Live data from Hacker News

Adblock buying ads to advertise Adblock

thenextweb.com

21–30 of 85 posts

Re: Adblock buying ads to advertise Adblock

#21
post #15
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The content provider also paying for the bandwidth.

So? Perhaps they would also like to block the ads at the server side, and save themselves the bill? But more seriously, I don't care about their bills. They're delivering HTML over an open network connection - what I do with that HTML is entirely up to me. If they don't like that there's nothing they can do about it.

Greetings,

> I don't care about their bills

[sarcasm] How farsighted. Oh how very farsighted. [sarcasm off]

So you really do not care about their service being shut down, because it could not pay for itself? I mean, people working there to produce content, hardware to run the service, bandwidth, and so on...

Re: Adblock buying ads to advertise Adblock

#22
post #12
post #11

I'd understand the use of adblock that only blocks annoying ads, like pop-ups or animation / sound. But why would sane person block regular ads?

Because I'm paying for the bandwidth, and because I'm there for the content, not the adverts, and because I can - it's my computer, I can decide what it does.

It's not your site, you cannot decide what it does. I mean really, blocking regular ads won't get us anywhere.

It's like receiving free news every morning, but you have ordered a kid who delivers them to cut out ads.

Re: Adblock buying ads to advertise Adblock

#23
post #22
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because I'm paying for the bandwidth, and because I'm there for the content, not the adverts, and because I can - it's my computer, I can decide what it does.

It's not your site, you cannot decide what it does. I mean really, blocking regular ads won't get us anywhere. It's like receiving free news every morning, but you have ordered a kid who delivers them to cut out ads.

That's actually completely fine. You're allowed to do that.

Personally I use the free newspapers they unwarrantedly deliver to my house as a firestarter.

Re: Adblock buying ads to advertise Adblock

#24
post #13

How likely would advertisers be to refuse to allow the Adblock ads? I don't really have a problem with ads on websites, experienced users can easily block them, but I see no problem with providing ads for a free service. Many organizations only have three methods to generate revenue, either show advertisements, have paid memberships, or take donations. Google shows advertisements, Apple has paid memberships, Wikipedi…

"Plus if Adblock is actually successful and the online advertising industry collapses, then they will be putting themselves out of business." Even worse. Some of these companies (not adblock) are asking protection money from big advertisers to be whitelisted. Mafia style.

A free service putting itself out of business...

Can someone explain to me how that works?

Re: Adblock buying ads to advertise Adblock

#25
post #20
post #13

How likely would advertisers be to refuse to allow the Adblock ads? I don't really have a problem with ads on websites, experienced users can easily block them, but I see no problem with providing ads for a free service. Many organizations only have three methods to generate revenue, either show advertisements, have paid memberships, or take donations. Google shows advertisements, Apple has paid memberships, Wikipedi…

I completely agree. If I could reinvent adblock I would create it so only false ads would have been blocked. By that I mean false download buttons, fake iphone winnings, insert your phone number for iq test, etc...

I wouldn't use your adblock, I want all ads to be blocked.

Re: Adblock buying ads to advertise Adblock

#27
post #22
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because I'm paying for the bandwidth, and because I'm there for the content, not the adverts, and because I can - it's my computer, I can decide what it does.

It's not your site, you cannot decide what it does. I mean really, blocking regular ads won't get us anywhere. It's like receiving free news every morning, but you have ordered a kid who delivers them to cut out ads.

"It's like receiving free news every morning, but you have ordered a kid who delivers them to cut out ads."

What's wrong with that? What laws is that breaking? I'm not even sure that's breaking any social contract.

Re: Adblock buying ads to advertise Adblock

#28
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So? Perhaps they would also like to block the ads at the server side, and save themselves the bill? But more seriously, I don't care about their bills. They're delivering HTML over an open network connection - what I do with that HTML is entirely up to me. If they don't like that there's nothing they can do about it.

Greetings, > I don't care about their bills [sarcasm] How farsighted. Oh how very farsighted. [sarcasm off] So you really do not care about their service being shut down, because it could not pay for itself? I mean, people working there to produce content, hardware to run the service, bandwidth, and so on...

I really don't care. I'm just not going to look at any adverts.

Re: Adblock buying ads to advertise Adblock

#29
I don't understand how ad-blocking is even legal. It's like stealing - stealing content for free, IMHO there's no difference between stealing MP3s and news or any other content. There's some kind of user agreement between websites and its users - "you can use our site for free, but you have to watch the ads". Adblock violates this agreement. The people responsible for this should be in prison, they're thieves. And I'm pretty sure the time will come they will.

Re: Adblock buying ads to advertise Adblock

#30
post #20
post #13

How likely would advertisers be to refuse to allow the Adblock ads? I don't really have a problem with ads on websites, experienced users can easily block them, but I see no problem with providing ads for a free service. Many organizations only have three methods to generate revenue, either show advertisements, have paid memberships, or take donations. Google shows advertisements, Apple has paid memberships, Wikipedi…

I completely agree. If I could reinvent adblock I would create it so only false ads would have been blocked. By that I mean false download buttons, fake iphone winnings, insert your phone number for iq test, etc...

That's not really the demand, except for a relatively small set of people who are savvy to the reasons why advertising exists and benefits big companies. It wouldn't be nearly as successful.
Post reply on HN