Live data from Hacker News

Apple Just Cannibalized the MacBook Air

clear-coat.com

21–30 of 82 posts

Re: Apple Just Cannibalized the MacBook Air

#21
post #2

The battery life is missing from the table, probably because it contradicts the author's linkbait title.

Because the author is critical of Apple, it's link-bait? The title is hardly sensational.

What made you think the author is critical of Apple? Apple cannibalizes themselves all the time. It's one of the great things about them, that they're not afraid to do it.

Re: Apple Just Cannibalized the MacBook Air

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He also treats weight as a non issue.

Is weight really an issue? We're talking less than a half pound difference between two laptops. I don't think that's an "issue".

He is doing his compare against the 13", the 11" Air is 2.38 pounds. It matters for me. I had an Air and now have a Pro and it is a bit of a pain. Also, the whole bag is more weight since it is bigger than the 11" version.

Re: Apple Just Cannibalized the MacBook Air

#24

The author is a moron. The MBA is a much better machine for the average user and their pricing reflects that. As a developer, I would take the 13" MBA over the MBP. Also the author forgets the 11" Macbook Air. This is just dumb. I don't think the author understands how business works, or more specifically how Apple works.

Dude, civility.

Re: Apple Just Cannibalized the MacBook Air

#25
post #2

The battery life is missing from the table, probably because it contradicts the author's linkbait title.

The battery life estimate on Apple's site is 9 hours for the 13" Retina MBP and 12 hours for the 13" Air. The Air will run longer, but they probably both run long enough.

Eric Griffin seems to have different needs than I do. The relevant comparison for me is 13" Air with 256GB flash, 8GB RAM, 1.7GHz i7, and 12 hours estimated battery life for $1,549.00 or the 13" RMBP 256GB flash, 16GB RAM, 2.4GHz i5, and 9 hours of estimated battery life for $1,699.00. (Haswell i5s have hyperthreading, so the upgrade to the i7 does very little). This is $150 for twice the RAM, a great display, and 3/4 the battery life. It really does make the 13" Air seem silly.

Re: Apple Just Cannibalized the MacBook Air

#26

The author is a moron. The MBA is a much better machine for the average user and their pricing reflects that. As a developer, I would take the 13" MBA over the MBP. Also the author forgets the 11" Macbook Air. This is just dumb. I don't think the author understands how business works, or more specifically how Apple works.

What are your specific reasons, why would you take the 13" MBA over the 13 MBP?

Re: Apple Just Cannibalized the MacBook Air

#27

The author is a moron. The MBA is a much better machine for the average user and their pricing reflects that. As a developer, I would take the 13" MBA over the MBP. Also the author forgets the 11" Macbook Air. This is just dumb. I don't think the author understands how business works, or more specifically how Apple works.

so tell us, how does it work then?

Re: Apple Just Cannibalized the MacBook Air

#28
post #18

Unless they come out with an 11" Macbook Pro, I'm sticking with the Air. If you have a 13" Air then yes, the pros have made more sense for awhile IMO. For me the 11" Air with 8 gigs of ram, i7 processor and a solid state drive plus a Thunderbolt display is the ideal setup. Super portable and powerful enough for anything but the latest 3d gaming plus the display for when I'm in the office.

I'd like to hear more about your experience working on the 11", when you're away from the external display. Are you cramped because of the resolution? Keyboard and trackpad?

I think the screen and trackpad are the same size for all MacBooks.

Re: Apple Just Cannibalized the MacBook Air

#29

The author is a moron. The MBA is a much better machine for the average user and their pricing reflects that. As a developer, I would take the 13" MBA over the MBP. Also the author forgets the 11" Macbook Air. This is just dumb. I don't think the author understands how business works, or more specifically how Apple works.

Well, I was pretty committed to getting an Air as my travel machine, as I am building a desktop at home but still need something portable, and the performance gains of the small Pro have me reconsidering, plus the Retina display is such an upgrade for me (although I am still leaning Air, mainly for the 11'inch model).
Post reply on HN