Live data from Hacker News

GitHub Firewall Install (your own github)

fi.github.com

21–30 of 35 posts

Re: GitHub Firewall Install (your own github)

#21
post #8

I'm really excited by this, but I'd love to hear some guidance on pricing. Is this for hacker shops like mine, or for the IBMs of the world?

I think it's for the IBMs of the world, that won't allow 3rd party hosted services... most small companies are fine with it.

We're not an IBM, but tend to avoid solutions that won't readily integrate with our existing LDAP users and group-based access control, backup system, etc.

Re: GitHub Firewall Install (your own github)

#22
this is really cool, but I couldn't help but notice this quote:

“Killer apps makes or breaks any platform. With GitHub, I think the Git hub just scored one.” -DHH

Um. I know DHH is an important guy, but not only is that quote grammatically way out there, I don't think it makes any sense at all...

Re: GitHub Firewall Install (your own github)

#23

this is really cool, but I couldn't help but notice this quote: “Killer apps makes or breaks any platform. With GitHub, I think the Git hub just scored one.” -DHH Um. I know DHH is an important guy, but not only is that quote grammatically way out there, I don't think it makes any sense at all...

[this is how I interpreted it. makes perfect sense imho]

'Killer apps' make a platform. Lack of 'killer apps' break a platform. GitHub is Git community's (=hub) killer app.

Re: GitHub Firewall Install (your own github)

#25
post #2

The GitHub guys are just iterating and growing so fast. I'd hate to be SourceForge right about now (it seems to have caused the SF.net folks to wake up, though, as they've begun to improve at a very rapid clip). I ordinarily recommend folks not go the installable application route (even though our business is all installable based) if they can avoid it, but I think it definitely makes sense for GitHub. It's an area w…

SF woke up a bit around the time Google Code project hosting was released. But with GitHub and BitBucket kicking things up a notch, it's definitely a bad time to be SF. And despite all their changes, it still feels like a pain to use SF.net.

Re: GitHub Firewall Install (your own github)

#26
post #13

Here's our launch post explaining FI: http://github.com/blog/441-launch-github-firewall-install

Awesome job, PJ and team. I first heard about this at Startup Riot 2009 when Chris came to speak.

Although, my initial concern is how this is being spun to customers in terms of customization. One of my design clients is a SaaS vendor that had a large potential customer request an on-site deployment of their big product. Along with packaging up their software for a remote deployment, the customer was asking for all kinds of modifications to match up with their very particular needs. This was sort of spreading them thin on what they could work on for the customer and for the core product. So, my question is are you going to provide customization options for purchasers, or is the product just a rebuilt copy of whatever state the GitHub code is at? I'm a fan of what you guys have built, so I'd hate to see it suffer.

Re: GitHub Firewall Install (your own github)

#27

This is one of the main reasons that I'm not using Git at work, there hasn't been a super solid way to get the Github functionality on an internal network where it's 100% secure. This is a REALLY smart move for the guys at Github.

You can use Git without Github, you know.

Yees, but these folks aren't early adopters. A lot of the people here don't even use (or approve of) key based SSH logins =/

Re: GitHub Firewall Install (your own github)

#28
post #15

How do you guys do code obfuscation and allow your service to be packaged into a downloadable, well, package? One of my startups is thinking about doing something of the sort, for academic institutions to throw our software on their own servers.

I don't understand why you need obfuscation for this. With customers of this size, you can have them sign a contract that protects your IP. Price in what you think is the risk, and insist on a contract.

Re: GitHub Firewall Install (your own github)

#30
post #10

So roughly how much would this cost for a small team, say <10? I'm assuming far too much for me, since it's not visible anywhere, but I'm still curious :)

How much are you willing to pay? :) Seriously, though, it's probably priced beyond what most small teams could afford, but it's on a per-company basis which is why we're not posting prices.

GitHub:FI was really built with large customers in mind, places with tens to hundreds of developers bridled with restrictions that prevent them from hosting their code on GitHub.com.

There's no reason smaller companies can't use it, but for the time being we want to dedicate more attention and support to fewer well-paying customers.

We may offer a pricing model in the future that's more affordable for smaller teams, but I can't state emphatically enough that if your team doesn't have the type of restrictions mentioned earlier, you should absolutely be using GitHub.com.

Post reply on HN