Live data from Hacker News

Maps That Show How Americans Speak English Differently From Each Other

businessinsider.com

1–10 of 105 posts

Re: Maps That Show How Americans Speak English Differently From Each Other

#2
This interesting set of maps is an example of how presentation can triumph over content. The pretty maps total to not a huge amount of information on dialect differences in the United States, a topic that has been posted about here on HN before, but their sheer prettiness prompted me to share the link to my Facebook wall, whereupon Facebook showed me on my home page that five of my other friends have already shared the same link. It's often easier for pretty pictures to go viral than more informative paragraphs of text.

The underlying survey that gathered the data

http://www4.uwm.edu/FLL/linguistics/dialect/

is, I think, something we have also discussed before here on HN. The link from the survey home page that is supposed to lead to the faculty webpage of the principal investigator appears to be a dead link. He is now at a new university,

http://www.mml.cam.ac.uk/dtal/staff/bv230/

still working on linguistics research.

Re: Maps That Show How Americans Speak English Differently From Each Other

#4
post #3

What is the difference between "cray-ahn" and "cray-awn"? Note that I pronounce "dawn" = "don". Also, I say crayon as "crown", which either isn't very popular, or they just chose poor colors for the heatmap.

Dawn and don are the same for me, too.

I pronounce crayon as "cray'n" -- pretty much exactly as you could pronounce "prayin'"

Re: Maps That Show How Americans Speak English Differently From Each Other

#5

This interesting set of maps is an example of how presentation can triumph over content. The pretty maps total to not a huge amount of information on dialect differences in the United States, a topic that has been posted about here on HN before, but their sheer prettiness prompted me to share the link to my Facebook wall, whereupon Facebook showed me on my home page that five of my other friends have already shared t…

I disagree about the quality of the information presented herein. As someone whose day job involves recording sound for film (necessarily including lots of dialog) and who is not American, regionalisms in accents are both challenging and fascinating for me, and a frequent topic of discussion between myself and the actors I work with. On smaller films there isn't usually the budget for a dialog coach and since I listen to people for a living that aspect of production often falls in my lap.

I found these maps extremely informative and and they helped to clarify some perplexing edge cases (eg people from Missouri sound southern in general, but on some words they exhibit marked differences from their near neighbors).

Re: Maps That Show How Americans Speak English Differently From Each Other

#6
post #3

What is the difference between "cray-ahn" and "cray-awn"? Note that I pronounce "dawn" = "don". Also, I say crayon as "crown", which either isn't very popular, or they just chose poor colors for the heatmap.

It would help if you mentioned where you're from, and where your parents are from.

Re: Maps That Show How Americans Speak English Differently From Each Other

#9
post #3

What is the difference between "cray-ahn" and "cray-awn"? Note that I pronounce "dawn" = "don". Also, I say crayon as "crown", which either isn't very popular, or they just chose poor colors for the heatmap.

Dawn and don are the same for me, too. I pronounce crayon as "cray'n" -- pretty much exactly as you could pronounce "prayin'"

What about "down" then ?

As in "Don said dawn gets him down".

Post reply on HN