Live data from Hacker News

Internet Credit Union

iafcu.org

11–20 of 26 posts

Re: Internet Credit Union

#11

Why is this here? There are other credit unions. This 'bank' is running on Wordpress - 3.5.1 from what I can tell [0]. Isn't that vulnerable [1]? The customer login page takes you somewhere else [2] - seems sketchy. I can't find any information about their interest rates - why should I put my money with them? [0] https://iafcu.org/wp-admin [1] http://codex.wordpress.org/Version_3.5.2 [2] https://obc.itsme247.com/237/…

[deleted]

Re: Internet Credit Union

#12
I don't know very much about the banking system, but I had a roommate in college who was a business/finance student, and always told me, "Banks are for businesses. You, as a person, don't have enough assets to make a bank care about you. Credit Unions are for people."

I don't know if he is right or not, but I've been a die-hard CU member for the last 12 years, and would never go back to a bank for my personal finances.

Re: Internet Credit Union

#13

I don't know very much about the banking system, but I had a roommate in college who was a business/finance student, and always told me, "Banks are for businesses. You, as a person, don't have enough assets to make a bank care about you. Credit Unions are for people." I don't know if he is right or not, but I've been a die-hard CU member for the last 12 years, and would never go back to a bank for my personal finance…

Must be different in the US. I don't even know the term for 'credit unions' in my native language, everyone here uses a bank. Although, the larger banks tend to favour businesses, while the smaller banks tend to favour people.

As far as I can gather from Wikipedia, it seems that in other languages, the term for 'Credit Union' still includes the word 'bank', so that might be the confusion. Still, I don't believe my bank technically is a credit union. Also, bankers here aren't dicks.

Re: Internet Credit Union

#14
Here is a talk by the founders @ the Bitcoin 2013 conference... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RD6fVNGEnlI

They are working on quite a bit at the moment; their site might appear 'sketchy' at first glance but it seems like this is only the beginning and they have some pretty serious plans for their future.

Re: Internet Credit Union

#15
post #9

https://iafcu.org/special-posts/membership/ "Persons who live, work, worship, attend school, or participate in associations headquartered in New Brunswick or Highland Park, New Jersey" Am I misunderstanding what this means, or are they saying you have to live there in order to be a member?

I looked into the feasibility of starting a web-based credit union a few years ago and I discovered that federal regulations require credit unions to serve some distinct community -- whether it be a physical community (like a town) or an affinity community (like an alumni association).

This makes it more difficult to establish an open-to-everyone web-based credit union; you basically have to have some sort of online community already in place, and attract members from that community.

Nevertheless, there are some web-based credit unions that have been able to successfully meet the requirements ... however, this explains why you don't see the cooperative equivalent of an ING Direct/Capital One 360.

Even so, I do hope that either the regulations change or some established web-based credit unions are able to attract people away from the for-profit banks, because credit unions, being member owned, never put profits before people. (But if they DO happen to make a profit, it goes back to the members, not to some outside shareholder.)

Re: Internet Credit Union

#16
post #4

I was interested until I couldn't easily find the interest rate for a savings account. I like having a physical branch with in walking distance, but iff you could give me an extra percent on a savings account that is accessed infrequently I'd probably go for it.

I'm kind of the opposite. I really have no need for a physical branch. If anything, it might imply that the bank has less focus on serving customers without access to a bank branch. I prefer doing my banking online. I think USAA has physical branches someplace, but I have no idea where they are off the top of my head.

I'm really not sure why I would normally need access to a physical branch. I once had to get paperwork notarized at another bank, but that only cost me $5 and USAA probably would have sent a notary out if that paperwork had anything to do with them.

Re: Internet Credit Union

#17

Why is this here? There are other credit unions. This 'bank' is running on Wordpress - 3.5.1 from what I can tell [0]. Isn't that vulnerable [1]? The customer login page takes you somewhere else [2] - seems sketchy. I can't find any information about their interest rates - why should I put my money with them? [0] https://iafcu.org/wp-admin [1] http://codex.wordpress.org/Version_3.5.2 [2] https://obc.itsme247.com/237/…

I have the same question. Maybe because Founder of the Internet Archive, Brewster Kahle, is on the management team?

It seems like a interesting option (they have some decent ideas in place) but I agree it also seem sketchy/fly by night. It is only a small credit union for people in a specific part of NJ, USA.

Re: Internet Credit Union

#18
post #9

https://iafcu.org/special-posts/membership/ "Persons who live, work, worship, attend school, or participate in associations headquartered in New Brunswick or Highland Park, New Jersey" Am I misunderstanding what this means, or are they saying you have to live there in order to be a member?

No, you don't have to live there. As part of the account creation process, you donate a small amount of money ($5, iirc) to one of their local partners, and that satisfies the "participates in associations" aspect of the rule.

EDIT: See "Persons participating in programs to alleviate poverty or distress that are located in the approved area" on the members page

Post reply on HN