Live data from Hacker News

I challenge you to remove the gray ad using Adblock

0x1b.pw

21–30 of 46 posts

Re: I challenge you to remove the gray ad using Adblock

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Updated, try again ;)

Sorry, you don't get to work around successes every time someone posts one in order to claim that nobody can do it. The GP did it, the challenge has been won.

He's not denying that the challenge was met, he's setting another challenge on top of that. It's like reverse Ruby Koans. You don't complete the first challenge then declare your learning done, the challenge keeps building.

Re: I challenge you to remove the gray ad using Adblock

#22

Is Adblock a requirement? Opera has built-in element blocking: I clicked "Block elements", clicked the "ad", clicked "Done," and ... done :)

Hm, tried it with Opera and it is indeed blocking it. However, the image still shows when the page is reloaded. So eh, kinda works.

Interesting...it indeed shows up on reload.

Re: I challenge you to remove the gray ad using Adblock

#23
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sorry, you don't get to work around successes every time someone posts one in order to claim that nobody can do it. The GP did it, the challenge has been won.

You don't get a prize, he's working WITH HN on an experiment.

I know you don't get a prize, but a challenge is one specific thing. This is a new challenge now.

Re: I challenge you to remove the gray ad using Adblock

#24

This is a pointless challenge, because it has none of the characteristics of an actual ad. For tracking, security, and analytics reasons, ad providers almost always originate ads from a separate domain than the content provider's.

Moreover, if the gray ad were representative of the state of advertising on the internet, I highly suspect that less people would spend too much effort in blocking advertisements.

My ideal ad-blocking solution turns the popover, popunder, rollover-expanding, shouting at the top of their heads to get your attention advertisements into something as innocuous as that 'nasty' gray ad. I don't have a problem trading my eyeballs for a product, but I do have a problem when your ad takes over my browser, makes the page unusable, or is generally a pain in the ass.

Of course, my fix there isn't to use an adblocker, it's just to block the site altogether.

Post reply on HN