Live data from Hacker News

LinkedIn Intro: Doing the Impossible on iOS

engineering.linkedin.com

21–30 of 309 posts

Re: LinkedIn Intro: Doing the Impossible on iOS

#22
This seems very very very brittle. Some over compensating product asshat managed to convince their code monkeys into building something that will probably break easily not to mention security concerns with giving them your mailbox access.

Re: LinkedIn Intro: Doing the Impossible on iOS

#23
post #5

Proxy to return a header in your email. CSS to render the content upon click. IFrame to update content so it doesn't get cached. Cute web hacks. I don't understand the problem with simply using their mobile app if you were really looking for work. It sounds like an unnecessary feature for people who are looking and an annoyance to people who are not. That seems to be the problem of Linked In. They harass those who ar…

I don't think it is designed for people "looking for work". It seems to be built for business development. For example, an email like: "Hey, we met at a conference last month, just wanted to follow up..." - now you can see who they are, where they work, a profile picture to jog your memory and quickly connect - all from your email client. Very similar to what Rapportive did for Gmail.

That's actually a good point. I never would think to use Linked in as a business card. I usually would just write, "Hey it's me from that place we met."

Re: LinkedIn Intro: Doing the Impossible on iOS

#24
post #18
post #12

Surely corporate IT departments are going to have a collective heart attack as employees start handing all their email to a third party?

Additional madness when the services inevitably closes and tens of thousands of corporate tickets are files about non-working email clients.

Why would the service close? It's supported by LinkedIn and AFAIK they're not in the habit of shutting things down. This almost feels like a no-brainer for them, especially given the move to mobile devices and locked-down apps.

Edit: Have I missed the point? I'm sure LinkedIn is a little more cautious about such changes than your average newly-founded startup. This product gives them access to people emails which they can probably glean a lot of info from. They already try to get access into email accounts (username + password) via the LinkedIn webapp so in a way this is just extending that to mobile. The only reason I can imagine them shutting it down is if no-one uses it (in which case, no one will complain).

Re: LinkedIn Intro: Doing the Impossible on iOS

#26
post #15
post #3

Wouldn't this essentially allow them access to read/analyze/archive all of your email for any account you set up?

Of course. They can send as you too, which given their spammy record is quite a huge issue. They will also be storing your IMAP password in plaintext.

Since they are proxying the request, they don't actually have to store the password at all.

Re: LinkedIn Intro: Doing the Impossible on iOS

#27
post #17

I don't care who the company is, or how trustworthy you think they are: avoid giving third parties credentials to your inbox.

If you think about the reach Linked in has, combine that with each contact the linked in user has and you have a very fast database of emails that can be misused.

Re: LinkedIn Intro: Doing the Impossible on iOS

#28
post #14

Technologically this is straightforward: it uses a proxy server that sits in between you and your actual mailserver. I think the privacy concerns of having your mail (potentially) available over yet another server in exchange for modest convenience makes it unlikely that I would use this, but I'm sure many will find the trade-off acceptable and desirable.

There are lots of concerns: * your local mail client might get different E-mail content every time mail is downloaded, which is not the intent of IMAP, * LinkedIn (hence, the NSA) gets full access to your E-mail, * once people get hooked it's easy to transition to inserting ads, or "more helpful LinkedIn content", I find all this rather disturbing and would never use this service.

Yes, I would never want them (or virtually any third party) to have the ability to access my inbox, much less stand in between my mail provider and myself.

Re: LinkedIn Intro: Doing the Impossible on iOS

#30
Despite the privacy concern everyone is warring about, it is a beautiful integration. Technology is supposed to make life easier, not harder. Since Apple didn't open the door, someone else will ended up doing it. I am sure an open source solution with own proxy + LinkedIn api will work as well. That should take away the privacy concern.
Post reply on HN