Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Is No Longer the Most Popular Social Network for Teens

slate.com

51–60 of 82 posts

Re: Facebook Is No Longer the Most Popular Social Network for Teens

#51
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What teacher buy-in would you like and reasonably expect? Does such a system have a single practical benefit to a teacher doing their job, that they couldn't / wouldn't do better offline by simply talking to the kid at school after the lesson? It's a benefit for the parents, and they got the daily status information (attendance, grades, discipline&other issues) flowing quickly and easily from teachers to parents, tha…

> Does such a system have a single practical benefit to a teacher doing their job, that they couldn't / wouldn't do better offline by simply talking to the kid at school after the lesson? I think so, as long as the scope is clearly defined. You are right in your later implications that it could easily be subverted to a tool making more work for teachers, and I was erroneously drifting down that path. > What would you…

For this functionality such systems work okay - but they won't work for kids-to-kids communication due to the same chicken and egg problem.

Your daughters wouldn't (couldn't) use it the way you imagine, because, face it, the 'critical mass' of other kids who'd they want to talk to simply wouldn't be on such a system online/active/quickly responding as they are on facebook/snapchat/whatever.

And I'm not sure if any classmate communication forum with a heaping level of oversight is realistic - the nature of teens and pre-teens is such that any must-be-part-of social activities would happen elsewhere; and if all the good stuff is elsewhere, then they don't need/want to use the monitored forum.

Re: Facebook Is No Longer the Most Popular Social Network for Teens

#52
post #16
post #3

The chart shows a huge jump in "Other," from 4% to 17% in just six months. I wish they explained that. Vine?

Reddit

Reddit is a social bookmarking site, not a social networking site.

The focus is on the content, not the user.

Re: Facebook Is No Longer the Most Popular Social Network for Teens

#53
post #12
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Teens represent the near future. They'll grow up and maybe carry their allegiances forward.

If services only remain at their peak for 4/5 years this doesn't represent much of an advantage.

The question is, does Facebook behave like Google, or even more generally, like e-mail, and last a long time, or is it just another 4-5 year fad? If its a longer term tool then the behavioral trends of young demographics are a big deal.

Re: Facebook Is No Longer the Most Popular Social Network for Teens

#55
post #3

The chart shows a huge jump in "Other," from 4% to 17% in just six months. I wish they explained that. Vine?

In Asia (at least here in Thailand) I think LINE is quickly overtaking all other social networks. It's sort of like What's App, but with much more functionality.

Re: Facebook Is No Longer the Most Popular Social Network for Teens

#57

I find Silicon Valley's obsession with teens fascinating. Why is teen usage a benchmark for the health of a startup? Do teenagers spend money online? Is there any research on that?

My guess is that the teenager/young adult demographic is highly coveted by advertisers because they tend to have disposable income (gross generalization) and are the most vocal/enthusiastic customers. they can act like 3d billboards for whatever they happen to be into. idk just a guess

Re: Facebook Is No Longer the Most Popular Social Network for Teens

#59
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Chicken and egg problem - they wouldn't be really active ther because they don't want to, and because noone is really active, then it wouldn't be a valuable resource for homework and communicating with other students. I've seen a large implementation (around 1/3 schools in my area) that technically could do all that, but you can only 'mandate' a horse to the water but can't make it drink - in the end, they were used…

I wonder how much of that was based on (lack of) teacher buy-in and parents knowing about it? I can tell you that if the teacher was available on such a system in my are, there would be at least a few users just from my kids. Beyond any moral or parent protectiveness issues, Facebook, Google Plus and Instagram all require you be at least 13 years old to use their services. My (very limited) understanding is that TOS…

It is illegal in the US for a company to collect information from a child under the age of 13. COPPA.

That is why the TOS are all what they are.

Re: Facebook Is No Longer the Most Popular Social Network for Teens

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe - though my guess is that they'll join a university population and/or workforce and start interacting with the wider world, that just happens to be significantly on Facebook. But at 40 mine is hardly a relevant opinion :)

My guess is they'll join university & the workforce, and then they'll join the world's most popular social network: email. ;)

They don't. 20somethings don't use SMTP-backed email as a significant component of telecommunication.

They use websites, apps, and txting.

Post reply on HN