Live data from Hacker News

iOS 7 before and after screenshots

tapfame.com

141–150 of 165 posts

Re: iOS 7 before and after screenshots

#141
post #89

Whoa, a cell phone number was included in one of the screenshots? That can't be good. (Cobook Contacts) Also, the interface for Photo Investigator is horrible. It's really hard to read the buttons at the bottom!

The number is for the CEO of cobook. Lead by example I guess.

Re: iOS 7 before and after screenshots

#142
EVERYTHING beautiful is skeuomorphic. The page turn in iBooks, page curl in maps, cover flow, the shred animation in passbook, the date picker in iOS, rotating settings gear (when updating iOS), the Time Machine interface in OS X, photo borders and shadows in iWorks documents, etc.

This is not surprising, because our sense of beauty comes from the physical world.

So what is the problem with skeuomorphism?

Tech enthusiasts would like their phones to look like something from the future, not something from the past. But ordinary everyday people prefer for it to look like things they are already familiar with.

Tech enthusiasts worry that the skeuomorphism was getting totally out of hand, particularly where the UI metaphor started limiting functionality (e.g. an address database that's limited to what a Rolodex can do, rather than exploiting what is possible with a computer). But this is not really true. For example, iBooks has instant search, something only possible with a computer.

Some people say skeuomorphism looks tacky. This is partly true. Skeuomorphism is hard to do. When done poorly it does look tacky. But when done well it looks very beautiful.

By removing all skeuomorphism Apple is throwing the baby out with the bathwater.

Re: iOS 7 before and after screenshots

#144
post #53
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I noticed that too. Lots of the new apps have a distinctly "Android" feel to them, even to the point of Fancy having what looks clearly like an Android menu button (though not in the standard Android location). A fun flame war to start (i.e. let's please not) would be to argue whether this is due to app designers feeling an increasing need to target Android or whether it's because the truth is that iOS's "new look" s…

The simple truth probably is the company that made the app designed their Android version first and didn't bother to come up with a complete new app design for iOS, so they just kinda ported it. You can also find a lot of Android apps that seem to be directly ported from its iOS incarnations, instead of using native UI conventions.

I find this deliciously delightful after suffering the wrath of these stupid app developers historically on Android. I don't agree with it, certainly, but I feel some warped sense of justice.

Re: iOS 7 before and after screenshots

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I like them. The information is much more clear.

Really? Tell me how this is more clear: http://grab.by/qmAu I don't know which button state is worse, selected or unselected. I can't read either of them in the iOS7 version.

I think the new (iOS7) design is better simply because the transparent box on the non-selected buttons allow me to see more map.

Re: iOS 7 before and after screenshots

#147
post #53
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I noticed that too. Lots of the new apps have a distinctly "Android" feel to them, even to the point of Fancy having what looks clearly like an Android menu button (though not in the standard Android location). A fun flame war to start (i.e. let's please not) would be to argue whether this is due to app designers feeling an increasing need to target Android or whether it's because the truth is that iOS's "new look" s…

The simple truth probably is the company that made the app designed their Android version first and didn't bother to come up with a complete new app design for iOS, so they just kinda ported it. You can also find a lot of Android apps that seem to be directly ported from its iOS incarnations, instead of using native UI conventions.

which is idiotic.

had everyone put effort in browser integration like webos was doing, the end user would be much better served.

but lack of lock-in doesnt sell in the corporate world...

Re: iOS 7 before and after screenshots

#148
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I noticed that too. Lots of the new apps have a distinctly "Android" feel to them, even to the point of Fancy having what looks clearly like an Android menu button (though not in the standard Android location). A fun flame war to start (i.e. let's please not) would be to argue whether this is due to app designers feeling an increasing need to target Android or whether it's because the truth is that iOS's "new look" s…

The "three lines to represent a menu" metaphor has existed for years now. It just hasn't been as widely used until probably in the last year or so. I wouldn't use it to assume that iOS apps are being designed from Android apps or vice versa. You're just making baseless extrapolations.

I can't say it is baseless extrapolations. If you are hesitant to associate hamburger menu's to Android, the whole idea of iPhone revolutionizing mobile industry would be baseless extrapolations. Everything is built up on shoulders of its predecessors. Hamburger menu and side drawer have become an Android design standard at this point of time and there is no harm in saying that most iPhone apps will look like redesign of Android apps.

Re: iOS 7 before and after screenshots

#149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The "three lines to represent a menu" metaphor has existed for years now. It just hasn't been as widely used until probably in the last year or so. I wouldn't use it to assume that iOS apps are being designed from Android apps or vice versa. You're just making baseless extrapolations.

aka the "hamburger" button.

I know that it what it gets called... But it is seriously the worst name for it :/

Re: iOS 7 before and after screenshots

#150
In some ways iOS7 looks cleaner and more subtle but to me it is generally MUCH worse for understanding what to do (like when MS Office went away from menus and to the tool strip junk). The old version used blank space better, it was clear what elements could be clicked as buttons were clearly buttons, content was more separated from control, etc.

Some of the icons/fonts/colors are clearly improved but in general I think it’s a fail. And, to me, flat looks cheap.

Post reply on HN