Live data from Hacker News

Nuclear fusion milestone passed at US lab

bbc.co.uk

221–222 of 222 posts

Re: Nuclear fusion milestone passed at US lab

#221
post #213

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's just not true, and skirts the line of the being a deliberate lie. Fusion has occured in tokamaks, at an efficiency of 65%. ITER, as currently designed and being built, is expected to make a 10-fold return on energy input. We are precisely at the position of "the math is all there" with regard to magnetic confinement. And so is the engineering and the funding (barely). It's going to happen, hopefully not before…

I should mention that in the past, I worked on the software backing research tokamaks. ITER is a research project. It is not designed to produce electricity. It was originally projected to cost over 5 billion pounds to build and has now tripled, but is years from completion. Even if it was successful beyond its wildest dreams, the best result would be that we'd have to spend another $50B to build a plant, and since t…

That's not much. A single modern nuclear plant costs around 8.5 billion.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Olkiluoto_Nuclear_Power_Plant#U...

Re: Nuclear fusion milestone passed at US lab

#222

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Speculating about their "real" motives is just that; speculation. I'm sorry your project was defunded, but that in itself is not evidence that the facility is actually a sham.

You say "speculation" as if it were a bad thing.

I could speculate that space aliens secretly landed in Roswell and took over the government 60 years ago, but without evidence, it's just a story.
Post reply on HN