Power users aren't tripped up with an annoying confirmation. Novice users can revert. This seems a much better paradigm.
Are there any cases where this doesn't make for good UX?
51–60 of 152 posts
Power users aren't tripped up with an annoying confirmation. Novice users can revert. This seems a much better paradigm.
Are there any cases where this doesn't make for good UX?
Some of these are good ideas others are pure opinion and don't necessarily make sense in all contexts.
Meanwhile a distracting footer covers >25% of the page, and clicking the intuitive "down arrow"-looking thing does nothing, nor is there an obvious close button. You close it with that über-readable burnt-orange-on-charcoal link "Ok, enough already. Hide the footer." Either they assume the user scans for "Ok," when wanting to close something, or that they skim sentences from the inside-out. If you do close it and cli…
And for me on my desktop the footer was so un-noticeable that I had to go back to the page to even see what it was that you had an issue with.
Any empirical evidence to show any of these things are actually good? Some "seem" to be common sense (e.g. less form fields to lower sign up friction) but a lot of the other things appear to be what one UX designer thinks it's a good idea rather than anything that might actually help you.
At a previous company our target audience was older women. We A-B tested every single element on our landing page, and I can tell you, using the advice on this site would be a complete disaster.
Meanwhile a distracting footer covers >25% of the page, and clicking the intuitive "down arrow"-looking thing does nothing, nor is there an obvious close button. You close it with that über-readable burnt-orange-on-charcoal link "Ok, enough already. Hide the footer." Either they assume the user scans for "Ok," when wanting to close something, or that they skim sentences from the inside-out. If you do close it and cli…
Meanwhile a distracting footer covers >25% of the page, and clicking the intuitive "down arrow"-looking thing does nothing, nor is there an obvious close button. You close it with that über-readable burnt-orange-on-charcoal link "Ok, enough already. Hide the footer." Either they assume the user scans for "Ok," when wanting to close something, or that they skim sentences from the inside-out. If you do close it and cli…
As I scroll, it keeps reappearing right in the middle of the content, then flashes away after 2 seconds
When I got to the end, it was nigh impossible to actually get the footer to show (or whatever the sign up box was) I finally got to enter my name but then going to [Next] on iPad just made the whole thing disappear and I couldnt get it back.
I like their ideas, really dislike their execution, that was a frustrating experience.