Live data from Hacker News

Bart employee salaries CSV

github.com

11–20 of 72 posts

Re: Bart employee salaries CSV

#11

It'd have been nice to anonymize this data. I know it's publicly available but we should respect people's privacy. I don't think having people's name adds anything interesting to this data set.

No, this is ALL public data. It's easily accessible ever since the CA state mandated transparency for all public service employee salaries.

By the way, if anyone wants to know what Terry Tao, math extraordinaire, is making, you can also find that on the CA gov website.

Re: Bart employee salaries CSV

#14

Wow, some of these public servants make as much money as a 19 year old college dropout in Silicon Valley.

Did you mean the high end, or the low end?

A college dropout can make a killing in Silicon Valley, if they are also: a talented software developer.

OTOH, some of the other dropouts might end up working as BART train operators, who seem to make between 12 and 15k/yr, which is likely for full time, in a city where it costs about 1/4 of that just to scrape by on a monthly basis.

It is not right to employ people at a wage that they cannot possibly subsist on. These people all ended up as bart train operators for one reason or another. Maybe they were lazy. Maybe they got shafted in life. Maybe they're dumb. But does that mean they should be paid a substandard living wage? No.

Meanwhile the luckier, more industrious, or combination thereof, are making over 10x the amount of the lowest paid workers.

Min wage needs to be raised, a lot. Look at Australia.

Re: Bart employee salaries CSV

#15
post #10

It'd have been nice to anonymize this data. I know it's publicly available but we should respect people's privacy. I don't think having people's name adds anything interesting to this data set.

By law, salaries of public sector employees are public knowledge. I think this is the same data that is seen here: http://www.mercurynews.com/salaries/bay-area?Entity=Bay%20Ar...

Yea I just got it from there. I thought it would be useful to some people in CSV format.

Re: Bart employee salaries CSV

#16
This is just mean. Why don't you put your own name and salary up there for us to see, mariusz331?

Whether your employer is the government or a private entity and whether or not you participate in a strike you don't deserve to have your financial data exposed.

Re: Bart employee salaries CSV

#17
post #2

Very interesting. How come there are a bunch of people with $0 base salary ? Are those contractors, interns ? Also, some of those low-base employees seem to have very high employer contributions to medical/dental/vision plans. How does that work ?

Some are explicitly called "intern" or "PT" (part time), some very much look like probable contractors, but I don't know how contractors end up with contributions to insurance/pension/etc, and others I see no obvious reason for such numbers at all.

Conceivably some of it could be attributable to oddities of recently-retired/fired/resigned employees, but I'm sure not all of it.

I think this dataset is impossible to make meaningful sense of without much more information on BART's employment practices, possibly wider laws/regulations on California public employees, and more specific information about individuals.

Re: Bart employee salaries CSV

#18
post #16

This is just mean. Why don't you put your own name and salary up there for us to see, mariusz331? Whether your employer is the government or a private entity and whether or not you participate in a strike you don't deserve to have your financial data exposed.

They're public employees, their salaries have been public information for a long time.

Mean or nice doesn't have anything to do with it.

Re: Bart employee salaries CSV

#19
post #16

This is just mean. Why don't you put your own name and salary up there for us to see, mariusz331? Whether your employer is the government or a private entity and whether or not you participate in a strike you don't deserve to have your financial data exposed.

We the People pay and employ public workers. Ergo, We the People are entitled to see their salaries, and in this particular case, how badly they're "ripping off" the Public in general.

Re: Bart employee salaries CSV

#20
Wow. Lesson number one from this list is that if you want to make a boatload working for the government, be a cop. Aside from top administrators, the top ranks of the list are dominated by regular transit cops.

Usually the very, very generous retirement benefits drive high police compensation. Well paid overtime helps, too.

Post reply on HN