Live data from Hacker News

Our new Rails app: pplrep

pplrep.com

1–10 of 35 posts

Re: Our new Rails app: pplrep

#2
Reputation is a very important problem worth solving. However, I'm not sure your app tackles the most important part of this problem, which is connections between participants.

For example, let's say I started a business and I need first customers, which I cannot get without the reputation. One cheat is to simply create 100 accounts on your website, each referring to each other and giving points to each other. Even if you manually check each account, which I think you wouldn't be able to do at a certain point, I can game the system and gain fake reputation.

An alternative would be a system based on connections. For instance, if my friend or a friend of my friend gave your account some points, then I can be more sure of the validity of your reputation. The more connections you have to me and the shorter the route, the more reputable you appear to me. On the other hand, if all your points come from your own fake accounts which have no connections to any of my friends, your reputation appears 0 to me, even though you have 100 points.

Re: Our new Rails app: pplrep

#3
Finally, there's a question of openness. If you store your DB of connections and points on your own server, I'd trust it less than if it was stored publicly, like the Bitcoin blockchain.

Re: Our new Rails app: pplrep

#9
post #8

George Zimmerman is in seventh place. This app doesn't really make any sense.

Hi. The site just launched. So far it seems our members seem to like Zimmerman. It's out of our hands as to who people want to rep, as that should be up to the community.

Re: Our new Rails app: pplrep

#10

>Each time you rep someone, you are rewarded with 2 rep points of your own. If I randomly rep enough people I will become A GOD.

Hi, I am the author of the app. Thanks for your comment.

There's a limit on how often you can rep a single person (once every 24 hours), and if you are to spam different people with rep, your rep is likely to be deleted by the person's profile, which will take your score back down two points. Since a person's profile is public, they likely don't want their profile filled with spam rep or to like their reps are fake. We are hoping members will play their role in moderating in their own profiles.

Post reply on HN