Live data from Hacker News

Facebook is Blocking Connections from Tor Network

arabcrunch.com

31–40 of 128 posts

Re: Facebook is Blocking Connections from Tor Network

#31
post #18

It's probably a government request. But let's give them benefit of doubt. My guess is that there's a business reason behind it. Probably they want to track you.

I really doubt they care about tracking you that much. Tor is so infrequently used that it's not worth the trouble to force you to log in without it just to track you. Maybe if teenage girls were using Tor I might be inclined to agree but right now it's just not worth the effort for a few nerds.

Re: Facebook is Blocking Connections from Tor Network

#32

kind of pointless using Tor to access a site that has all your personal information on it.

What personal information exists in facebook?

Associates. Thoughts. Articles you liked. Articles you didn't like. Private messages. Contact information. Photos. Location check-ins. Causes you support.

The whole point of Facebook is to share some private information with a selected group of friends.

Re: Facebook is Blocking Connections from Tor Network

#33
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article simply states the issue. Its not up to the writer to come up with excuses for facebook, which if you are really hot on bad journalists you would rightly write off a mere speculation. Its up to facebook to explain their position. If their excuse turns out to be a reasonable reason, then lets hear it.

It's up to the journalist to investigate and find out why Facebook is doing this so he can write a more complete story.

Not necessarily - if their goal is to get Facebook to reverse the change (which I imagine it is based on the fact that the website is based in an area with a lot of civil unrest), then providing reasonable rationalization in the article isn't what you want to do.

Re: Facebook is Blocking Connections from Tor Network

#34

Google, IIRC, does not let you search from TOR either. If they can't track you, you're no good to them.

Because a lot of spammers/SEO Scrapers (such as Scrapebox or xrumer, or even sites with private databases such as SEOmoz or SEMrush-like databases could) use TOR to bulk-scrape Google.

So you are told that the IP you are using is rate limited.

Re: Facebook is Blocking Connections from Tor Network

#36
post #2

this means that facebook do not care about the fat of its users, as now thousands of activists in tyrant regimes might risk their identities be found and that means they will go to jail.

Facebook is supposed to be a site where you use your real identity and therefore seems like a bad choice for activists trying to keep their identity hidden. Twitter seems like a better solution which is still mainstream and the public nature of it makes it easier to communicate with the outside world.

activists are using facebook pages to lobby behind causes they do not use their real names so they are not arrested by oppressive regimes. there are many pages with millions of fans run this way. all at risk now.

Re: Facebook is Blocking Connections from Tor Network

#39
post #15
post #3

Has anybody tried asking Facebook why they've done this? Possible reasons: 1. One or more governments (which ones?) have told Facebook to block Tor or else. (Or else what?) 2. A manual security review revealed more hacking attempts via Tor than legitimate use, so Facebook decided to block Tor. 3. After a sustained hacking attack via Tor, an automated Facebook security system automatically blocked Facebook access from…

The article simply states the issue. Its not up to the writer to come up with excuses for facebook, which if you are really hot on bad journalists you would rightly write off a mere speculation. Its up to facebook to explain their position. If their excuse turns out to be a reasonable reason, then lets hear it.

"Its up to facebook to explain their position."

Uh, yeah. That's why the parent comment suggests asking Facebook what's going on NOT guessing about it!

Re: Facebook is Blocking Connections from Tor Network

#40
post #24
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

True, sorta. In my past experiences, if you're on tor (or proxy'd through a known portal), and have Javascript disabled entirely, Google will sometimes (not always) give you an error stating that your IP is a known abuser. If you DO have JS enabled, I have encountered the "Your IP is known to be abusive, so type in this captcha in order to continue" and then it forwards to encrypted.google.com. I get similiar behavio…

I never realized that turning on/off noscript had something to do with google blocking me, thanks.

Makes sense -- most bots don't run JS.
Post reply on HN