Live data from Hacker News

Poll: how much would you pay to get issues resolved on GitHub?

news.ycombinator.com

31–40 of 51 posts

Re: Poll: how much would you pay to get issues resolved on GitHub?

#31

And similarly, I'd pay good money to have certain StackOverflow questions answered. But if these things seem like a no-brainer, there's a good reason why they're not available. (Third-parties have stepped in, but they're not officially supported.) Introducing money into the ecosystem can spoil people's motivation to do anything for free. This was one of the lessons from Google Answers, an early version of Stack, Quor…

[deleted]

Re: Poll: how much would you pay to get issues resolved on GitHub?

#32

I think maybe each bug could have a pot where people could put an amount, and if a developer fixed that bug and enough people agreed he would get that pot. That way developers could pick the bugs where people are willing to put their money where their mouth is.

This seems like it could be a very good business model for developers to employ. Maybe someone could start a service based upon it. I could see it doing very well.

Re: Poll: how much would you pay to get issues resolved on GitHub?

#33
post #4

This would change my work from a hobby to being a business. If someone pays for a ticket, the roles change a bit. The person who pays will expect something from you. I personally would not do that. If you like what I do, send me a beer afterwards. Or a gittip or a flattr. But don't pay me money.

How about this.. take samefisher's idea:

> I think maybe each bug could have a pot where people could to put an amount, and if a developer fixed that bug and enough people agreed he would get that pot.

Except leave out this part:

> That way developers could pick the bugs where people are willing to put their money where their mouth is.

Instead, completely hide showing how much money was donated to a bug. From everyone. When a developer fixes a bug, they may get a nice surprise for their contributions, that may further encourage them to work on issues.

A little like GitTip, but you're tipping whoever solves an issue, ahead of time. And because it's invisible, it doesn't make your hobby feel like a job because you don't know which issues are worth the most. (although it may be possible to guess by issue popularity)

Re: Poll: how much would you pay to get issues resolved on GitHub?

#34
post #10
post #3

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is an elegant way to crowdfund open-source software. Nice idea.

this! features can be funded this way as well.

I do really love the features idea.

Being a developer myself, when I create a piece of code to do a specific thing and release it to the public it's not for monetary gain, but to help others than need it by using my source. However, if they wanted additional features added to it, you could have a pot, and once the feature is achieved the pot would be deposited to the developer.

Re: Poll: how much would you pay to get issues resolved on GitHub?

#35
For reasons explained well here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5828677 I don't like this idea. I think it goes against the very motivation behind open source software.

What I think what would work better is if you had the option in github to vote up a bug (or expose the number of people following/watching it) so that the owner of a repository could use that number in deciding how important a bug is to his/her userbase.

Re: Poll: how much would you pay to get issues resolved on GitHub?

#36

I think maybe each bug could have a pot where people could put an amount, and if a developer fixed that bug and enough people agreed he would get that pot. That way developers could pick the bugs where people are willing to put their money where their mouth is.

This is exactly what https://www.bountysource.com/ does. Any number of people can contribute to the bounty pool. When a developer submits a solution that gets merged into the project and the issue itself is closed, that developer collects the bounty.

For example, here's an issue with 11 backers: https://www.bountysource.com/#issues/27-split-pane-feature

...and here's a bounty over $1100 with 5 backers: https://www.bountysource.com/#issues/315019-add-a-tiling-win...

Re: Poll: how much would you pay to get issues resolved on GitHub?

#37
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well, yes, actually I'm building http://issuehunter.co at TechPeaks[1]. What do you think about it? Are you using it? [1] http://techpeaks.eu

Time for firefox and chrome plugins that show the dollar value on a specific issue right on github, or whatever sites you support. Make it so I can add 10 dollars to an issue I care about, and add a "Sort by money" thing.

Great idea. At Bountysource.com we have a plugin for GitHub that automatically updates issues with bounty details when they exist (adds a link to the bounty in the issue body, bounty total to issue title and a special label). This needs to be installed by a project committer though. I'd love to see a Bountysource Chrome/Firefox extension, maybe we should put a bounty out for one :P

Re: Poll: how much would you pay to get issues resolved on GitHub?

#38

And similarly, I'd pay good money to have certain StackOverflow questions answered. But if these things seem like a no-brainer, there's a good reason why they're not available. (Third-parties have stepped in, but they're not officially supported.) Introducing money into the ecosystem can spoil people's motivation to do anything for free. This was one of the lessons from Google Answers, an early version of Stack, Quor…

I answered $100, but I am thinking more about Stackoverflow.

But I am willing to pay for someone fix my problem, not answer it. I mean, get access to my code and solve the issue himself. Like a micro-freelance job.

Thar way there is still incentive to answer doubts for free, in order to get more points/karma and attract more clients/charge more money.

Re: Poll: how much would you pay to get issues resolved on GitHub?

#39
Cool idea, but don't pollute Github's UI with this feature. Developers rely on Github to have a consistent UI — I think we all hate when it changes a bit.

Another website managing this would be nice. It could tie into Github's API and offer this service.

Re: Poll: how much would you pay to get issues resolved on GitHub?

#40
I have hundreds of open source modules and I really hate this idea. It creates a monetary incentive for developers to keep adding more features even when they are bad ideas. Also, what happens when a paid issue/feature was a mistake and should really be removed later? The economic incentive does not align very well with creating the most appropriate set of features for the task at hand and you end up with bulky enterprise kitchen-sink software.
Post reply on HN