Live data from Hacker News

Elite: Dangerous will support Oculus Rift

kickstarter.com

11–18 of 18 posts

Re: Elite: Dangerous will support Oculus Rift

#11

I'm _deeply_ excited about Elite: Dangerous - it's pretty much the only videogame I think that could these days, thanks to how it opened my eyes and captured my imagination as a youngster. The idea of OR on top is brilliant, too - seems like a great fit for a cockpit-based game. Question: only the OR dev kits appear to be available at the moment. Is there a public roadmap for a consumer version?

Q3 2014~

Couldn't wait personally. No regrets.

Re: Elite: Dangerous will support Oculus Rift

#12
post #10

I'm _deeply_ excited about Elite: Dangerous - it's pretty much the only videogame I think that could these days, thanks to how it opened my eyes and captured my imagination as a youngster. The idea of OR on top is brilliant, too - seems like a great fit for a cockpit-based game. Question: only the OR dev kits appear to be available at the moment. Is there a public roadmap for a consumer version?

Might want to temper that nostalgia-driven enthusiasm a bit. The path you're on leads only to disappointment and regret. To answer your question, not yet. I would expect to hear something later this year on the time frame for the consumer version, which I'm also waiting for. Not only for this game, but also to plug into a raspberry pi for a project. Just waiting for that 1080 display.

I'm cautiously optimistic. The Elite series has had a lot of misfires, but they do seem to have learned from them. And a lot of those misfires come from single design decisions that seemed like a good idea at the time, like using a true Newtonian physics model instead of the traditional "WWII fighter jet in space" physics model. If you could get past that, Frontier Elite still had the fun Elite stuff at its core, it's just that it was very nearly wrecked by that decision. I would still consider this a risk, but it looks like at the very least they have no intention of repeating that mistake.

Note I did not fund it, so this isn't just rationalization of sunk cost for me. And I do mean "cautiously" optimistic... while I continue to believe that procedural content generation is the way of the future, its continuing failure to manifest is making me wonder if perhaps it is the way of the future in the same way that, say, raytracing or voxels has been the way of the graphics future for about 10 years now, without ever happening. Still, we'll see.

Re: Elite: Dangerous will support Oculus Rift

#13

Virtual Reality headsets have had a long history of not being as successful as they should have been. Anyone remember Virtuality, as in the company? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtuality_(gaming) Their products were amazing for the time but they just did not catch on. I never understood why. (However, I did subsequently learn that their games were not actually stereo vision!) It is a bit like 3D - amazing cinema ex…

I have a Oculus Rift, it is not even remotely comparable to the VR headsets of the 90s. The VR headsets of yesteryear were incredibly heavy, had extremely poor resolution, and either did not sense head motion or at all, or were so laggy at it that it induced severe motion sickness.

The Oculus Rift has solved all of this except the resolution bit, and word has it they've got it figured for the retail launch of their product.

The Oculus Rift is to 90s VR as the Ford Model T is to a donkey.

Re: Elite: Dangerous will support Oculus Rift

#14

Virtual Reality headsets have had a long history of not being as successful as they should have been. Anyone remember Virtuality, as in the company? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtuality_(gaming) Their products were amazing for the time but they just did not catch on. I never understood why. (However, I did subsequently learn that their games were not actually stereo vision!) It is a bit like 3D - amazing cinema ex…

Cheers for the downvotes!

Re: motion sickness.

Oculus (Rift) are aware that this is a problem with their product and they have not solved it.

If you think about it, having better tracking sensors than the VR headsets of the 90's does not do anything to fix the fundamental problem: your eyes getting different inputs to what the body is getting. If your eyes are telling you that you are falling but your stomach and ear canals are telling you that you are still sat on your arse in your mom's basement then you just might start feeling sick. Improved gyros in the headset are not going to magically create some anti-gravity field for you, are they?

As for the 'you have not tried this particular brand of VR headset and therefore you don't know what you are on about', line of argument, true I have not tried these particular VR headset novelty devices yet. However, I have also yet to try a 2013 model 3D TV but, from having seen how the 2010 3D TV's had their failings I can fairly predict that the 2013 3D TV's have not addressed the fundamental failings that the 2010 models had and are therefore unlikely to take the market by storm.

