Live data from Hacker News

Google Might Have Walked Into A Nestle Boycott Problem With Android KitKat

forbes.com

21–30 of 47 posts

Re: Google Might Have Walked Into A Nestle Boycott Problem With Android KitKat

#21

Google really didn't think this one through. I don't see how any possible marketing 'synergies' can overcome the vague confusion that some people will have when confronted with the word KitKat and its associated Nestle registered trademark and the very real opinions that Nestle does not behave ethically as a company. Maybe they couldn't think of anything else sweet that started with K but don't I think they've come t…

>Maybe they couldn't think of anything else sweet that started with K

Could have gone with Krackel, key lime pie, kumquat, or kandy korn, and that's without going anywhere exotic.

Re: Google Might Have Walked Into A Nestle Boycott Problem With Android KitKat

#23
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why? It's an opinion piece. Thus, it expresses the opinions of the author. You can see more, in a similar style, on their blog: http://timworstall.com/

Just wondering, why do you use 'their' when it's quite obvious that it's a man?

Singular their has a long established use.

(http://crossmyt.com/hc/linghebr/austheir.html)

Re: Google Might Have Walked Into A Nestle Boycott Problem With Android KitKat

#25
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why? It's an opinion piece. Thus, it expresses the opinions of the author. You can see more, in a similar style, on their blog: http://timworstall.com/

Just wondering, why do you use 'their' when it's quite obvious that it's a man?

Probably for the same reason you use 'it' when it's quite obvious he's a 'he', it's a more convenient and more colloquial way of phrasing something.

*EDIT: for tone & clarity

Re: Google Might Have Walked Into A Nestle Boycott Problem With Android KitKat

#26
post #23
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just wondering, why do you use 'their' when it's quite obvious that it's a man?

Singular their has a long established use. ( http://crossmyt.com/hc/linghebr/austheir.html )

Going by that page, AndrewDucker's usage of the singular their is incorrect.

Re: Google Might Have Walked Into A Nestle Boycott Problem With Android KitKat

#27
post #16

As I pointed out in the previous discussion, your smartphone, whatever the brand, almost certainly has metals mined or processed by children in dangerous and unhealthy work environments. That has a much bigger impact on child health than some tenuous three degrees of separation link of a marketing partnership.

Yeah...seriously. I expect some people will take offense to this, but here it goes:

So what? If this contrived issue that Google may face is now considered a serious matter, then I guess everything is off limits.

"Hey Tom, what should we name our new operating system?"

"I don't know, how about 'daring diamond' - it's got alliteration, and everybody loves diamonds."

"Mmmm...nope, sorry, that whole blood diamonds thing...don't want to risk that!"

Google isn't making a statement supporting Nestle's practices in other countries. They're not saying people are silly for boycotting the product. This is really just hypersensitive.

I'm not saying you shouldn't boycott Nestle. But KitKat is a fantastic name. It's not a loaded word. If you stopped people on the street and asked them what they thought about it, they'd probably say, "Hey, those give me a break commercials?" not "Hey, I boycott Nestle! Screw those bastards."

It's a cute name that has alliteration and is well known. I mean...come on. Criticize Google for something substantial, not because they named an operating system after a delicious chocolate treat marginally related to some controversy. If you're going to criticize Android, go the whole hog and do it with something that actually matters.

Re: Google Might Have Walked Into A Nestle Boycott Problem With Android KitKat

#28
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just wondering, why do you use 'their' when it's quite obvious that it's a man?

Probably for the same reason you use 'it' when it's quite obvious he's a 'he', it's a more convenient and more colloquial way of phrasing something. *EDIT: for tone & clarity

Not sure what you mean, referring to a person as 'it' is almost universally offensive, at least in the US.

Re: Google Might Have Walked Into A Nestle Boycott Problem With Android KitKat

#29

It's worth also remembering that the Nestlé CEO declared that OGM food is healthy, water is not a human right and we should all work more, not less: http://youtu.be/SEFL8ElXHaU

Err, no he didn't. Did you actually look at the link you posted? Or did you just look at the title, and hope nobody would watch it?

First, he claimed that in 15 years of eating GM food in the US, there haven't been any reported illness. That's not an opinion, that's a fact.

Now, you might think there could be issues down the track, sure - and that may be your informed medical opinion.

But nothing he stated is actually false.

And just to forestall you, he also claimed that he personally thinks this obsession with organic everything is bad - sure, you might disagree with him, but he's entitled to his opinion, and it's hardly that controversial an opinion, to be honest.

Also, organic doesn't mean "all natural and the way we did it 4000 years ago". In fact, it's probably very different to what most people think:

http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=organic-sti...

And this much vaunted water claim?

He said that water should have a value, or price on it, and that for those who didn't have access to it, we should take steps to help them.

I for one think that people in developed countries are terribly wasteful fresh water (among other things) - and it should definitely have a price, since it's a limited resource, and if you use it up, somebody else doesn't get it.

The fact that you and I are using computers to type this probably makes us better off than a large proportion of the world.

How about we stop all this silly hypocritical DOWN WITH THE EVIL CORPORATIONS! muck, and I don't know, start using that energy to something like World Vision, or CharityWater? (https://www.charitywater.org/donate/)

Re: Google Might Have Walked Into A Nestle Boycott Problem With Android KitKat

#30

This seems like something a competent editor would have removed from the post before it went up: "We could simply dismiss this Nestle boycott as the wibblings of a bunch of hypersensitive hippies. Which is pretty much how I view it myself for whatever little my personal opinion is worth."

Overall this is a rather poorly written article, with little or no meaningful information in it.

I think the odds that this Nestle boycott (that I've never heard of or noticed before) would transfer to Android KitKat devices are pretty slim. And even if it did, I think it would be barely noticeable in the sales of Android devices.

Post reply on HN