Live data from Hacker News

Find Cities with Similar Climates

mikemcbrearty.com

31–40 of 48 posts

Re: Find Cities with Similar Climates

#31
What I really like about the search, is that it accounts for seasons on different hemispheres. E.g. it returns Lisboa and Cadiz as places similar to Sydney. Even though the months with hot weather are different in the Northern and Southern Hemispheres.

As a side note - clicking the name of a place shows an overlay in the graph. It was not obvious at first; the names are in black.

Re: Find Cities with Similar Climates

#33
post #27

Do a search for 'South Africa' - the cities it returns are all small cities which are just big enough to have airports. In the cases of places like new york, only the airport is returned. I'm just guessing here, but possibly this is a database of geographical locations with a population figure attached. The author has probably swapped 'only show cities with greater than X population' with 'only show cities with less…

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Weather_Service in the US the NWS / NOAA operates weather stations at airports, wouldn't be surprised if other countries have similar programs. my hometown has a much larger population than the next one over, but the next one over is listed because there's an airport there.

You missed my point maybe - the fact that your hometown is bigger and not listed is exactly the problem. There are a number of small cities listed that do not have airports also. The key is that a listed city either lists as 'airport' (population 0), or is a very small city (low population). So my point is that the filtering is probably backwards, and it's filtering out big cities instead of filtering out small ones.

Maybe. ;)

Re: Find Cities with Similar Climates

#35
Overall, this is pretty alright, though I'm looking at the climate results for Boston in the summertime right now, and as sweat pours down my face I really really wish that 25°C was the average temperature around here in June-July.

Re: Find Cities with Similar Climates

#38
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Weather_Service in the US the NWS / NOAA operates weather stations at airports, wouldn't be surprised if other countries have similar programs. my hometown has a much larger population than the next one over, but the next one over is listed because there's an airport there.

You missed my point maybe - the fact that your hometown is bigger and not listed is exactly the problem. There are a number of small cities listed that do not have airports also. The key is that a listed city either lists as 'airport' (population 0), or is a very small city (low population). So my point is that the filtering is probably backwards, and it's filtering out big cities instead of filtering out small ones.…

Might it not be likely that an application dependent on weather data is actually limited to locations for which weather data is available, regardless of population?

Re: Find Cities with Similar Climates

#39
post #26
post #14

This city search is the worst one I've ever used. Devs, please test your sites, even the toy projects.

I typed in 3 large US cities and got 3 "no results found". Google map API is your friend.

I tried London, but it only gave me a place in South Africa or a canadian airport.
Post reply on HN