Live data from Hacker News

"Nothing like this will be built again"

antipope.org

31–40 of 97 posts

Re: "Nothing like this will be built again"

#31
post #27

> smelling the thing (mostly machine oil and steam, and a hint of ozone near the transformers) Possibly just metal oxides or dimethylsulphide, as ozone is odourless.

Next time choose your sources more carefully. Not only ozone has smell, its name means that.

Re: "Nothing like this will be built again"

#33
post #32

"Anti-rabbit defenses"?

Torness has been shut down due to jellyfish, maybe they expect suicide rabbit squads to invade and nibble vital cables?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torness_Nuclear_Power_Station#S...

[NB I carefully avoided making any reference to The Wasp Factory]

Re: "Nothing like this will be built again"

#34
post #12
post #8

Nothing like it will be built again because a) successive British governments over the last 30 years have buried their heads in the sand over energy policy[1] and b) we as a country don't do actual engineering anymore. Both a and b mean that our energy future likes wholly in the hands of France! [1] Say what you like about Thatcher, at least she had a halfway coherent energy story.

> we as a country don't do actual engineering anymore ...is that really true? The UK is currently home to Europe's largest civil engineering project (Crossrail), my hometown produces Trent jet engines and designs wings for all Airbus aircraft. And there's the cars that are both manufactured (BMW, Honda, Toyota, Nissan, etc) and designed (Jaguar, Aston Martin, Land Rover, McLaren...) here. The engineering we do has ch…

But not those that support a large number of jobs and how many of these engineering projects are done by non uk firms.

Re: "Nothing like this will be built again"

#35
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And how many of these are UK owned? Which I took to be his point, given the dig that a French company will be building the new Nuclear power plants at Hinkley Point...

Doesn't matter who owns the company - the engineers are British and they are solving their engineering problems in the UK. CocaCola is obviously a US company but the production plant in the UK has some very interesting manufacturing/engineering problems (as does Mars, Proctor and Gamble, Fuji (pharma division)) and if you really need examples of British companies then try Dynex, Wolfson Microelectronics, Imagination…

Um a lot of these European companies favor their own nationality it's going to be french engineers and possibly a lot of the navvies/ground workers will be imported.

Re: "Nothing like this will be built again"

#36
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

page content hash Change one byte. regex match Now we get into ship-of-theseus arguments. What counts as the "same" article? 99 percent? 51 percent? What if you resubmit a blog post that's picked up 150 more comments since it was last posted? How would HN tell the comments apart from the article text? What if someone submits a blog post that heavily quotes another article that's been submitted, in the process of rebu…

> Change one byte. Most resubmissions are submitted by people other than their authors, who are typically not in a position to change any bytes of the content. In the present case, speaking as the last person to submit this one (more than two years ago), I don't see that there's any harm in it at all. If this is still interesting two years since it was last discussed on HN -- which clearly it is -- then good for the…

The slightest spec of dynamic content makes this approach brittle at best, author or not.

Re: "Nothing like this will be built again"

#37
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And how many of these are UK owned? Which I took to be his point, given the dig that a French company will be building the new Nuclear power plants at Hinkley Point...

Doesn't matter who owns the company - the engineers are British and they are solving their engineering problems in the UK. CocaCola is obviously a US company but the production plant in the UK has some very interesting manufacturing/engineering problems (as does Mars, Proctor and Gamble, Fuji (pharma division)) and if you really need examples of British companies then try Dynex, Wolfson Microelectronics, Imagination…

Thans, that's an interesting list.

In terms of pure engineering I agree it doesn't matter who owns the company; in terms of whether engineering is having its full impact on Britain (other than by providing jobs) I'd say it does - if profits get moved to other countries and taxes paid elsewhere, we're losing out and I'd like to see more UK owned companies for that reason.

Re: "Nothing like this will be built again"

#38
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And how many of these are UK owned? Which I took to be his point, given the dig that a French company will be building the new Nuclear power plants at Hinkley Point...

Doesn't matter who owns the company - the engineers are British and they are solving their engineering problems in the UK. CocaCola is obviously a US company but the production plant in the UK has some very interesting manufacturing/engineering problems (as does Mars, Proctor and Gamble, Fuji (pharma division)) and if you really need examples of British companies then try Dynex, Wolfson Microelectronics, Imagination…

>CocaCola is obviously a US company but the production plant in the UK has some very interesting manufacturing/engineering problems

Citation needed. They are Coca Cola manufacturing plants all around the world. From Bolivia to India and from Germany to Albania, and they don't have any interesting manufacturing/engineering problems.

Nothing that wasn't already solved in the US HQs anyway.

Re: "Nothing like this will be built again"

#39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Doesn't matter who owns the company - the engineers are British and they are solving their engineering problems in the UK. CocaCola is obviously a US company but the production plant in the UK has some very interesting manufacturing/engineering problems (as does Mars, Proctor and Gamble, Fuji (pharma division)) and if you really need examples of British companies then try Dynex, Wolfson Microelectronics, Imagination…

Um a lot of these European companies favor their own nationality it's going to be french engineers and possibly a lot of the navvies/ground workers will be imported.

[deleted]

Re: "Nothing like this will be built again"

#40
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Doesn't matter who owns the company - the engineers are British and they are solving their engineering problems in the UK. CocaCola is obviously a US company but the production plant in the UK has some very interesting manufacturing/engineering problems (as does Mars, Proctor and Gamble, Fuji (pharma division)) and if you really need examples of British companies then try Dynex, Wolfson Microelectronics, Imagination…

> CocaCola is obviously a US company but the production plant in the UK has some very interesting manufacturing/engineering problems Citation needed. They are Coca Cola manufacturing plants all around the world. From Bolivia to India and from Germany to Albania, and they don't have any interesting manufacturing/engineering problems. Nothing that wasn't already solved in the US HQs anyway.

There are, but each plant (just like in every industry) will have it's own issues, targets and geography specific problems to deal with. Manufacturing isn't a setup once and repeat around the world process - as much as the people working on it would like it to be.

My citation is a friends Dad who was a lead engineer on CocaCola's line. Your citation the Bolivia etc not having interesting problems would be?

Post reply on HN