Live data from Hacker News

You Might Have an Invisible Facebook Account Even if You Never Signed Up

groovypost.com

41–50 of 182 posts

Re: You Might Have an Invisible Facebook Account Even if You Never Signed Up

#41
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, that's how modern privacy invasion works. After Facebook scanned Jane's phonebook, and made the invites Jane asked, Facebook should have deleted your phone number.

You are going to be in for a real shock if you ever see a phone book. Pages upon pages of names matched with phone numbers!

"Recording the relationship" is the privacy invasion.

Re: You Might Have an Invisible Facebook Account Even if You Never Signed Up

#42
The bigger picture is in terms of Social Network Analysis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_network_analysis

and the fact that companies are able to figure out lots of stuff about you even though you never consented to being a part of their service.

Hopefully the next "leak" will be about one of these big companies and what they do with your information.

Re: You Might Have an Invisible Facebook Account Even if You Never Signed Up

#43
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The profile also probably contains a list of all the Facebook users who had you in their contact lists, and all the photos that you were tagged in. Since such information would get updated every time a Facebook user uploaded your contact information or tagged you, I'd say this qualifies as Facebook actively keeping tabs on you.

How do you tag someone if they don't have a Facebook account? AFAIK it's not possible to tag someone with an email address or telephone number? Certainly you can "tag" someone if they are not on Facebook and not in your friends (of friends) list, but it is then just tagged as text, not associated with an account... maybe I missed an option somewhere...

>it is then just tagged as text, not associated with an account...

Not associated with a non-shadow account.

Re: You Might Have an Invisible Facebook Account Even if You Never Signed Up

#44
last year, i - without having a facebook account - tried to get the data facebook might have stored about me through the corresponding EU privacy protection laws. all i got was the answer that they do not compile custom data exports upon request anymore and that i would have login into my facebook account [sic] to any data through some data downloading service...

now i wonder if i should have pestered a bit more, i.e. by demanding the release of the possible stored data (which definitely exists seeing the "please join"-spam from some years ago) in writing through snail mail. anyone had any success with that?

Re: You Might Have an Invisible Facebook Account Even if You Never Signed Up

#45
None of this is unexpected.

If you were making exactly the same service, you would come up with exactly the same evil outcomes.

"Hey, we can upload every contact list in the world with no consent then cluster and cross reference every entry behind the scenes!" Sounds fun to me, especially if you have no sense of societal ethics or boundaries (quintuply so if you firmly believe you're changing the world and everybody else only advances at the pace of your unique genius).

Imagine the graph the NSA can construct about how people are connected throughout the world. facebook probably has close to exactly the same information based solely on voluntary information coughed up by Social Internet Morons. People aren't trained to think about data and relations and how everything can be sewn together, and that puts them at a gross disadvantage when interacting with global megacorps these days.

Re: You Might Have an Invisible Facebook Account Even if You Never Signed Up

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are going to be in for a real shock if you ever see a phone book. Pages upon pages of names matched with phone numbers!

It's a relatively new idea, the modern expectation of 'privacy', and one that's completely out of touch with reality. It's only within the past hundred years that most people did not know everyone in their town - Even in cities, you probably shopped at a small set of stores and were known by name by the clerks. Technology has caught up, and now it's possible for shopkeeps to know your name again.

Technology has caught up, and now it's possible for shopkeeps to know your name again.

And people you don't even know from nowhere near where you live, and who definitely don't have your best interests at heart (remind me, why exactly is this data being collected?). Even with the "local" knowledge you espouse, I say privacy is necessary. Until society can put aside it's childish prejudices (say, against non-heteronormative sexuality), then privacy will be necessary. As many noted thinkers have seen fit to enshrine (eg, the US constitution).

Re: You Might Have an Invisible Facebook Account Even if You Never Signed Up

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Good thing deleting the pre-installed Facebook application (if it's ever been used at all it was inadvertently) off of my Android phone is quick and easy, and doesn't require root access! EDIT: This is why we need sarcasm tags. No, I have not actually been able to remove my Facebook application.

How? Sony Ericsson Xperia Arc S, ICS, locked to my carrier, unrootable. I've been wanting to get rid of it ever since the phone started running out of space all the time, app info gives no option to remove it. Is this a case of my manufacturer/carrier are more annoying than yours, or am I really missing something?

I was able to root my Arc S (but UK model/unlocked). I seem to recall using this method, but would need look on my PC for the files i used to verify... http://theunlockr.com/2012/10/09/how-to-root-the-sony-xperia...

Re: You Might Have an Invisible Facebook Account Even if You Never Signed Up

#48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are going to be in for a real shock if you ever see a phone book. Pages upon pages of names matched with phone numbers!

It's a relatively new idea, the modern expectation of 'privacy', and one that's completely out of touch with reality. It's only within the past hundred years that most people did not know everyone in their town - Even in cities, you probably shopped at a small set of stores and were known by name by the clerks. Technology has caught up, and now it's possible for shopkeeps to know your name again.

I'm still known by the clerks of the stores in my neighborhood. That's completely orthogonal to this.

The reason this type of discussion of privacy wasn't being had 30 years ago is because 99.9% of the things we did 30 years ago were private, outside of getting arrested as an adult and, eventually, drivers' license info. If I didn't want to be recognized while buying birth control or hemorrhoid medication, I would just have to go to a store that I didn't usually go to.

Also, of course, 1890: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Right_to_Privacy_%28articl...

Re: You Might Have an Invisible Facebook Account Even if You Never Signed Up

#49

The main invasion of privacy here is your friend(s) agreeing to give Facebook (a 3rd party) your information without asking or informing you. This is analogous to Facebook giving the government (a 3rd party) your information without asking or informing you.

i brought this up when my family using the "family tree" app a few years ago. they kept marking their familial relations online for all to see, for free and in great detail.

needless to say, i was met with blank stares when i brought this up.

Re: You Might Have an Invisible Facebook Account Even if You Never Signed Up

#50
post #2

When you install the Facebook app on your phone it requires permission to read your contacts, call log, location, accounts, and application data. Is this true?

Even better, it updates your contact book email addresses to facebook domain ones.

They had to do that for national security purposes, and you know, the children.

And yeah, that was very sad. http://news.cnet.com/8301-1023_3-57464415-93/facebook-e-mail...

I never sync Facebook/my contacts, but I do wonder if they steal this info anyway... most likely is my guess, but that's just me being a cynic.

Post reply on HN