will get stuff through I think its called UPS Mail Solutions or Fedex smartpost. it is where UPS or Fedex delivers my package to the Post Office, and then the USPS carrier delivers it to my house.

I think at my last job we got an oversized item by DHL, though it could have been FedEx. sub $100 A-frame ladder with $2.99 overnight shipping FTW.

I think DHL has scaled back there operations in my part of the country. Not something that I loose sleep over either.

Re: Why I Canceled Amazon Prime

#88
I used to have similar problem where I lived...

The USPS guy would regularly heave a package over a fence onto a stone patio (fragile packages be damned). Or lasership (a last mile carrier) would never actually deliver on time despite marking it in their tracking system as delivered (yet they would magically show up the next day claiming that it must have accidentally been delivered to a neighbor, though none ever claimed they did).

I would gladly pay a premium to choose delivery companies.

Re: Why I Canceled Amazon Prime

#89
post #49

Why not use Amazon Lockers [1]? It's actually sad that it's amazon specific. I'd love to see this rather implemented for the post services like USPS/UPS. In Germany, we have DHL Packstation and you can just have it shipped to those location and pick up your package 24/7. It started getting a bunch of locations in 2004 and nowadays they have them every ~300-500m around big towns (like Munich for instance). [1] http://…

Amazon Locker looks great - though it's not ubiquitous. The closest one is probably a 1 hour drive (with light traffic) and I live in a major metropolitan area in the US.

Re: Why I Canceled Amazon Prime

#90
post #72

I have more of a problem with lasership, but really my problems are kind of petty. I once ordered a hand plane on Amazon. I was planning on going to home depot (about 20 minutes away) but Amazon had same day delivery for $3 extra (prime). Easy choice, it was 10am, and by the time I get home i'd have the tool to continue work on my project. The website said delivery would be at or before 8pm. It ended up showing up at…

I used to share you pain - lasership was the worst!

Routine non-deliveries that they'd report as delivered, only to have it randomly show up 1-2 days later. Customer service was pretty bad too.

Post reply on HN