Live data from Hacker News

Video reveals NYC subway ride 108 years ago from Union Square to Grand Central

nydailynews.com

41–48 of 48 posts

Re: Video reveals NYC subway ride 108 years ago from Union Square to Grand Central

#42
post #19
post #6

Reminds me of this video: http://www.wimp.com/sanfrancisco/ -- uninterrupted San Francisco footage from 1905. Very surreal, extremely captivating.

Wow this is amazing.. they used to have emergent / "chaotic" traffic patterns back then in the west, the likes of which you only find in (much of) Asia, Africa or India these days. And how agile, vivid and alert most everyone is in the streets! Quite remarkable -- truly people were a different breed back then, for better or worse.

Notice no traffic lights, stop signs! Also note the conspicuous absence of women in this video and also car steering wheels on the right! In fact, I'm surprised there are so many cars on the road in 1905!

Re: Video reveals NYC subway ride 108 years ago from Union Square to Grand Central

#44
post #24

Reminds me more of the London tube stations than any of the NYC subway stations of today, likely due to a combination of respect and lack of bodily waste/trash. I ride the NYC subway every day and am always surprised at how poorly the stations are treated. People throw wrappers on the tracks so calmly and confidently as if they were designated to collect waste. Puddles of urine are not uncommonly found. It baffles me…

New York in general is just dirty. It's a place to visit, not to live in.

[deleted]

Re: Video reveals NYC subway ride 108 years ago from Union Square to Grand Central

#45
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

New York in general is just dirty. It's a place to visit, not to live in.

Reality is dirty. I love it here in NYC.

No, reality in NYC is dirty. The rest of the country isn't. It's always amazed me how New Yorkers think their city of 8 million defines a country of 330 million.

Re: Video reveals NYC subway ride 108 years ago from Union Square to Grand Central

#46
post #42
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wow this is amazing.. they used to have emergent / "chaotic" traffic patterns back then in the west, the likes of which you only find in (much of) Asia, Africa or India these days. And how agile, vivid and alert most everyone is in the streets! Quite remarkable -- truly people were a different breed back then, for better or worse.

Notice no traffic lights, stop signs! Also note the conspicuous absence of women in this video and also car steering wheels on the right! In fact, I'm surprised there are so many cars on the road in 1905!

There are women in the video, although not as many as there are men. For example, you can see two women at the 35 second mark at the right side of the screen, and another near the left side of the screen at the 1:35 mark. There are more, but these are just two that show them clearly in the foreground.

Re: Video reveals NYC subway ride 108 years ago from Union Square to Grand Central

#47
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Reality is dirty. I love it here in NYC.

No, reality in NYC is dirty. The rest of the country isn't. It's always amazed me how New Yorkers think their city of 8 million defines a country of 330 million.

It doesn't at all define america, but the rest of the country is literally built on dirt. May as well embrace it. Maybe it's because I grew up in the country but living on a garbage pile doesn't really phase me after poking at animal carcasses in my childhood.

Re: Video reveals NYC subway ride 108 years ago from Union Square to Grand Central

#48
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No, reality in NYC is dirty. The rest of the country isn't. It's always amazed me how New Yorkers think their city of 8 million defines a country of 330 million.

It doesn't at all define america, but the rest of the country is literally built on dirt. May as well embrace it. Maybe it's because I grew up in the country but living on a garbage pile doesn't really phase me after poking at animal carcasses in my childhood.

There's a whole lot of difference between soil and trash, even if both can also be referred to as "dirt".
Post reply on HN