Live data from Hacker News

AT&T gives DEA 26 years of phone call records to wage war on drugs

arstechnica.com

1–10 of 211 posts

Re: AT&T gives DEA 26 years of phone call records to wage war on drugs

#4
post #3

Interesting. At first glance, this feels wrong, but thinking about it more, the only significant issue I really have with it is that it seems strange for the DEA to be allowed to issue its own warrants.

...and for there to be a war on drugs in the first place. Eliminate the fundamentals, and there should be no issues at all, really.

Re: AT&T gives DEA 26 years of phone call records to wage war on drugs

#6
post #3

Interesting. At first glance, this feels wrong, but thinking about it more, the only significant issue I really have with it is that it seems strange for the DEA to be allowed to issue its own warrants.

Somehow I doubt the database detailing the history of subpoenas is as accurate as the one containing all the phone records.

Is there anything like the FISA court for these subpoenas? I couldn't find any kind of checks on their power.

Re: AT&T gives DEA 26 years of phone call records to wage war on drugs

#8
Interesting to note here is that the ATT _gave_ those records "on its own", versus being subpoena via DEA by a judge, something that 99% of judges in their sound mind would have never ever ever agreed on, even in today's world.

I had a hard time believing that ATT would have done something like this out of their own free will, as they would have never done anything that could undermine their sales and bottom line (potentially) so severely.

I put "on its own" in quotes because knowing the way Government thugs are conducting themselves, most likely the ATT had been heavily blackmailed under the table this or another way and at some point they have given up (Wikipedia: tyranny). Don't be surprised if in couple of years from now the administration will change, and the management of ATT will change, and then you will see some tiny PR-lawsuit surfacing that yes indeed ATT were pushed by DEA and now they are "suing".

Re: AT&T gives DEA 26 years of phone call records to wage war on drugs

#10
post #4
post #3

Interesting. At first glance, this feels wrong, but thinking about it more, the only significant issue I really have with it is that it seems strange for the DEA to be allowed to issue its own warrants.

...and for there to be a war on drugs in the first place. Eliminate the fundamentals, and there should be no issues at all, really.

Then there would be a war on piracy. How would you like it if they kept 20 years of your downloading habits? Do you think that in 20 years time they could find something to incriminate you?

And that's why it's so wrong to keep data for so long, and actually be able to use it.

Post reply on HN