Live data from Hacker News

Bing: Microsoft Prepares For War With A Revamped Search Engine (Screenshots)

techcrunch.com

11–20 of 25 posts

Re: Bing: Microsoft Prepares For War With A Revamped Search Engine (Screenshots)

#11
post #7

Less is more. Microsoft just doesn't seem to get that. This interface looks like a convoluted piece of crap that changes based on what I search on. No thanks.

It looks like it will be the Zune of search engines.

TEH WOW STARTS NAO GUISE LOL

Re: Bing: Microsoft Prepares For War With A Revamped Search Engine (Screenshots)

#13
Why not wrap these new features into "Live", it seems like they are also going to be competing with themselves.

The tag line is horrible: "When it comes to decisions that matter, Bing & Decide." I prefer the name "Live", since it seems more relevant.

Re: Bing: Microsoft Prepares For War With A Revamped Search Engine (Screenshots)

#14
post #7

Less is more. Microsoft just doesn't seem to get that. This interface looks like a convoluted piece of crap that changes based on what I search on. No thanks.

Plus, everyone knows that the first step in great UI development is covering an application's background in stock photos.

Re: Bing: Microsoft Prepares For War With A Revamped Search Engine (Screenshots)

#15
post #2

I may be in the minority, but I think this is exciting. We need more competition in search. I'm not sure if Microsoft is the right company for the job, but I'm glad they finally seem to be taking search seriously. I'm also glad they went with Bing and not Sift, as we bought BingSEO.com recently. ;)

I like the competition but I also want Microsoft to lose.

The thing about Google is that it is a very intelligent but very minimal interface to the whole Internet itself. This thing, the whole Internet, has been expanding faster than any "portal" or other kind of "walled garden" could. I hope this continues, for the variety involved but also for the freedom - knowing that no entity (even Google) will be able to sweep the results away.

When Google is just providing access to something others can give access to as well, it keeps them somewhat honest even if they are 90% dominant. When Google or Microsoft or Wolfram or anyone both hosts content and provides the interface, it makes censorship much easier. Even Google is moving more towards doing combining hosting and search through owning Youtube but Google still looks like least likely to create a "wall garden".

Re: Bing: Microsoft Prepares For War With A Revamped Search Engine (Screenshots)

#16

Why not wrap these new features into "Live", it seems like they are also going to be competing with themselves. The tag line is horrible: "When it comes to decisions that matter, Bing & Decide." I prefer the name "Live", since it seems more relevant.

Live is tough to use as a verb, and they use Live for a number of other products (e.g. Xbox Live, Windows Live, MSN Live Spaces). As a result they have to describe the search as Live Search, and they don't own LiveSearch.com.

So even though live.com is an awesome domain it wasn't going to work for their search engine.

Re: Bing: Microsoft Prepares For War With A Revamped Search Engine (Screenshots)

#19

It's different and I like the thesis behind it: "decision engine". A good way to understand search is to see how people make the decisions to go about what they're searching for. Keyword they start out with, its variants, the final answer/result, and what form of search they should be using. travel? local? image? etc. It's all going to come down to execution though (Cliche, but relevant here more than ever). If it su…

With something like this, you don't want to overtly advertise. You want word of mouth to develop. I think the advertisement will sometimes work against them. I know I'm wary of ads for search -- most things advertised for search have been a disappointment to me.

Re: Bing: Microsoft Prepares For War With A Revamped Search Engine (Screenshots)

#20
post #14
post #7

Less is more. Microsoft just doesn't seem to get that. This interface looks like a convoluted piece of crap that changes based on what I search on. No thanks.

Plus, everyone knows that the first step in great UI development is covering an application's background in stock photos.

I don't know. I quite like the background photos on the current Live.com. It's a welcome change from the boring white pages.

I do agree that the results interface looks cluttered. Granted, they are trying to present a lot of information, but they should find a way to simplify it. I suspect they'll change it up in time and after a real world launch.

Post reply on HN