Live data from Hacker News

The Dribbblisation of Design

insideintercom.io

101–104 of 104 posts

Re: The Dribbblisation of Design

#101
post #22

Dribbble is to design what GitHub is to coding. Case closed.

If so, dribbble is like letting you post only the first 5 lines of a README.md without commit history. Not quite the same.

In design world, if you need more than 5 lines, you're doing it wrong.

Re: The Dribbblisation of Design

#102
post #24

As someone who went through a job hunt without a "Dribbblized" portfolio a couple years ago: Go with the Dribbble approach. At least if you're looking for anything resembling a design job. That final layer of polish and execution is what gets you hired. If you don't have that, you get eliminated immediately. Nobody will ask about your process or your wireframes if your resume gets tossed in the trash bin. You'll neve…

I also agree. It's like a developer obsessing about good code and best practices.

Sure the developer cares but the client does not care whatsoever.

Similarly the designer cares about sticking to product design and making the problem easier. However the manager wants something that looks pretty, something that looks expensive and nice to use.

EDIT: I would also like to add I agree with this sentiment. We want pretty apps. I think the time for functional apps was when the iOS and Android markets first came out and touching things on your screen to do something was foreign. Now just like iOS7, it's time to take the steering wheels off.

This is akin to the web during the '90s and early 2000 era.

Re: The Dribbblisation of Design

#103

Earlier quoted context omitted.

IMO: Considering its place currently in overall page layout, logo might be better simplified and with less contrast. E.g., take the favicon version—it's nice too, actually. It especially concerns the application section of Predictobot: current logo will be too distracting. Compare a few pages with similar layout to yours, note they all use more schematic logos that draw less attention to header: https://www.getsentry…

Thanks for the constructive criticism. I'll try to tone it down a bit in the real site. I just did the teaser site quite quickly to collect emails, before a conference I was talking at.

Sure, glad if I helped. To complete my suggestion—you can also change landing page layout to make logo more prominent (something like http://docker.io/), in which case it doesn't need to be simplified.

Re: The Dribbblisation of Design

#104

I agree with this article, but who is to say the goal of Dribbble isn't to just showcase visual design? To join Dribbble, you must get an invite from a Dribbble user. Dribbble users invite people who have similar taste and design state-of-mind as they do. So in the end you get a gated community of designers who think and work alike. The problem with this I see is that non-design people who wants to hire designers thi…

You nailed it. Dribbble excels at featuring and sharing solutions to visual design challenges. Icons. Logos. UI components that show effective affordance (as best you can tell from a small screenshot).

I think Dribbble is somewhat a victim of success; everyone wants in and uses it as they see fit.

Post reply on HN