Live data from Hacker News

A Low-Tech Mosquito Deterrent

nytimes.com

181–190 of 195 posts

Re: A Low-Tech Mosquito Deterrent

#181
post #119

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The mosquitoes are pretty rough up on the north slope. They're even worse than the Anchorage area (and bigger, too). Anywhere there's lots of standing fresh water, you'll have mosquitoes in the summer in Alaska. The wind does make a huge difference though. If it's windy, there's more or less no problem. It's when the wind lies down that they come out in force. The mosquitoes are bad enough that blood loss due to inse…

Anchorage is south.

Yes. That's what I was saying. The mosquitoes can be even worse in the extreme north of Alaska than they are in southeast Alaska.

Re: A Low-Tech Mosquito Deterrent

#182
post #170
post #29

Spend a summer up in the Yukon or Alaska if you want to see solid walls of ravenous mosquitoes. I get bitten while riding my bike, bitten while my arm is out of the car window driving at 30km/h, and bitten through jeans. 100% DEET (you can get it in Alaska) does the trick for about 30 minutes before you have to re-apply - and it's nasty stuff. This past weekend I was camping at a music festival and slapped my arm cas…

I agree. I don't think the author has been to India. I lived in Hyderabad, and the mosquito's there were super fast and super aggressive. Fans? Hah. Before sleeping, I'd close all the windows and doors and spray the toxic anti-mosquito product. After half an hour, I'd go in and find all the fallen mosquito's and squish them, since they weren't actually dead, just stunned. After a while they would just get up and fly…

Seconded. From Pakistan. Fans mean nothing to these mosquitoes. The only thing that works is physically zapping them.

Re: A Low-Tech Mosquito Deterrent

#183
post #170
post #29

Spend a summer up in the Yukon or Alaska if you want to see solid walls of ravenous mosquitoes. I get bitten while riding my bike, bitten while my arm is out of the car window driving at 30km/h, and bitten through jeans. 100% DEET (you can get it in Alaska) does the trick for about 30 minutes before you have to re-apply - and it's nasty stuff. This past weekend I was camping at a music festival and slapped my arm cas…

I agree. I don't think the author has been to India. I lived in Hyderabad, and the mosquito's there were super fast and super aggressive. Fans? Hah. Before sleeping, I'd close all the windows and doors and spray the toxic anti-mosquito product. After half an hour, I'd go in and find all the fallen mosquito's and squish them, since they weren't actually dead, just stunned. After a while they would just get up and fly…

You just need a bigger fan. Downside would be noise of the fan and wind of a constant mini-hurricane :)

Re: A Low-Tech Mosquito Deterrent

#185

There is a guy on Youtube [1] that builds large DIY Mosquito fan traps. Well worth a watch if this is an issue for you. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pU2kbghz85I

I purchased one of these devices that clips onto a box fan and traps the mosquitos. It works ok, but the best results are from having the fan blow away from you, which isn't all that cooling: http://skeeterbag.com/

Re: A Low-Tech Mosquito Deterrent

#186
post #180

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It seems likely that capturing cats, sterilizing them, and releasing them would have a larger impact than simply releasing a large number of sterile cats. It's also much easier to do in appreciable numbers, relative to the wild population, and it doesn't actually lead to extinction, just some additional population control. I don't think it is a good fit for mosquitos. I once heard a modified version of the plan, wher…

But presumably the female mosquitos will eventually learn to avoid the males with the modified Y chromosome?

I think I recall there being some argument as to why this was unlikely, but I'm not able to produce it. Certainly, every female mosquito has two X chromosomes that have avoided being driven out by the Y, and choice of mate would factor into that, and so in the population of female mosquitoes I would tentatively expect there to be evolutionary pressure there...

There is obviously the question of whether it would be sufficient, in time - the figures around time-frame were surprisingly short - but that's not a solid guarantee. Even if it just produced a substantial collapse for a couple years, it might help substantially in fighting malaria, though.

Re: A Low-Tech Mosquito Deterrent

#187

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That is an incomplete summary of her credentials... Hello! I’m a freelance science journalist living in New York with my ball python, Agamemnon Fang. I spent the last few years as a marine geochemist by day, contributing editor for CBS SmartPlanet at night. Before that, I was a news intern for Nature in Washington, D.C., an editorial intern at Discover in New York, and a reporter for the infamous Point Reyes Light in…

Rather than summarize her credentials, I was attempting to point out that perhaps an intern writer at Nature.com is not someone we can refer to as "a scientist" and reference as such. Yes, she has a degree and experience. No, I'm not prepared to accept interns 2 years out of college as authoritative experts when it comes to planetwide ecological policy.

How do you know I wasn't referring to one of the scientists she interviewed for the article, more than one of whom suggested that we could live without mosquitoes?

Re: A Low-Tech Mosquito Deterrent

#189
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Also don't ever mix it with DEET, because the combination is neurotoxic. Holy crap. I must know 100 people who regularly wear Permethrin-treated clothes and then spray on DEET repellent. I had no idea it was dangerous. (FWIW, I avoid them both due to general conservatism when it comes to toxic chemicals, especially when the stakes are low -- i.e., the worst-case is itching and not malaria.)

I started doing it only because I've already gotten bitten by two ticks this year and have found another half dozen on me. I'm only outside a few hours a week collecting mushrooms though, I'm not lying with it pressed against my skin for ten hours straight in a hunting blind or doing anything that would cause me to sweat excessively. But yeah, at least in the Northeast it's gotten to the point where going out into th…

“Lyme disease is the only infection I know of where we have a safe and effective vaccine, but it’s not available to the public,” says Dr. Allen Steere, the physician who uncovered the disease:

http://www.wbur.org/2012/06/27/lyme-vaccine

Re: A Low-Tech Mosquito Deterrent

#190

As a Yukon resident, I can safely say the only way to avoid the mosquitos is to hole up in your house, and utilize your arctic entrance as an airlock for when you need to refill your groceries. This is a guide to entering your house with the airlock system: Step 0: Open outside door to arctic entrance Step 1: Run inside with your groceries/supplies Step 2: Close outside entrance Step 3: Nuke the arctic entrance, RAID…

Good lord.
Post reply on HN