Live data from Hacker News

Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 141 posts

Re: Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

#41
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can't downvote submissions and TC is great at linkbait headlines, which get upvoted before people read the actual post. That's the problem.

You can flag submissions, you can learn not to up-mod something before you actually read it, and you always just not click on the link! There's a parallel here with language choice. Some languages let you shoot yourself in the foot, and others try desperately to protect you. Newbies might need and benefit from the protection, power users often get frustrated at being prevented from doing things. My principle is: when…

> you can learn not to up-mod something before you actually read it

Others would need to learn that.

Re: Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

#42

A ban would allow no incentive for them to change their behavior. As it is, the up/down voting gives them feedback on an post-by-post basis as to what matters to HNers. [ Just in case they care. ] In regard to one post: Let's not "protect" noobs from "bad info" - except to the extent that we noobs can see what the overall HN population thinks of value of specific articles. That is the power of what HN has to offer to…

HN's total traffic is 1/12th of TechCrunch's. I doubt HN visitors click on many ads, either. So I don't think our opinion will strongly affect TC's editorial policy. I'm sure their style is a very concious decision.

Re: Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

#46
post #34
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, screening is OK, but banning the whole site just because you don't like them is nonsense.

Read the OP. This isn't about "Not liking TC", it's about the quality of journalism they have been displaying lately.

I can say that statements in the poll definition are very arguable, and can be easily dictated by the author's personal attitude. (You say - "Strong negative bias" and would qualify this as a "Journalist investigation").

Re: Poll: Should we ban TechCrunch?

#49
We shouldn't be biased. Techcrunch links are sometimes crap, sometimes good. So completely banning wouldn't do any good.

Let's solve it the HN way. Just don't up vote what you don't like. OK, you say, "I don't, but they get votes somehow". That, my friend, is _probably_ because community is polluted.

Post reply on HN