Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Soylent International

blog.soylent.me

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

21–30 of 91 posts

Re: Soylent International

#21

Post by schabernakk »

jckt wrote: post #8

I doubt they really care about HN's opinion given the vast number of criticisms put forward, but I do really hope that they'd post more product information, perhaps more of the science, more of the research. Again, as I've said before, hiring a few more relevant scientists would help with their credibility, and might it be possible? -- improve their product. That is all. May there be no more flamewars. (Granted, I've…

I just skimmed through their discussion board for a while, and it seems they are planning to employ a couple of industry experts (whatever that means) fulltime or for consultation with the money they made from their crowdfunding campaign.

Re: Soylent International

#22

Post by ChikkaChiChi »

I was interested when it was one guy on a mission for himself. I've become less so now that its clear he wanted to go worldwide with this as soon as possible.

I do not wish the project ill will, but I won't be signing on at this time unless things (re: testing) get a lot more transparent.

Re: Soylent International

#23

Post by chasing »

fredsted wrote: post #14
t0 wrote: post #9

Doesn't this require monitoring of blood levels? How could an average person order it and know they're healthy?

If you don't feel sick... Although I'd just go to the doctor for a checkup.

The problem is that you're average twenty-something can live off of all sorts of crap for an extended period of time before feeling sick. How many of you live off of fast food and Mountain Dew?

Re: Soylent International

#24

Post by [deleted] »

jgrahamc wrote: post #4

I'd be interested in seeing a comparison of Soylent against Ensure Complete. They seem to be very similar in intent: http://ensure.com/products/ensure-complete-shakes and based on the nutrition information for Ensure Complete from that page and the rough description of Soylent ( http://robrhinehart.com/?p=424 ) I do not see a major difference. It would appear that to get the same nutrients as Soylent I would need to…

[deleted]

Re: Soylent International

#26

Post by jjoonathan »

uncoder0 wrote: post #10
scott_karana wrote: post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Looking at Ensure, I don't get the impression that you're supposed to be able to live entirely on it. It looks more like a meal substitute (liquid nutrition bar) than a food substitute.

From the Ensure FAQ @ http://ensure.ca/en/faq/ " >For how long can I use Ensure? Ensure products deliver complete and balanced nutrition that is always beneficial. There is no time limit to using Ensure products. In fact, long-term use is encouraged if you’re at a nutritional risk (for example, if you’re an older adult). >Can Ensure replace a meal? Yes. Ensure products are complete and balanced, when used in appropri…

Well, here's a source for that (they use it in Guantanamo):

http://www.miamiherald.com/2013/04/29/3370916/more-navy-medi...

Re: Soylent International

#29

Post by jamesaguilar »

tokenadult wrote: post #20

This is perhaps the worst example of people who learn their science and medicine from reading Reddit that I have yet seen in the Hacker News community. It illustrates the fallibility of human nature behind every new business scheme, and shows that a business doesn't have to be a big, multinational publicly traded corporation to engage in business with little regard for customer safety or public benefit. AFTER EDIT: I…

Yeah, I'm pretty sure that you don't actually know where this guy learned his science and medicine. Let people experiment on themselves. IMO there are enough humans that if a few get slightly ill from this, it is worth it for the chance that it does work (which seems significant given the experimentation he did on himself, the presence of similar, competing products, etc.).

Re: Soylent International

#30

Post by ChikkaChiChi »

jgrahamc wrote: post #4

I'd be interested in seeing a comparison of Soylent against Ensure Complete. They seem to be very similar in intent: http://ensure.com/products/ensure-complete-shakes and based on the nutrition information for Ensure Complete from that page and the rough description of Soylent ( http://robrhinehart.com/?p=424 ) I do not see a major difference. It would appear that to get the same nutrients as Soylent I would need to…

The Soylent guy is an engineer who approached it like an engineering problem. It is supposed to contain everything your body needs on a regular basis.

Ensure is a food replacement that has a long history of helping people with medical concerns. My great-grandmother lived mostly on this stuff while going through chemo.

So far as I know, Ensure has never been advertised as the magic bullet to replace every food ever.

Post reply on HN