Live data from Hacker News

Release of Diaspora v0.1.0.0

joindiaspora.com

41–50 of 64 posts

Re: Release of Diaspora v0.1.0.0

#41
post #6

It's hard to see this getting traction now, but I'm still glad it exists. Maybe Facebook will somehow fuck up badly enough to push people onto Diaspora, although I can't really see how at this point.

You could say that if no users would join Diaspora. Yet, more come constantly, so you can't say that it didn't gain traction.

Re: Release of Diaspora v0.1.0.0

#44
For those who asked about chat functionality in Diaspora - the project is looking into enabling a chat capability, naturally using interoperable protocols like XMPP. It's not as trivial as it seems though, since it will require running additional XMPP server on the pod. Another option is to allow using external XMPP accounts for the web UI.

Having a chat is not really the highest priority, since there are tons of federated XMPP servers around already, and standalone XMPP clients that are light years better and feature rich than any possible web UI. But having web UI for chat as a convenience is still useful and attractive, so see the discussion here about adding this feature:

https://www.loomio.org/discussions/3678

Re: Release of Diaspora v0.1.0.0

#45
post #3

Maybe it's just me that noticed or felt this, but often times a service or product builds up a lot of hype and ends up being vaporware. Diaspora got mainstream attention when Zuckerberg donated money to them and when they complained at the height of Facebook's privacy problems. But then didn't deliver until like a year later? Similar thing happened with Google+. I remember my non-techie friends wanting to get in, but…

How is it vaporware when it's a working and functional social network? It's not as feature rich as it could be - there are a lot of things to improve there. But it's working, which is NOT vaporware by any means.

Re: Release of Diaspora v0.1.0.0

#46

Due to the focus on privacy, I think Diaspora makes perfect sense as intranet social network for Companies, Govt, Colleges etc. I would wish Diaspora pivots in this direction

How does diaspora focus on privacy? The whole point of Diaspora was to implement a decentralized Facebook. Diaspora as it has been, is centralized, and doesn't seem to be anything but a smaller, crappier Facebook. Friendica does what Diaspora was supposed to do, and well, and can integrate with the Facebook API and download your personal Facebook feed into your Friendica feed.

> Diaspora as it has been, is centralized

Diaspora is as much decentralized, as many pods participate in it. There are many single user pods which demonstrates its decentralization pretty well. So your statement above is false. I'd compare it to federated XMPP network - there are major servers with many users, and there are single user servers as well.

Re: Release of Diaspora v0.1.0.0

#47
post #6

It's hard to see this getting traction now, but I'm still glad it exists. Maybe Facebook will somehow fuck up badly enough to push people onto Diaspora, although I can't really see how at this point.

Sadly I think that Google and FB would need to fuck up at the same time (when hell freezes over). All the people I know who avoid FB are proudly on G+, for reasons I don't understand.

I avoid FB. And I'm on G+ strictly because a distributed work group I'm on uses hangouts to meet. I do nothing else with G+.

Re: Release of Diaspora v0.1.0.0

#48
post #41
post #6

It's hard to see this getting traction now, but I'm still glad it exists. Maybe Facebook will somehow fuck up badly enough to push people onto Diaspora, although I can't really see how at this point.

You could say that if no users would join Diaspora. Yet, more come constantly, so you can't say that it didn't gain traction.

are there any publicly-available metrics on Diaspora adoption, engagement?

Re: Release of Diaspora v0.1.0.0

#49
post #45
post #3

Maybe it's just me that noticed or felt this, but often times a service or product builds up a lot of hype and ends up being vaporware. Diaspora got mainstream attention when Zuckerberg donated money to them and when they complained at the height of Facebook's privacy problems. But then didn't deliver until like a year later? Similar thing happened with Google+. I remember my non-techie friends wanting to get in, but…

How is it vaporware when it's a working and functional social network? It's not as feature rich as it could be - there are a lot of things to improve there. But it's working, which is NOT vaporware by any means.

I signed up for an invite around the time it was announced. It took a while before even an alpha was released. Diaspora has unfortunately stagnated. The future rests with Status.net, Tent.io, or App.net in this field.

Re: Release of Diaspora v0.1.0.0

#50
post #21

What kind of version is v0.1.0.0? First major version? First minor version? Something in between? It would be so much easier to reason about version numbers if everyone would stick to Semantic Versioning[0]. [0]: http://semver.org/

Semver is explicitly ambiguous about versions < 1

Yeah, but not about whether you're at a version < 1.
Post reply on HN