Live data from Hacker News

A 75-Year Harvard Study Finds What It Takes To Live A Happy Life

businessinsider.com

21–30 of 175 posts

Re: A 75-Year Harvard Study Finds What It Takes To Live A Happy Life

#21
post #14

These are the kind of studies that make me think social-psychology is just a psuedo-science. If you want to understand human-nature, read Shakespeare over Freud. If you want to influence people, read Dale Carnegie over B.F. Skinner. I'll gladly eat crow if this study results in a 6% increase in loving relationships or a 5% decrease in alcoholism...

Not actively disagreeing, but would you care to elaborate on why you think social-psychology is a psuedo-science?

Re: A 75-Year Harvard Study Finds What It Takes To Live A Happy Life

#22

Ack. Reliable or not, I'm sure it was meant as a feel-good piece, but for people like me the quote:- "Vaillant’s key takeaway, in his own words: “The seventy-five years and twenty million dollars expended on the Grant Study points … to a straightforward five-word conclusion: ‘Happiness is love. Full stop.’" Is actually very depressing. I am 5'5" so have this (if you've not encountered it you are unlikely to be aware)…

wat. you're 5'5". that's what's stopping you from being in love? what in the fuck does that have to do with ANYTHING. that's not a question.

you need to get out of your head, your bubble and get friends first. good friends that can help you get your head straight. no one cares about your height bro.

Re: A 75-Year Harvard Study Finds What It Takes To Live A Happy Life

#23
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's useful to parents.

Because bad parents will become more nurturing after reading an article?

Sorry, I don't have a link for you, but I've recently read that one of the problems that many parents who live in poverty have is that they simply do not know what is necessary to be a good parent.

The specific example was with respect to talking to infants - that talking to children who do not yet have the power of speech makes an enormous difference in the development of verbal and cognitive ability. Rich infants heard an order or two more words per day than poor infants due only to the fact that poor parents didn't know that it was important. There was no intent to neglect, just ignorance.

The overwhelming majority of parents want to be good parents, some just need better information on how to do it.

Re: A 75-Year Harvard Study Finds What It Takes To Live A Happy Life

#24
If you really want to know what it takes to live a happy life, read the book Flow [1] by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi. It's the best book I've ever read on happiness and reading it has positively changed my life like nothing else.

[1] http://www.amazon.com/Flow-Psychology-Experience-Mihaly-Csik...

Re: A 75-Year Harvard Study Finds What It Takes To Live A Happy Life

#26

Ack. Reliable or not, I'm sure it was meant as a feel-good piece, but for people like me the quote:- "Vaillant’s key takeaway, in his own words: “The seventy-five years and twenty million dollars expended on the Grant Study points … to a straightforward five-word conclusion: ‘Happiness is love. Full stop.’" Is actually very depressing. I am 5'5" so have this (if you've not encountered it you are unlikely to be aware)…

I'm 5'4", chubby, prematurely balding, and under 30, and I've been in long term relationships with several awesome women.

There are certainly disadvantages to being short, probably especially in the dating realm. Big whoop. That's not what's preventing you from dating anyone.

Re: A 75-Year Harvard Study Finds What It Takes To Live A Happy Life

#27

Ack. Reliable or not, I'm sure it was meant as a feel-good piece, but for people like me the quote:- "Vaillant’s key takeaway, in his own words: “The seventy-five years and twenty million dollars expended on the Grant Study points … to a straightforward five-word conclusion: ‘Happiness is love. Full stop.’" Is actually very depressing. I am 5'5" so have this (if you've not encountered it you are unlikely to be aware)…

I just had a couple stay at my place from Airbnb. They were both under 5'5. I don't have anything beyond this anecdote, but this alone must prove that someone is out there!

Sure there are exceptions, but as a rule, he's right.

I'm slightly taller than average, but even I have noticed this phenomenon. It is ridiculous how many single women say they exclusively want a tall man, they want to "look up" to a man. Even the shorter-than-average women want a man of at least average height. On dating sites like PlentyOfFish I've seen ~5' tall women say that they are only interested in men at least 6' tall. I wouldn't be surprised to learn that height is in the top 3 discriminators that women have for men (weight, race and baldness being in contention for the other two spots).

The short guys (as well as chubby, bald guys) that I know who have been successful with the ladies have all been comedians. If you can get past their firewall of physical characteristics, making a woman laugh is the root password to her lady parts and her heart. Sucks if you are short, fat, bald and not very funny though.

Re: A 75-Year Harvard Study Finds What It Takes To Live A Happy Life

#28
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's useful to parents.

Because bad parents will become more nurturing after reading an article?

A lot of people who had bad parents want to be better parents than what they experienced. Articles can definitely affect their behavior.

How do I know this? Because I'm one of them!

Re: A 75-Year Harvard Study Finds What It Takes To Live A Happy Life

#29

Ack. Reliable or not, I'm sure it was meant as a feel-good piece, but for people like me the quote:- "Vaillant’s key takeaway, in his own words: “The seventy-five years and twenty million dollars expended on the Grant Study points … to a straightforward five-word conclusion: ‘Happiness is love. Full stop.’" Is actually very depressing. I am 5'5" so have this (if you've not encountered it you are unlikely to be aware)…

I am short (5'6"). Never had a problem (except maybe as a kid). My wife is taller than me.

I am sure you will be fine. It's all about the attitude.

Re: A 75-Year Harvard Study Finds What It Takes To Live A Happy Life

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The research on mothering style may be highly predictive, but unless I'm missing something, it isn't actionable or "useful."

It's useful to parents.

did they isolate correlation from causation yet though..?
Post reply on HN