Live data from Hacker News

Ouya console review: "Pass on it"

gdgt.com

11–20 of 44 posts

Re: Ouya console review: "Pass on it"

#11
This review states the Ouya is "hacker friendly" and I think thats far from the truth. It comes with a locked bootloader and, as far as I've been able to research, no one has been able to put any other version of Linux on it.

I think piracy concerns ended up causing Ouya to close their system some, making it less hacker friendly.

Re: Ouya console review: "Pass on it"

#12

Can't help but feel Ouya's sitting in a niche that someone's going to snap up in 6 months or so like the iPad did to the ill-fated crunchPad/JooJoo. Be it the steam box or someone else. Perfectly good market, fantastic vision, just not quite polished enough and with not enough money behind it to get over the technical hurdles & polish to win over the consumers (obviously excluding the drama with the crunchpad at the…

I feel that the problem is the price, none of the major console manufacturers have tried (or at least succeeded) in building a console for that sort of money. There's probably a reason for that.

The reason the major players haven't made a cheap console is because they (Nintendo excepted) are pushing the boundaries of what "cheap enough" hardware can do. That's necessary for the type of games they want to sell -- but it's not necessary for all games.

I fully expect an Ouya/Google/Apple/GameBerryPi/etc to really find a fun loving, large market at a $100 price tag.

Re: Ouya console review: "Pass on it"

#14
post #3
post #2

I actually think that as an inexpensive XBMC TV device + emulator gaming Ouya is an outstanding offering for its price. But if someone expected current gen console compatition here - it means that the product was misunderstood.

Yes, I've been thinking about getting one specifically for that purpose: a cheap way to play NES/SNES/GBA/etc. games on my TV (I'd imagine that a Ouya filled with such games would be a great present to a niece/nephew whose family can't afford to pay for modern consoles + games). The Ouya also has Towerfall, which is apparently a fantastic game. Comparing it to PS3/Xbox/Wii U is missing the point.

Why do this when the Wii with Homebrew is perfectly capable of running a myriad of emulators that are a pleasure to use, has a superior controller, and runs it all really well?

Re: Ouya console review: "Pass on it"

#15
post #9
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

NES/SNES/GBA? Since you mentioned costs of original games, where will you get legal ROMs for those consoles?

where will you get legal ROMs for those consoles? You don't. You put on your eyepatch, grab your cutlass, and raise the Jolly Roger.

You've both missed his point, which is: why pirate SNES games but not Xbox 360 games?

Re: Ouya console review: "Pass on it"

#16
post #3
post #2

I actually think that as an inexpensive XBMC TV device + emulator gaming Ouya is an outstanding offering for its price. But if someone expected current gen console compatition here - it means that the product was misunderstood.

Yes, I've been thinking about getting one specifically for that purpose: a cheap way to play NES/SNES/GBA/etc. games on my TV (I'd imagine that a Ouya filled with such games would be a great present to a niece/nephew whose family can't afford to pay for modern consoles + games). The Ouya also has Towerfall, which is apparently a fantastic game. Comparing it to PS3/Xbox/Wii U is missing the point.

Another cheap way to play SNES games; your computer and a $10 controller.

Re: Ouya console review: "Pass on it"

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I feel that the problem is the price, none of the major console manufacturers have tried (or at least succeeded) in building a console for that sort of money. There's probably a reason for that.

The reason the major players haven't made a cheap console is because they (Nintendo excepted) are pushing the boundaries of what "cheap enough" hardware can do. That's necessary for the type of games they want to sell -- but it's not necessary for all games. I fully expect an Ouya/Google/Apple/GameBerryPi/etc to really find a fun loving, large market at a $100 price tag.

Problem is that you are trying to hit a middle ground between people who are gaming enthusiasts and want to play games on a dedicated device be it a console or PC with a fancy GPU. And a larger casual market; many of whom are probably looking to buy games for a system they already own like a laptop or tablet.

Re: Ouya console review: "Pass on it"

#18
post #6
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, I've been thinking about getting one specifically for that purpose: a cheap way to play NES/SNES/GBA/etc. games on my TV (I'd imagine that a Ouya filled with such games would be a great present to a niece/nephew whose family can't afford to pay for modern consoles + games). The Ouya also has Towerfall, which is apparently a fantastic game. Comparing it to PS3/Xbox/Wii U is missing the point.

NES/SNES/GBA? Since you mentioned costs of original games, where will you get legal ROMs for those consoles?

http://www.retrode.org/

Even ripping your own, legality is still probably a bit of a grey area.

Re: Ouya console review: "Pass on it"

#19
post #11

This review states the Ouya is "hacker friendly" and I think thats far from the truth. It comes with a locked bootloader and, as far as I've been able to research, no one has been able to put any other version of Linux on it. I think piracy concerns ended up causing Ouya to close their system some, making it less hacker friendly.

Does it allow side-loading of unsigned apk's? That wold make it very friendly for some types of hackers.

Re: Ouya console review: "Pass on it"

#20
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

where will you get legal ROMs for those consoles? You don't. You put on your eyepatch, grab your cutlass, and raise the Jolly Roger.

You've both missed his point, which is: why pirate SNES games but not Xbox 360 games?

Because people love classics.
Post reply on HN