Live data from Hacker News

The Zuckerberg Files - All public utterances of Mark Zuckerberg

zuckerbergfiles.org

11–20 of 50 posts

Re: The Zuckerberg Files - All public utterances of Mark Zuckerberg

#11
post #5

Kinda of scary that people are collecting X founder's profile. Although these data are publicly available, this is still kind of scary.

Why is it scary? The other side to our society rewarding you with billions of dollars is that you are now a public figure.

Not only that but he's the CEO of a transnational corporation: their public pronouncements are always examined for any sort of securities edge.

Re: The Zuckerberg Files - All public utterances of Mark Zuckerberg

#12
post #10
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you realize that 'people are collecting X founder's profile' is essentially nothing highly significant in and of itself in this day and age (much thanks to Zuckerberg&co, ironically enough)? -- because this information is out there anyway and will always be there, anyone who's interested can cull that information with considerably little effort with some clever scraping scripts. What's offered with this initiative…

I do. I wrote that in my comment if you read it. But it is still quite "creepy" to see someone making that effort to collect all your public appearance and put into a profile, shared on HN when you wake up (although you have to send in an email stating your goal). And this is normally a job the public relation firm has to do.

This is not creepy, this is an academic pursuit of rounding up information of one individual who is incidentally spearheading big change of privacy in a society. This is one of the things that happens to you when you become a public figure. Is a 'biography' creepy? History researchers do this themselves when they're writing history, when they're writing biographies -- some work is made easier for them with this kind of stuff.

I think Zuckerberg's doings are a lot creepier than this when you really get down to it.

Re: The Zuckerberg Files - All public utterances of Mark Zuckerberg

#14

"The Zuckerberg Files is an open-access public archive" ... "Scholars wishing to gain access to the full archive should email access@zuckerbergfiles.org with their name, affiliation, and a brief description of the research project or purpose for which the materials will be put." Open-ish.

> Open-ish.

Aka closed :)

Re: The Zuckerberg Files - All public utterances of Mark Zuckerberg

#15
post #14

"The Zuckerberg Files is an open-access public archive" ... "Scholars wishing to gain access to the full archive should email access@zuckerbergfiles.org with their name, affiliation, and a brief description of the research project or purpose for which the materials will be put." Open-ish.

> Open-ish. Aka closed :)

It's like a box on a shelf you can't reach. It's not locked. It's not even closed. If you squint, you can guess what's inside.

But it's in a box. And it's up there. And you have to wait for someone to bring a ladder.

Re: The Zuckerberg Files - All public utterances of Mark Zuckerberg

#18
Am I the only one that thinks this should absolutely be put up in some open-source version-control-based way? If it's public, it's public. If I have to email you and you get to decide whether or not I'm a scholar, doesn't that defeat the purpose of making something available for learning, sharing, and accountability? Should I really have to have a research project or composed purpose to view "open" things?

Self undermining, that is.

Re: The Zuckerberg Files - All public utterances of Mark Zuckerberg

#19
post #3

While they don't ask upfront for money, they make a commendable effort of actually keeping people away from those files by asking people to email them with a stated research goal. Casually interested normal folks need not apply. It doesn't help either that their text files are in PDF instead of a format that can actually be programmatically processed.

It certainly would be useful to do some sort of programmatic analysis of speeches mapped over time. Sentiment analysis. Repeated phrases. Cross-reference with others' phrases to see who's saying the same things at the same times.

Oh well. I guess you can print it out really nicely. And it's "portable"!

Re: The Zuckerberg Files - All public utterances of Mark Zuckerberg

#20
>By gaining a better understanding of how Facebook’s founder and CEO conceives of his own company’s role in the policy and ethical debates surrounding social networking [...]

Sure, knowing how the CEO thinks is a good judge to know where Facebook is going, but it's a bit odd to think that Zuckerberg doesn't take note of what the Board say.

Why aren't they logging what Sandberg, Thiel and Graham say/do?

Post reply on HN