Apple Patent on Touch Typing, Multitouch Upheld; Allows Ban on Most Androids

This just shows how bad the state of the US Patent Industry is, were instead of making a better product, it's easier to hamstring a competing company.

If the patent is upheld, and Apple, having the hate it does for Android tries and bans Android Phones, then in the end, all it does is hurt the users who want a decent alternative to Apple Products. People expect multi-touch on their phones, and non-physical keyboards. I can just see my mom asking me why her new android phone doesn't swipe to scroll because her last phone did.

Such a shame.

This just shows how bad the state of the US Patent Industry is, were instead of making a better product, it's easier to hamstring a competing company.

If the patent is upheld, and Apple, having the hate it does for Android tries and bans Android Phones, then in the end, all it does is hurt the users who want a decent alternative to Apple Products. People expect multi-touch on their phones, and non-physical keyboards. I can just see my mom asking me why her new android phone doesn't swipe to scroll because her last phone did.

Such a shame.

Exactly. Furthermore, the claims are not limited to 'capacitive touch' screens and could in fact apply to gestures on any touch screen system, so a large part of the article is pointless and wrong.

I highly doubt that. I have a FingerWorks Touchstream LP that (while I don't use it anymore) was performing the same exact gestures we all recognize as "swipes" on capacitive touchscreen phones/tablets. As evidence I point you to the founder's dissertation on the topic from 1999: http://www.eecis.udel.edu/~westerma/main.pdf

The only difference between how it worked on a Touchstream LP and a modern capacitive touchscreen is that the trouchscreen has a "screen". Other than that they're absolutely identical.

Actually, the Touchstream LP had capabilities that exceed today's capacitive touchscreens. For example, it supports ten-finger chording and could recognize which finger was which. So if I pressed my index and middle fingers (say, with both hands) in a certain region of the keyboard it would recognize that and send whatever pre-programmed sequence of keystrokes or mouse movements I wanted.

It was awesome technology! It only had one (big) flaw though: No tactile feedback.

You take it for granted but the "click" you feel when you press a key on your keyboard is very, very important to typing quickly and efficiently. Without it you have to constantly ensure your hands & fingers in properly positioned. This is why autocorrect is so important with software keyboards (if you're tapping instead of swiping). Without it--if you tried to type really quickly without thinking about what is actually being output from the IME--you'll end up with typos all over the place.

Another thing we take for granted is the ability to "feel" a key as we press it. On a capacitive touch surface there's no way to do that without accidentally typing that key. This is why I have high hopes for that technology that produces little bubbles on top of touchscreens on-demand to provide tactile feedback as to key locations.

So that is the reason why I eventually gave up on using the Touchstream LP. While it was the greatest mousing device I've ever used (and I've used HUNDREDS) it was not that great of a keyboard. I'd be happy to use it day-to-day for typing up English words and sentences but it was just too error-prone to use in a bash shell or for programming. Even with the "programmer pad" feature (which let you enter keys like braces, brackets, parens, etc using handy gestures) it still resulted in too many typing mistakes--even after training myself and using it regularly for a year.