Live data from Hacker News

TSA Admits In Leaked Doc: No Evidence of Terrorist Plots Against Aviation in US

tsaoutofourpants.wordpress.com

41–50 of 129 posts

Re: TSA Admits In Leaked Doc: No Evidence of Terrorist Plots Against Aviation in US

#41
post #2

...But as you can see, Senator, there is also no evidence of the guaranteed absence of terrorist plots either. They are obviously even better hidden than we feared. Increased resources will be required to bring them to light. Our department has drafted a new budget proposal that takes this changed situation into account.

Ah you see, no terrorist plots actually means that our tiger^Wterrorist repellent rock is working!

Re: TSA Admits In Leaked Doc: No Evidence of Terrorist Plots Against Aviation in US

#42
post #7

I know I'm throwing my karma down the toilet here but domestic-sourced airline terrorism has happened before. The TSA (edit: OK, whoever it was that scanned our bags and ran us through the metal detector, if it was not "the TSA") was unaware of 9/11 as well. Argue all you want that we should just tolerate the occasional 9/11-style (edit: or the random pipe bomb blowing out the side of the plane, cockpit doors can't p…

You know what the answer is to 9/11-style events? Locking cockpit doors. And that's what they did after 9/11. Passengers now know what's at stake too. So, while bad things can happen, another 9/11 can't happen again (and as such, the TSA does nothing to prevent it anyway).

Also there is one actually proven method to deterring terrorist events like 9/11.

Four planes were hi-jacked. Three of those did not know that the outcome was to crash the plane into a building. But one did, and (as far as we know) the people aboard prevented that.

If the American people would simply have been informed that terrorists didn't want to steal planes, but instead fly them into target then 9/11 would have turned out very differently. And we know this because we have proof.

Re: TSA Admits In Leaked Doc: No Evidence of Terrorist Plots Against Aviation in US

#43
post #2

...But as you can see, Senator, there is also no evidence of the guaranteed absence of terrorist plots either. They are obviously even better hidden than we feared. Increased resources will be required to bring them to light. Our department has drafted a new budget proposal that takes this changed situation into account.

Exactly. Why can't we just pull their meta-data profiles from online, and just assess potential threat levels and weight it against the national threat level.

Threat level orange? Internet Anarchists and Armchair Libertarians don't fly.

Threat level blue? Just people who look like they have some desert heritage.

Threat level red? "I'm sorry sir. It says here you we're really, really mad at how a cop stopped you last weekend for going through a red light."

Re: TSA Admits In Leaked Doc: No Evidence of Terrorist Plots Against Aviation in US

#44
post #7

I know I'm throwing my karma down the toilet here but domestic-sourced airline terrorism has happened before. The TSA (edit: OK, whoever it was that scanned our bags and ran us through the metal detector, if it was not "the TSA") was unaware of 9/11 as well. Argue all you want that we should just tolerate the occasional 9/11-style (edit: or the random pipe bomb blowing out the side of the plane, cockpit doors can't p…

Have you ever been in line in a long TSA queue at a major airport? See anybody get scanned before getting in that line? With a coordinated attack across multiple airports, you could kill far more people just while they're standing in line to get their TSA gaterape procedure performed than you could by attacking while onboard an aircraft. The aircraft attack vector has already been played out. Lets keep sane regulatio…

Terrorists have indeed already done this at Domodedevo airport in Moscow, Russia. By creating giant lines of people at security checkpoint (along with a scattering of federal employees), the TSA has created the perfect target.

Re: TSA Admits In Leaked Doc: No Evidence of Terrorist Plots Against Aviation in US

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Have you ever been in line in a long TSA queue at a major airport? See anybody get scanned before getting in that line? With a coordinated attack across multiple airports, you could kill far more people just while they're standing in line to get their TSA gaterape procedure performed than you could by attacking while onboard an aircraft. The aircraft attack vector has already been played out. Lets keep sane regulatio…

Terrorists have indeed already done this at Domodedevo airport in Moscow, Russia. By creating giant lines of people at security checkpoint (along with a scattering of federal employees), the TSA has created the perfect target.

