Live data from Hacker News

The problem with Android is choice

sixrevisions.com

61–67 of 67 posts

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#61
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's not true though. http://developer.android.com/about/dashboards/index.html

Fixed that for you, 1/3 of android devices are still trapped <= 2.3

You should also revise "These phones represent a fraction of the overall android market" to "These phones represent the majority of the overall android market."

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> On the other hand I think Android is a just a confusing mess to use, and I say this as someone who is fairly familiar with its innards and has been hired to write Android firmware code. That's funny, because my grandma uses Android just fine, even though she had never touched a computer in her life before using Android. Being "familiar with its innards" and having written Android firmware doesn't give you very good…

Did she set it up herself?

There was nothing to "set up", she created a Google account and that was about it. The biggest difficulty she had was learning to type with a QWERTY keyboard, since she had never used a typewriter or computer before. So she instead uses the mazec2 Handwriting Recognition keyboard[0] with a stylus. That's something you definitely could have never done on Apple's locked-down platform.

0: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.metamoji.m...

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#63
post #56
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Have you used Android? It's really not that annoying. It's actually one of the best things Android has over iPhones right now.

I have a Nexus 4. Had a Nexus S. I find it irritating, in a papercut kind of way.

if you find it irritating, when why are you trying to share things anyhow?

The alternative is iPhone style, where you copy-and-paste things from app-to-app...

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#64
post #30
post #8

To present Android's Intents as some disadvantage must be pure ignorance.

To pretend that for the majority this isn't annoying is disingenuous.

I have not find anyone confused or irritated with intents. How do you share something without a list of choices?

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#65

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did she set it up herself?

There was nothing to "set up", she created a Google account and that was about it. The biggest difficulty she had was learning to type with a QWERTY keyboard, since she had never used a typewriter or computer before. So she instead uses the mazec2 Handwriting Recognition keyboard[0] with a stylus. That's something you definitely could have never done on Apple's locked-down platform. 0: https://play.google.com/store/a…

Wireless? Rejecting/accepting Google Now? Non-gmail email accounts?

I'm trying to think back to when I set up my dad's phone and my own phone. Certainly wasn't 1. Create Google account 2. Done.

I don't think Apple did it any better though. It all sucks in different ways.

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There was nothing to "set up", she created a Google account and that was about it. The biggest difficulty she had was learning to type with a QWERTY keyboard, since she had never used a typewriter or computer before. So she instead uses the mazec2 Handwriting Recognition keyboard[0] with a stylus. That's something you definitely could have never done on Apple's locked-down platform. 0: https://play.google.com/store/a…

Wireless? Rejecting/accepting Google Now? Non-gmail email accounts? I'm trying to think back to when I set up my dad's phone and my own phone. Certainly wasn't 1. Create Google account 2. Done. I don't think Apple did it any better though. It all sucks in different ways.

> Wireless?

I probably entered this while she was at my house, but she had no problems setting it up after going home.

> Rejecting/accepting Google Now?

Never came up.

> Non-gmail email accounts?

As someone who had never used a computer before, this obviously wasn't an issue either.

Re: The problem with Android is choice

#67
post #43
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think Linux stood a real chance with the introduction of Ubuntu a long time ago. Graphical package management was enormous, coupled with Gnome and a very simple installation. But stagnation came very quickly. That distribution is 10 years old and all the changes to it only added more fluff, more bulk, annoying notifications, uglier windows, sprites and mini icons all over the place. It looks the exact same except w…

> I think Linux stood a real chance with the introduction of Ubuntu a long time ago. Graphical package management was enormous, coupled with Gnome and a very simple installation. From that perspective Ubuntu didn't add much to Debian, or existing variants like Knoppix. > The problem wasn't lack of consistency or choice. It was like going from Windows 7 to Windows 8. Now I can only see myself using Linux as a stepping…

I would say that in those 10 years where that distribution already had a great starting point, it has been surpassed an absurd amount by Android.
Post reply on HN