Live data from Hacker News

Xbox, A New Generation Revealed (livesteam)

xbox.com

71–80 of 92 posts

Re: Xbox, A New Generation Revealed (livesteam)

#71
post #70

Can somebody explain why HN's ranking algorithm has already pushed this submission to the second page? This seems inconsistent with its points, age and level of discussion relative to the articles ranked above. (I'm just asking out of curiosity and have no personal interest in having this post ranked higher or lower.)

Some moderator probably downvoted it.

I've noticed when the discussion is of low quality stories tend to fall faster. So yeah, you're probably right.

Re: Xbox, A New Generation Revealed (livesteam)

#72
post #61
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You still think this is still primarily a game console? Microsoft is putting all its chips down on the battle for your living room, which is a major front. The fight to be the all-in-one device people buy that replaces their cable box, game console, and media server (and the data being positioned as the provider of that device brings with it) is not a small one. Self-identified "gamers" like yourself, who will probab…

Does the average consumer really want an expensive, gigantic box with huge blower fans to watch Netflix and Hulu - when an Apple TV, Roku, or any coffee grinder with an HDMI port does the job?

The average consumer? Of course. They want as few fiddly bits as possible. They want their stuff to just work.

Re: Xbox, A New Generation Revealed (livesteam)

#73
post #61

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Does the average consumer really want an expensive, gigantic box with huge blower fans to watch Netflix and Hulu - when an Apple TV, Roku, or any coffee grinder with an HDMI port does the job?

The average consumer? Of course. They want as few fiddly bits as possible. They want their stuff to just work.

Then they want an Apple TV or a Roku. My wife's grandma can and does use an Apple TV to watch Netflix. There's no way in hell she could ever navigate the UI disaster that is the XBox 360.

Re: Xbox, A New Generation Revealed (livesteam)

#74

Can somebody explain why HN's ranking algorithm has already pushed this submission to the second page? This seems inconsistent with its points, age and level of discussion relative to the articles ranked above. (I'm just asking out of curiosity and have no personal interest in having this post ranked higher or lower.)

No one can down-vote posts, but posts that require attention (moderator related?) can be flagged to indicate that the link is to something that is outright bad (spam, inflamatory content, false information etc) and if it gets flagged by a lot of people it falls down the front page.

There's probably something else I don't know about the ranking algorithm though.

Re: Xbox, A New Generation Revealed (livesteam)

#75
post #4

Xbox One? That's a rather confusing name since it's the third Xbox.

That didn't stop Apple from naming the newest iPhone the "iPhone 5", despite being the sixth.

Yeah, man. Why did this stupid developer call her newest release "Program 2"?! It’s her third release, after all, she already released Program 1.0 and Program 1.1.

To want to call the iPhone 5 iPhone 6 is so insane, I cannot fathom how anyone could come up with this crazy idea.

Re: Xbox, A New Generation Revealed (livesteam)

#76
I have to say I'm pretty disappointed in HN right now. I came to this thread hoping to see some good discussion but instead there's just a bunch of crap. I see a lot of complaining and comments at a very superficial level. Can we talk about the competition and their different strategies? Can we talk about any of the new things presented and whether or not they are interesting or valuable, and why? Can we talk about the technology? Can we talk about how Sony seems to have gone out of their way to court indie developers but MS didn't even mention them here?

Re: Xbox, A New Generation Revealed (livesteam)

#77
post #70

Can somebody explain why HN's ranking algorithm has already pushed this submission to the second page? This seems inconsistent with its points, age and level of discussion relative to the articles ranked above. (I'm just asking out of curiosity and have no personal interest in having this post ranked higher or lower.)

Some moderator probably downvoted it.

I'd like it better if this kind of moderation would be more transparent.

Re: Xbox, A New Generation Revealed (livesteam)

#78
post #74

Can somebody explain why HN's ranking algorithm has already pushed this submission to the second page? This seems inconsistent with its points, age and level of discussion relative to the articles ranked above. (I'm just asking out of curiosity and have no personal interest in having this post ranked higher or lower.)

No one can down-vote posts, but posts that require attention (moderator related?) can be flagged to indicate that the link is to something that is outright bad (spam, inflamatory content, false information etc) and if it gets flagged by a lot of people it falls down the front page. There's probably something else I don't know about the ranking algorithm though.

Do users who abuse the flagging feature get penalized?

Re: Xbox, A New Generation Revealed (livesteam)

#79

"Practically silent" means my wife will practically force me to buy one, as she (rightfully) complains about the jet engine turbines the launch day 360 uses for fans. I've been holding off buying a dedicated Blu-ray player, so that has some value. Don't care about Kinect, not enough room in the TV room. Don't care about being "connected" as I have enough Skype-enabled, etc. devices around the house. The hard question…

The fan: http://www.wired.com/gadgetlab/2013/05/xbox-one-development-...

Bigger typically means quieter.

Re: Xbox, A New Generation Revealed (livesteam)

#80
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No one can down-vote posts, but posts that require attention (moderator related?) can be flagged to indicate that the link is to something that is outright bad (spam, inflamatory content, false information etc) and if it gets flagged by a lot of people it falls down the front page. There's probably something else I don't know about the ranking algorithm though.

Do users who abuse the flagging feature get penalized?

I don't think so, not for just flagging but there does seem to be a way HN can find this type of behaviour and ignore the actions of users that abuse the voting system. read this for some more info http://www.jacquesmattheij.com/The+Unofficial+HN+FAQ
Post reply on HN