Live data from Hacker News

Is Silicon Valley only interested in the problems of twentysomethings?

washingtonpost.com

1–10 of 86 posts

Re: Is Silicon Valley only interested in the problems of twentysomethings?

#2
It's hard to design and create software for subjects you don't know much about. It's not really a surprise that people create software for their own lives.

A lot of open source is focused on programming languages, libraries and things to help you code. It's what most open source people know, and thus what they create.

I wonder if it would have been better for CS to have been only offered as a minor or double-major to another field of study, at least at the Bachelor level. We would have fewer pure CS people, but a lot more people with training in another domain.

Re: Is Silicon Valley only interested in the problems of twentysomethings?

#5
The title is deceptive because shortly after asking that question in the article, the author comes to a resounding "no" and goes on to talk about why it is our impression that SV only works on the problems of 20-somethings. The core of the author's comment comes at the end:

"Imagine how odd it would be to read an article saying that the people who work for manufacturing firms are really just out to make money, or that they don’t seem interested enough in current events. It is only because Silicon Valley has done such an extraordinary job branding itself that articles about their social conscience, or lack thereof, seem completely reasonable. But the tech sector is, on the whole, much more like other sectors of the economy than it likes to believe, or than it likes anyone else to believe."

Re: Is Silicon Valley only interested in the problems of twentysomethings?

#6
If so, it's probably only because young adults are more likely to use the internet and therefore have problems that can be solved by the internet.

The internet can't really fix your problems if you don't use it in the first place. Or maybe it could, but you will never know better.

Re: Is Silicon Valley only interested in the problems of twentysomethings?

#7
Today's 20 somethings are tomorrows 30 and 40 somethings. Get them hooked young and you can milk them for a lifetime.

It's probably easier to persuade a 20 something to try something new. I know middle aged people who choose smartphones by waiting for their kids to each buy different ones and then choosing one of these for themselves.

Re: Is Silicon Valley only interested in the problems of twentysomethings?

#8
post #2

It's hard to design and create software for subjects you don't know much about. It's not really a surprise that people create software for their own lives. A lot of open source is focused on programming languages, libraries and things to help you code. It's what most open source people know, and thus what they create. I wonder if it would have been better for CS to have been only offered as a minor or double-major to…

I second this! or something similar, at least. Having not really gone to college, myself, I was lucky enough to have had so many varied life experiences and interests before I took up tech; so when talking to my colleagues who are cs-equipped, I find their methodology is often very CS oriented, and focused more on the tech than on the problem. I think that's why "design" has become such a big fad these days - it's almost as if we just figured out that people buy products, not tech.

That being said, after speaking with quite a few tech-inclined people, I feel they would be a lot more comfortable with less technically inclined subjects if they were stripped of the general cultural pretensions that they come with. There is a very strong resistance to "acculturation" among techies, as it is usually seen - rightly, for the most part - as a mechanism of enforcing a "cool kids' club", so to speak, rather than an actual venue for intellectual exploration.

I think, that as techies, we are in a unique situation, as far as intellectual development is concerned. The vast majority of the population can't appreciate technical phenomena because it is culturally viewed as "too hard" or "robotic" or "blah blah, boring". We, OTOH, actively refuse to engage with humanistic pursuits, but not out of any perceived difficulty so much as discomfort with the pretensions that come with "cultured society". If effort can be made to induct some history and philosophy, and heck, maybe even theology into the the techie culture, we could have the best of both worlds and possibly even have some truly fresh ideas put out.

In short, it's easier to teach a physicist to write essays than it is to teach a poet Diff Eq

Re: Is Silicon Valley only interested in the problems of twentysomethings?

#9
post #2

It's hard to design and create software for subjects you don't know much about. It's not really a surprise that people create software for their own lives. A lot of open source is focused on programming languages, libraries and things to help you code. It's what most open source people know, and thus what they create. I wonder if it would have been better for CS to have been only offered as a minor or double-major to…

I don't know about "only". Sometimes it's good to have a narrow focus on CS topics if you are going to implementing difficult low level stuff that only other techies will touch directly. It's also possible to get knowledge of other fields from places outside of academia.

Most UK universities do offer CS as a joint degree with other subjects, though in many cases they are limited to mainly other STEM subjects. I don't know anyone who studied joint CS/art history for example.

Re: Is Silicon Valley only interested in the problems of twentysomethings?

#10
post #2

It's hard to design and create software for subjects you don't know much about. It's not really a surprise that people create software for their own lives. A lot of open source is focused on programming languages, libraries and things to help you code. It's what most open source people know, and thus what they create. I wonder if it would have been better for CS to have been only offered as a minor or double-major to…

I don't know about "only". Sometimes it's good to have a narrow focus on CS topics if you are going to implementing difficult low level stuff that only other techies will touch directly. It's also possible to get knowledge of other fields from places outside of academia. Most UK universities do offer CS as a joint degree with other subjects, though in many cases they are limited to mainly other STEM subjects. I don't…

My university offered a undergrad CS major with a business minor that was pretty popular.
Post reply on HN