Live data from Hacker News

Is the FBI dumb, evil, or just incompetent?

techcrunch.com

1–10 of 105 posts

Re: Is the FBI dumb, evil, or just incompetent?

#4
The last line is the most important: if there is a backdoor (that is the Lawful Interception interface) there is no guarantee that it won't be used by unauthorized third parties.

Anyone could have predicted that something like the Google hack was going to happen. I also seem to remember that there was a similar incident involving the cellphone network in Greece.

Re: Is the FBI dumb, evil, or just incompetent?

#6
Are there any video chat clients with end-to-end encryption?

I was trying to do this by piping the output of my webcam to openssl and then to netcat, which sends the packets to a publicly addressable server (Amazon instance) that relays the encrypted packets to another computer behind a firewall, that decrypts the video stream and plays it in MPlayer. It works, but the latency is about 10 seconds. To reduce the latency, I could delta-encode the video stream, leverage the GPU somehow, but I'm not sure how to get the latency down to the 200ms required for seamless conversation. Also, it should be noted that there is little code behind this, mainly just unix utilities and pipes.

PS: Also I could remove the Amazon piece and forge a direct P2P connection using NAT hole punching if the routers on both ends permit, but this is not always reliable and isn't a huge source of latency.

Re: Is the FBI dumb, evil, or just incompetent?

#9

Maybe I'm being naive, but what's preventing Google or Facebook from using their resources to launch a PR campaign against these requests from the FBI, or at the very least be a bit more outspoken about them?

Google already makes noise about it. They have a project to report on requests. https://www.google.com/transparencyreport/

Re: Is the FBI dumb, evil, or just incompetent?

#10

Maybe I'm being naive, but what's preventing Google or Facebook from using their resources to launch a PR campaign against these requests from the FBI, or at the very least be a bit more outspoken about them?

Because they are?

http://news.cnet.com/8301-13578_3-57577958-38/google-fights-...

Post reply on HN