Live data from Hacker News

This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories

fastcolabs.com

21–30 of 39 posts

Re: This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories

#21
post #18

How exactly do they track if people actually read the entire article? Merely based on time?

Google Analytics can track pages and average time spent on page. It can even track visitors flow. Everyone should get an analytics account and see the insane amount of things that Google can track for YOU, for FREE with just three lines of extra code on your page.

It ONLY tracks the latter if they click on another page. A huge difference.

Re: This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories

#22
post #17

The site appears to have Google Analytics placed multiple times into its source code. This messes up tracking and artificially dramatically drops bounce rates. In my experience working with content sites, the real bounce rate reduction you see in moving from shorter articles to longer ones is closer to 5% or so - from, say, 77% to 72%. Still dramatic, but not nearly as dramatic as the drop you'll get by double-insert…

Are you saying that as a hypothesis? Is there a link you can point us to where the code is inserted multiple times?

Re: This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories

#23

How exactly do they track if people actually read the entire article? Merely based on time?

There are lots of ways of structuring the code, but usually by checking scrolldepth.

If you want to add this to your own site, checkout jQuery ScrollDepth: https://github.com/robflaherty/jquery-scrolldepth

Re: This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories

#24
post #17

The site appears to have Google Analytics placed multiple times into its source code. This messes up tracking and artificially dramatically drops bounce rates. In my experience working with content sites, the real bounce rate reduction you see in moving from shorter articles to longer ones is closer to 5% or so - from, say, 77% to 72%. Still dramatic, but not nearly as dramatic as the drop you'll get by double-insert…

I bet their automated system is re-inserting GA code every time it updates their stub. It probably copies the entire previous stub, GA code and all, then publishes that plus updates and fresh GA code.

From the article:

Stub stories work like this: You write the first installment like any other story. But when more news breaks, you go back to the article, insert an update at the top, and change the headline and subheadline to reflect the update. Our system updates the story "slug" when the headline changes--check the URL of this story, and you'll see words from the headline in the URL: /this-is-what-happens-when-publishers-invest-in-long-stories. But the number preceding the slug--on this article, it's 3009577--is a unique node ID which never changes. So essentially, every time we update an article, we get a fresh URL with a fresh headline, but pointing back to the same (newly updated) article.

We can check this by checking older stubs.

Edit: on checking the page source, I only see GA in there 2x - once to call a GA API from google-analytics.com, and once more to (I think) load ga.js from google-analytics.com. How many times do you see that page calling GA?

Re: This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories

#25
Even assuming the analytics are correct, what is the value in driving down bounce rate? Lower bounce rate doesn't inherently mean more revenue.

I can, of course, use my imagination. But I am more interested in reading why a lower bounce rate is the future for media revenue. The quote near the end from Vox CEO is the best part of the article, but even it doesn't make the bounce = revenue connection explicit.

I will also add that, if those analytics are correct, that is a crazy-low bounce rate. A 50-60% bounce rate seems super strong to me. Dipping well below 50% seems unlikely for any site with significant traffic coming from disparate sources.

Re: This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories

#26
post #18

How exactly do they track if people actually read the entire article? Merely based on time?

Google Analytics can track pages and average time spent on page. It can even track visitors flow. Everyone should get an analytics account and see the insane amount of things that Google can track for YOU, for FREE with just three lines of extra code on your page.

I actively block GA for that reason.

Re: This Is What Happens When Publishers Invest In Long Stories

#27
post #17

The site appears to have Google Analytics placed multiple times into its source code. This messes up tracking and artificially dramatically drops bounce rates. In my experience working with content sites, the real bounce rate reduction you see in moving from shorter articles to longer ones is closer to 5% or so - from, say, 77% to 72%. Still dramatic, but not nearly as dramatic as the drop you'll get by double-insert…

I'm not seeing multiple inserts per page, and I checked their 'stub' pages as well. They only have GA in the head.
Post reply on HN