Live data from Hacker News

The Xbox One: Hardware Analysis & Comparison to PlayStation 4

anandtech.com

1–10 of 82 posts

Re: The Xbox One: Hardware Analysis & Comparison to PlayStation 4

#2
As usual, Anand delivers a fact based impartial comparison unlike all the biased flamebait articles making the rounds targeted at fans.

Ironically it was the PS3 that advertised itself as a media center last time with bluray support. That didn't wok out well, but the 360 later pivoted to media very successfully and still continues to outsell other consoles.

Re: The Xbox One: Hardware Analysis & Comparison to PlayStation 4

#3
It looks like the Sony machine will be more expensive (or its profit margins will be a lot lower). The PS4 seems to have a lot more hardware under the hood than the One.

Having said that, as I pointed out elsewhere, it's now how many things your device does, but how well it does the thing that'll define its function. If it's an entertainment system, it's how well it entertains people. If it's a videogame, it's how fun the games it plays are.

Re: The Xbox One: Hardware Analysis & Comparison to PlayStation 4

#5
post #3

It looks like the Sony machine will be more expensive (or its profit margins will be a lot lower). The PS4 seems to have a lot more hardware under the hood than the One. Having said that, as I pointed out elsewhere, it's now how many things your device does, but how well it does the thing that'll define its function. If it's an entertainment system, it's how well it entertains people. If it's a videogame, it's how fu…

I believe they used to make the previous console at a loss, because they generate most of their profits through the sales of games and accessories. I believe.

Re: The Xbox One: Hardware Analysis & Comparison to PlayStation 4

#7
post #3

It looks like the Sony machine will be more expensive (or its profit margins will be a lot lower). The PS4 seems to have a lot more hardware under the hood than the One. Having said that, as I pointed out elsewhere, it's now how many things your device does, but how well it does the thing that'll define its function. If it's an entertainment system, it's how well it entertains people. If it's a videogame, it's how fu…

Exactly, the developer experience is very important, and hardware is only an issue if you're really pushing the limits. Differences in SDK made a huge difference in popularity between the PS3 and the 360. Since the 360 handled background music, matchmaking, and voice chat natively, devs had a huge head start over competitors on the PS3. Helping out the devs had a direct effect on the players' experience, which led to the 360's dominance in multiplayer games.

Re: The Xbox One: Hardware Analysis & Comparison to PlayStation 4

#8
post #3

It looks like the Sony machine will be more expensive (or its profit margins will be a lot lower). The PS4 seems to have a lot more hardware under the hood than the One. Having said that, as I pointed out elsewhere, it's now how many things your device does, but how well it does the thing that'll define its function. If it's an entertainment system, it's how well it entertains people. If it's a videogame, it's how fu…

And the rest of the ecosystem. I do hope the new incarnation of Live allows for PC/One simultaneous play.

Re: The Xbox One: Hardware Analysis & Comparison to PlayStation 4

#9
post #3

It looks like the Sony machine will be more expensive (or its profit margins will be a lot lower). The PS4 seems to have a lot more hardware under the hood than the One. Having said that, as I pointed out elsewhere, it's now how many things your device does, but how well it does the thing that'll define its function. If it's an entertainment system, it's how well it entertains people. If it's a videogame, it's how fu…

Not necessarily -- the Xbox include a Kinect in the box which will increase its price/lower its profit margin. The PS4 has a camera but nothing as sophisticated/expensive as the Kinect.

Re: The Xbox One: Hardware Analysis & Comparison to PlayStation 4

#10

Took me a while to discover the meat of the article was hidden inside a drop-down navigation system. I honestly nearly bailed thinking, "This is all there is?" What an awful idea. Thank goodness I saw it at the last minute.

>Took me a while to discover the meat of the article was hidden inside a drop-down navigation system

I agree! I hate their navigation UI. In general drop downs should only be used for familiar lists (counties, states, etc.) However, some of their articles are very detailed and has numerous pages and they need to provide a quick access to individual pages. One work around is to provide a simple "Next >>" at the bottom of the article. It would make it a lot less confusing.

Post reply on HN