I am merely sharing the same level of scepticism that the BBC had regarding this particular product:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-23877695

We have seen it all before and people just don't want to wear some clumsy headset in their living room, whether that is to watch a movie, to be 'in' a game or anything else. Even without the motion sickness problem this product would be only for a few gamers with more money and sense.

Re: Elite: Dangerous will support Oculus Rift

#16

Virtual Reality headsets have had a long history of not being as successful as they should have been. Anyone remember Virtuality, as in the company? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtuality_(gaming) Their products were amazing for the time but they just did not catch on. I never understood why. (However, I did subsequently learn that their games were not actually stereo vision!) It is a bit like 3D - amazing cinema ex…

Cheers for the downvotes! Re: motion sickness. Oculus (Rift) are aware that this is a problem with their product and they have not solved it. If you think about it, having better tracking sensors than the VR headsets of the 90's does not do anything to fix the fundamental problem: your eyes getting different inputs to what the body is getting. If your eyes are telling you that you are falling but your stomach and ear…

It's telling that the article you link to wastes several paragraphs on Nintendo's Virtual Boy, which didn't have any head tracking, displayed only red and black, and couldn't even render 3D models. Yep, totally applicable to modern consoles that can render highly detailed cities, with convincing physics, surround sound, and multiplayer connectivity that would be unimaginable in 1995.

The first wave of VR headsets came out while 3D gaming was in its infancy. Some genres (FPS, fighters) made sense early; platformers and RPGs were only really honed after the VR craze was dead and buried.

Re: Elite: Dangerous will support Oculus Rift

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Cheers for the downvotes! Re: motion sickness. Oculus (Rift) are aware that this is a problem with their product and they have not solved it. If you think about it, having better tracking sensors than the VR headsets of the 90's does not do anything to fix the fundamental problem: your eyes getting different inputs to what the body is getting. If your eyes are telling you that you are falling but your stomach and ear…

It's telling that the article you link to wastes several paragraphs on Nintendo's Virtual Boy, which didn't have any head tracking, displayed only red and black, and couldn't even render 3D models. Yep, totally applicable to modern consoles that can render highly detailed cities, with convincing physics, surround sound, and multiplayer connectivity that would be unimaginable in 1995. The first wave of VR headsets cam…

Picking holes in the BBC article, are we!

The BBC article is about the history of VR headsets hence it includes a mention of everything that went before - simples.

This new fangled headset does not solve the problems - 1) motion sickness and 2) nobody wants to wear these things in their front room. As a consequence it is only going to appeal to a few gamers rather than suddenly persuade millions of people that do not game to rush out and buy VR headsets.

If 2) wasn't the case then, given how high resolution panels have been available for quite a few years in affordable phones, we would have headsets for a wider range of non-game applications - e.g. watching 2D/3D movies, watching porn and taking photos. There are a few of these more basic headsets out there but nobody is queuing up for them and none of the big companies are desperate to sell them.

I wasted at least one whole summer playing the original Elite and the top 3/4 of the screen was black and white, mostly black with an occasional wireframe model of some space ship. The lower quarter of the screen was four colour and even chunkier graphics than the top due to how Bell+Braben did that cool mode 0/2 switch that had not been done before on the BBC Micro. I can still remember most of the hot keys - S, X, , H for hyperspace...

Elite was truly the most original and innovative game ever. In terms of rocket science and pioneering innovation it was in an entirely different league to this new fangled VR headset which is not really anything more than a mobile phone strapped to some ski goggles.

Re: Elite: Dangerous will support Oculus Rift

#18
post #10

I'm _deeply_ excited about Elite: Dangerous - it's pretty much the only videogame I think that could these days, thanks to how it opened my eyes and captured my imagination as a youngster. The idea of OR on top is brilliant, too - seems like a great fit for a cockpit-based game. Question: only the OR dev kits appear to be available at the moment. Is there a public roadmap for a consumer version?

Might want to temper that nostalgia-driven enthusiasm a bit. The path you're on leads only to disappointment and regret. To answer your question, not yet. I would expect to hear something later this year on the time frame for the consumer version, which I'm also waiting for. Not only for this game, but also to plug into a raspberry pi for a project. Just waiting for that 1080 display.

I had much fun with X-Beyond Frontier
Post reply on HN