Live data from Hacker News

The History of Ctrl + Alt + Delete

m.mentalfloss.com

31–40 of 47 posts

Re: The History of Ctrl + Alt + Delete

#31
post #2

Bill made it famous with his crashy software that made knowing it needed... These days of windows 8 I still have to use it regularly because of freezing programs and OS issues.

DOS was a real mode operating system, and so any bugs in any software could (and usually did) crash the computer. You can't blame Microsoft for that.

Re: The History of Ctrl + Alt + Delete

#32
post #16
post #2

Bill made it famous with his crashy software that made knowing it needed... These days of windows 8 I still have to use it regularly because of freezing programs and OS issues.

OS issues such as?

Like allowing a poorly coded game hijack your screen and having no way to fix it but using control alt del and hitting keys hoping it will close the offending program...

Or crashes related to Adobe products, or Apple products... I know it is mainly not windows fault, but there are some OSes that are more resilient to stupid programs.

Re: The History of Ctrl + Alt + Delete

#33
> And yet, few of these consumers were aware of Bradley’s shortcut quietly lingering in their machines. It wasn’t until the early 1990s, when Microsoft’s Windows took off, that the shortcut came to prominence.

What? I've programmed the PC since 1982 or so. Everyone knew about C-A-D.

Re: The History of Ctrl + Alt + Delete

#34
post #6

Hmm, it's a very long time ago that I pressed that key combination. I tried it out, and apparently it is wired to the Logout function of KDE...

Ditto here on Unity, but I got a confirm dialog. On Windows it's still the software interrupt, and on the corporate edition of win7 at work I get "Press Ctrl-Alt-Del to log in" on every boot.

Re: The History of Ctrl + Alt + Delete

#35
post #6

Hmm, it's a very long time ago that I pressed that key combination. I tried it out, and apparently it is wired to the Logout function of KDE...

Yeah- it was a pretty standard thing in Desktop Managers for a while for to be logout (or return to DM, depending on what you're using). I think GDM 3.0+ finally threw it out, but you'll still see it in KDM, LightDM, and Slim.

It's not even universal across all KDM et al installs. None of my Arch + KDE4 log out when using ctr+alt+del.

On a side note, ctr+alt+backspace used to kill Xorg (still can if you enabled it - but these days that shortcut key is disabled by default)

Re: The History of Ctrl + Alt + Delete

#36
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's been famous for probably longer than you've been paying attention, then. Windows stability has made huge strides over the past 20ish years.

I know, I've been using it for more than 2 decades :P And I always had the feeling that the amount of crashes due to actual OS bugs is way lower than what the common belief seems to be. Way over 90% of problems I witnessed myself was duewas dues to faulty software, drivers or hardware. And as you say it just got better with most releases which is (just guessing) partly due to less OS bugs and partly due to the OS tak…

Faulty 3rd party software should never be allowed to cause kernel panics (aka BSODs)

Re: The History of Ctrl + Alt + Delete

#37

I've always wondered whether the creator of Ctrl-Alt-Del was aware that the MIT Lisp Machines were rebooted with Ctrl-Meta-Ctrl-Meta-Rubout, or if this is just a case of convergent reinvention. Does anyone know?

I can't say for sure, but the ending quote from the article

  “I have to share the credit,” Bradley joked. “I may have
  invented it, but I think Bill made it famous.”
seems to support the theory that he reinvented it independently. I'd be interested to know who at MIT picked the key combination Ctrl-Meta-Ctrl-Meta-Rubout for the Lisp Machines.

Re: The History of Ctrl + Alt + Delete

#38
post #3

And yet, few of these consumers were aware of Bradley’s shortcut quietly lingering in their machines. It wasn’t until the early 1990s, when Microsoft’s Windows took off, that the shortcut came to prominence. In an indirect sense it came to prominence in the 1980s, but via Apple. Apple borrowed the CTRL + ALT + DEL soft-reset idea by adding a CTRL + OPEN APPLE + RESET soft-reset functionality to the IIe (the 1983 upgr…

I'm from the Macintosh generation, but I remember it being Apple-Option-Esc to force quit and Apple-Ctrl-Power to restart.
Post reply on HN