Live data from Hacker News

Frayed Prospects, Despite a Degree

nytimes.com

21–30 of 52 posts

Re: Frayed Prospects, Despite a Degree

#21
post #3

Article took way too long to get to the crux of the problem: 1. Choose your majors carefully and plan your career early - A degree in communications doesn't really make you employable. . 2. These people aren't willing to relocate to a less than desirable area to get that first opportunity

So, let's say that you're getting poor grades in pre-med. You're already 30,000 in debt. Is it better to continue in a degree where you have no chance of further advancement (no medical school will take you), drop out and have absolutely no career leads and a pile of debt, or get a second rate degree? This is the problem -- we've raised the bar for failure so high because of the cost of going to college. We've made i…

Sunk costs are sunk costs. You quit and move on to something that doesn't incur more debt. One option is joining the military where you can get real-world experience and they'll pay a significant portion of future education. Another is taking base courses at a significantly cheaper community college until you understand what you want to do and whether you have the natural ability for it.

The core problem is taking on 30k of debt without the commitment and/or natural ability necessary to complete the degree.

Re: Frayed Prospects, Despite a Degree

#22
post #14
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How much more do you want to produce?

Most people don't have everything they want, yet. So the answer is: more.

People have an infinite capacity for wanting, so towards infinite growth we go, I guess? Seems sustainable.

Re: Frayed Prospects, Despite a Degree

#23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So, let's say that you're getting poor grades in pre-med. You're already 30,000 in debt. Is it better to continue in a degree where you have no chance of further advancement (no medical school will take you), drop out and have absolutely no career leads and a pile of debt, or get a second rate degree? This is the problem -- we've raised the bar for failure so high because of the cost of going to college. We've made i…

Sunk costs are sunk costs. You quit and move on to something that doesn't incur more debt. One option is joining the military where you can get real-world experience and they'll pay a significant portion of future education. Another is taking base courses at a significantly cheaper community college until you understand what you want to do and whether you have the natural ability for it. The core problem is taking on…

The core problem is exploiting inelastic demand in charging 30k for something that could be provided at 2k.

Re: Frayed Prospects, Despite a Degree

#24

I think the key here is "without taking advantage of other opportunities". If you're unemployed for a couple years and you don't do anything, then you're signaling something very important to an employer: passivity. A fresh grad with no experience has no experience, but there's also no information to indicate that they won't be a good employee. A two-year unemployed worker has no experience and has two years worth of…

If you run a 100,000 user website, why acquire a degree in the first place?

Re: Frayed Prospects, Despite a Degree

#25

I think the key here is "without taking advantage of other opportunities". If you're unemployed for a couple years and you don't do anything, then you're signaling something very important to an employer: passivity. A fresh grad with no experience has no experience, but there's also no information to indicate that they won't be a good employee. A two-year unemployed worker has no experience and has two years worth of…

If you run a 100,000 user website, why acquire a degree in the first place?

Don't you know that on Hacker News the answer to every social problem is either make everyone code up a massively-successful website or become an engineer in the bay area?

Re: Frayed Prospects, Despite a Degree

#27
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would be with you if goods production somehow halted and we weren't able to get our hand on those very goods: less workers->less production->scarcity->unsatisfied demand->soaring prices that simply isn't happening. It seems to me that organizations that previously employed tens thousands of workers are now doing just fine with way less than that.

I'm not saying that there aren't efficiency improvements happening. The economy is clearly producing as much as it did before with fewer workers. But efficiency improvements reduce production costs, which, in a competitive market, tends to be reflected as reduced prices. But when prices go down, quantity demanded goes up, so efficiency improvements tend to result in more overall production. I.e. the fact that compani…

Growth is non-existent...

Growth is the same as it was before the recession (about 2.5%).

http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/GDPC1

Efficiency improvements have resulted in more overall production.

Re: Frayed Prospects, Despite a Degree

#28
post #18

>But the end result was disheartening: Mr. Wells was told, he said, that company policy required him to have at least two years of experience in the field before he could be hired. The interesting bit here is that it's a transparent, obvious lie. If it were the truth, he wouldn't have gotten the interview in the first place. I mean, his lack of experience undoubtedly hurt him, but if you get the interview, (and if a…

Sounds like it might be a sit-down-for-coffee styled chat, as opposed to anything formal.

Re: Frayed Prospects, Despite a Degree

#29
post #18

>But the end result was disheartening: Mr. Wells was told, he said, that company policy required him to have at least two years of experience in the field before he could be hired. The interesting bit here is that it's a transparent, obvious lie. If it were the truth, he wouldn't have gotten the interview in the first place. I mean, his lack of experience undoubtedly hurt him, but if you get the interview, (and if a…

Sounds like it might be a sit-down-for-coffee styled chat, as opposed to anything formal.

Right, but the point stands - if someone is with hiring authority at a company responds to your job search, you have not yet been disqualified.

So if it was clear on his resume/communication that he had less than 2 years experience, the "we require 2 years" is an excuse, not the real reason.

If the recruiter knew he lacked the experience, and if the experience was a hard, unyielding barrier, then the recruiter would not even bother.

Re: Frayed Prospects, Despite a Degree

#30

I think the key here is "without taking advantage of other opportunities". If you're unemployed for a couple years and you don't do anything, then you're signaling something very important to an employer: passivity. A fresh grad with no experience has no experience, but there's also no information to indicate that they won't be a good employee. A two-year unemployed worker has no experience and has two years worth of…

I agree. Basically, do something. Don't just sit there. Too much reality for some.
Post reply on HN