Live data from Hacker News

China to launch space station by 2023

bbc.co.uk

21–30 of 74 posts

Re: China to launch space station by 2023

#21
post #13

Thought I'd comment before the typical anti-Chinese-Engineering brigade shows up. In my opinion, Chinese engineering is a wonder to behold in an era of modern western bureaucracy killing amazing projects. I realise Chinese politics are so far the other way they can be just as bad in different ways, but if China had the same level of bureaucracy as the west their insane Beijing-Shanghai high speed rail link would have…

The cost now in such infrastructure expansion isn't "only" the human expense of civil/personal liberties in China, it's increasingly the planet itself. The sooner China, the US, and other industralizing countries start taking that seriously, the better.

And meanwhile Fukushima has been dumping huge volumes of radioactive waste water into Pacific for the past two years, the western world seems to be OK with that. Maybe space is more valuable than oceans.

Re: China to launch space station by 2023

#22

Does anyone have a list of things China said they are going to do but haven't actually done? [Added] Just to be clear, I am actually interested in a list, not interested in disparaging China. I'm mainly curious.

One thing for sure is that the list is too long to fit into NSA's hard drives. Proud to be a Chinese!

Re: China to launch space station by 2023

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The cost now in such infrastructure expansion isn't "only" the human expense of civil/personal liberties in China, it's increasingly the planet itself. The sooner China, the US, and other industralizing countries start taking that seriously, the better.

And meanwhile Fukushima has been dumping huge volumes of radioactive waste water into Pacific for the past two years, the western world seems to be OK with that. Maybe space is more valuable than oceans.

We seem to generally (east, west, whatever) lack the collective capacity to care about these things unless we can't ignore it in the short term.

Re: China to launch space station by 2023

#25
post #13

Thought I'd comment before the typical anti-Chinese-Engineering brigade shows up. In my opinion, Chinese engineering is a wonder to behold in an era of modern western bureaucracy killing amazing projects. I realise Chinese politics are so far the other way they can be just as bad in different ways, but if China had the same level of bureaucracy as the west their insane Beijing-Shanghai high speed rail link would have…

The 'bureaucracy' has just put the man behind the Chinese high speed railway behind bars.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liu_Zhijun

Re: China to launch space station by 2023

#26
A space station is a bad investment for any country.

The annual cost of the ISS is $3-billion-year. It will cost an additional 24-billion for the next 6-years to keep it up

The total budget cost of the Kepler Spacecraft was $0.6-billion and discovered something like 2,740 planets outside our solar system.

The Mars Science Laboratory cost was $2.5-billion and as of last month revealed that Mars once was a habitable planet.

The Hubble space telescope in all cost $9.6-billion over the decades (plural) and sincerely over-delivered by refining the predicted age of the universe and validating that the universe is indeed expanding faster and faster.

I would rather they launch more probes, telescopes, and comet samplers than a space station that costs more than it delivers.

Re: China to launch space station by 2023

#27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's only a bit hypocritical. There are actual degrees of hypocrisy! The US constitution frequently prevents the US government (and US State governments) from enacting laws or enforcing previously enacted laws. This can be good or bad depending on your point of view, but it's a simple fact that in the US we have constitutional rights that are actually pretty potent. Do the police in China have to read people their ri…

It's only a bit hypocritical. There are actual degrees of hypocrisy! I don't get this. Did you mean there are 50% hypocrites and 90% hypocrites? And the 50% hypocrites can always laugh it out at the 90% hypocrites, because he/she may think he/she has a moral high ground due to less hypocrisy. Heck, that's mouthful.

I don't get this. Are you saying someone who is a hypocrite 1% of the time is equal to someone who is a hypocrite 99% of the time?

Re: China to launch space station by 2023

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And meanwhile Fukushima has been dumping huge volumes of radioactive waste water into Pacific for the past two years, the western world seems to be OK with that. Maybe space is more valuable than oceans.

We seem to generally (east, west, whatever) lack the collective capacity to care about these things unless we can't ignore it in the short term.

I agree. This is the tragic commons of the human beings.

Re: China to launch space station by 2023

#29

A space station is a bad investment for any country. The annual cost of the ISS is $3-billion-year. It will cost an additional 24-billion for the next 6-years to keep it up The total budget cost of the Kepler Spacecraft was $0.6-billion and discovered something like 2,740 planets outside our solar system. The Mars Science Laboratory cost was $2.5-billion and as of last month revealed that Mars once was a habitable pl…

But it would be such a huge positive political asset that can feed so many people for years.

Re: China to launch space station by 2023

#30
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's only a bit hypocritical. There are actual degrees of hypocrisy! I don't get this. Did you mean there are 50% hypocrites and 90% hypocrites? And the 50% hypocrites can always laugh it out at the 90% hypocrites, because he/she may think he/she has a moral high ground due to less hypocrisy. Heck, that's mouthful.

I don't get this. Are you saying someone who is a hypocrite 1% of the time is equal to someone who is a hypocrite 99% of the time?

Yes, they are both hypocrites :)

(Seriously though, degree and frequency are different things)

Post reply on HN