Live data from Hacker News

Facebook deletes Social Fixer page, blocks page admins

socialfixer.com

11–20 of 92 posts

Re: Facebook deletes Social Fixer page, blocks page admins

#11
post #4

It is also against Facebook TOS to create or use browser extensions to alter the Facebook experience. This has been the rule for many years. The fact that this page and extension did not get banned sooner is the real story.

They can write that in their terms & conditions all they like, but it doesn't make it legal or enforceable.

Apparently it does make it enforceable as they removed his page. Unfortunately when you're on someones platform you're at their mercy, they can delete your page for some minor infraction and you've got very little recourse.

Re: Facebook deletes Social Fixer page, blocks page admins

#12
This is why I'm so scared / hesitant to build something that depends entirely or mostly on a third party company for its success or even ability to exist. Businesses that depend on Facebook or Twitter or Apple's App Store or even Meetup are scary. I have businesses that depend on one or more of these. And I'm scared. I'm doing my best to extricate myself from this dependency and build substantial visibility elsewhere where I can.

Re: Facebook deletes Social Fixer page, blocks page admins

#13
post #4

It is also against Facebook TOS to create or use browser extensions to alter the Facebook experience. This has been the rule for many years. The fact that this page and extension did not get banned sooner is the real story.

They can write that in their terms & conditions all they like, but it doesn't make it legal or enforceable.

If you use their website, especially if you build something on it, then you need to live by their rules.

Re: Facebook deletes Social Fixer page, blocks page admins

#14

"my Page had 338,050 Likes, my Support Group had 13,360 members, and my Interest List had 1.47 Million followers. But all of that work was wiped out in an instant when Facebook decided to shut it down without notice." "Not only did they remove the page, but they also blocked my personal account from posting anything for 12 hours (I can’t even Like anything). They also did the same for anyone who was an Administrator…

It is against the Facebook TOS, unfortunately shouldn't we be telling him "don't violate Facebook's TOS without expecting repercussions?"

The TOS is not above criticism or complaint, and I for one am tired of people being shouted down because they dared take issue with draconian policies.

Re: Facebook deletes Social Fixer page, blocks page admins

#15
post #5
post #3

From the FAQ: "Can Social Fixer hide the Sponsored ads? Yes, just click on the "X" in the upper right of the box, and all boxes with the same title will be hidden every time you load a page." There is a lesson here somewhere...

Does that mean https://www.facebook.com/adblockplus is next?

AdBlock Plus doesn't block Facebook ads for me. Am I using it wrong?

Re: Facebook deletes Social Fixer page, blocks page admins

#18
post #4

It is also against Facebook TOS to create or use browser extensions to alter the Facebook experience. This has been the rule for many years. The fact that this page and extension did not get banned sooner is the real story.

They can write that in their terms & conditions all they like, but it doesn't make it legal or enforceable.

How would it be illegal to remove pages from their own platform that alter Facebook's appearance? As far as enforceability, that seems demonstrably false based on this post.

Re: Facebook deletes Social Fixer page, blocks page admins

#19
This has been Facebook's MO for almost 5 years now. What Social Fixer was doing in particular is among a class of applications that Facebook has always deleted or banned as soon as they noticed them. I've had applications with 5-10MM MAU deleted without warning and know dozens of folks with similar stories.

That's life developing for Facebook. Don't be under any illusions if you decide to play in their sandbox.

Re: Facebook deletes Social Fixer page, blocks page admins

#20
One of the most important lessons I've learned during the growing-up phase of my being an entrepreneur -- and one of the first things I'm doing with my next startup -- is putting together a list of "doomsday scenarios" right off the bat.

What are the _single_ actions / events / scenarios that could kill your business overnight?

I emphasize single because every business is going to have the potential for a series of unforeseen events kill them (i.e. Microsoft would probably not have seen 'Apple releases a phone' as a business/Balmer-killer), but every business should be keenly aware of the single-points-of-failure (SPoF).

It seems obvious, but so many folks either willfully ignore or choose to pretend that SPoF don't exist or rationalize the scenario away.

Examples:

* You run on AWS in a single availability zone, and that availability zone goes down for a week ("The cloud is super reliable. Amazon won't go down.")

* Your CTO is the only person on the company who knows the product, and he quits overnight / gets injured / becomes incapacitated. ("He's my partner. He'd never abandon the business. We're in this together.")

* You rely solely on Facebook / Twitter / Apple App Store and are at the mercy of their changes in policy ("Oh Facebook would never just shut us down.")

* You're built solely on the Foursquare Places API. ("Foursquare won't just kill all the companies that rely on their API...right?")

Etc. etc. etc.

Now, this isn't saying that you should be paralyzed by the potential for SPoFs to hurt your business -- it may make sense to proceed even with them around (i.e. lots of people have made a lot of money building FB apps).

But you MUST be aware of what they are, and you MUST have a plan in place to handle the continuation of the business if one of them comes true.

Post reply on HN