[deleted]

Re: TSA Admits In Leaked Doc: No Evidence of Terrorist Plots Against Aviation in US

#47
post #10

From my horizon the entire security debacle have never been about actually keeping the populations safe - it's there to keep them worried about "the enemy" and keep them compliant with both funding requests and authorities in general. As of today neither USA or countries in western Europe can be considered police states. But if we keep on travelling in the same direction we are going now, that's where we'll end up.

Exactly! After "Communists!" went away in the early 90s, the US Government and the associated "defence contractors" found the money a lot tighter. Although I'm pretty sure they didn't create 9/11, or just let it happen, the US Government and the defence contractors have sure jumped on the "Terrorists!" wagon.

The War on Terror is just the boogie man that Containing Communism used to be.

Re: TSA Admits In Leaked Doc: No Evidence of Terrorist Plots Against Aviation in US

#48
post #15

I'm a huge critic of the TSA and would be thrilled to see it dismantled, but I always find these kinds of arguments a little intellectually dishonest. It could be that “terrorist threat groups present in the Homeland are not known to be actively plotting against civil aviation targets or airports” because we have scanners in place that deter that kind of threat. Now, I don't believe this is the case, as plenty of res…

How's the saying go? Absence of evidence isn't evidence of absence. Except when it is.

Yeah, really absence of evidence is evidence (though not proof) of absence, unless the absence of evidence can be explained as "well we haven't bothered trying to find evidence."

(In other words, if I don't look in a box, then I don't have evidence that anything is in the box, but that's not evidence that the box is empty. If however I do look in the box and fail to find evidence of anything in it, that is evidence that the box is in fact empty.)

They have presumably been looking for terrorists rather intensely.

Re: TSA Admits In Leaked Doc: No Evidence of Terrorist Plots Against Aviation in US

#49
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The TSA did not exist prior to 9/11/2001. Elements of various intelligence community agencies were aware of a 9/11-style plot and were aware of the hijackers' existence within the United States. If these existing agencies had worked together and done their job , 9/11 might never have happened. All without anyone removing their belts, frisking grandma, or having to stand like a perp in a county lock-up.

that is very interesting. were the people scanning the luggage and such beforehand just hired by individual airports? I've no issue with restructuring TSA or whatnot, I just think that if people could get on airplanes the way they do buses, there'd be events. Not so much 9/11 style hijackings, more like the occasional pipe bomb or shooting.

Yes, prior to 9/11 airports would hire private companies to do their security checks. This was often why different airports would have different degrees of thoroughness; I recall a trip through Kansas City in the mid-90s where I was amazed (and annoyed) that I had to turn on my laptop, despite never having to do that for dozens of trips elsewhere.

Re: TSA Admits In Leaked Doc: No Evidence of Terrorist Plots Against Aviation in US

#50
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The TSA did not exist prior to 9/11/2001. Elements of various intelligence community agencies were aware of a 9/11-style plot and were aware of the hijackers' existence within the United States. If these existing agencies had worked together and done their job , 9/11 might never have happened. All without anyone removing their belts, frisking grandma, or having to stand like a perp in a county lock-up.

that is very interesting. were the people scanning the luggage and such beforehand just hired by individual airports? I've no issue with restructuring TSA or whatnot, I just think that if people could get on airplanes the way they do buses, there'd be events. Not so much 9/11 style hijackings, more like the occasional pipe bomb or shooting.

What about the lines? People don't get felt up or forced through machines to wait in the lines to get felt up or forced through machines.

I fail to see how someone couldn't just bomb the lines with the exact same effect you're describing above.

I'd much rather prefer volunteering to use a private company's services freely without force or coercion, and risk dying randomly, then be harassed and embarrassed and risk dying randomly.

Post reply on HN