Live data from Hacker News

Actually eat healthily for £1 per day

supplementsos.com

11–20 of 180 posts

Re: Actually eat healthily for £1 per day

#11
post #6

I think the main weakness of the diet not listed on their weaknesses is they've made no attempt to break it down into a realistic 3x7 meal plan, because it doesn't really make one. Yeah, it's easy to put together a whole load of things cheaply that conform to predetermined values on a spreadsheet, but sometimes sum of the parts does not give you a realistic outcome. Also, I can tell you as someone who grew up with pa…

> I think the main weakness of the diet not listed on their weaknesses is they've made no attempt to break it down into a realistic 3x7 meal plan, because it doesn't really make one. Yeah, it's easy to put together a whole load of things cheaply that conform to predetermined values on a spreadsheet, but sometimes sum of the parts does not give you a realistic outcome.

That's a very fair point, but it seemed like premature optimization to try to nail down a meal plan before all the kinks in the nutrition side of things were ironed out. I do plan on getting to that stage in a later version.

Perhaps I should have waited before publishing this post, but honestly, I tend to lose myself in projects like this, and without some indication that other people are interested I often end up leaving the work in an archive somewhere to finish later.

I hope that there's enough data there to be useful/interesting in its current state, but I agree, needs more work

Re: Actually eat healthily for £1 per day

#13
Working back from a government nutritional RDA is not really the best way to shape a diet.

Instead:

1: Uncover your total daily energy expenditure: BMR*activity multiplier

2: Once you have your TDEE set your macro intake, and try to get them from mostly whole foods:

_2a: Set daily intake of protein to around 0.82g/lb of bodyweight. Higher if you're more active, can be lower if you're more sedentary.

_2b: Set daily fat intake to around 0.25-0.5g/lb bodyweight, prioritizing essential fats.

_2c: Fill remaining TDEE with carbohydrates.

_2d: Get adequate fibre: at least 0.15g/lb bodyweight per day, but stay below ~0.4g/lb so that it doesn't begin to negatively affect the absorption of nutrients.

3: Measure intake and body comp over time, adjust diet as required.

Re: Actually eat healthily for £1 per day

#15
post #7

This article (and many others like it) miss out an incredibly cheap and healthy source of food, growing your own vegetables.

Only if your time is cheap as well.

If I can make $500 in the few hours a week it takes to tend my garden, then it's better to buy off a local farmer.

Re: Actually eat healthily for £1 per day

#16
post #7

This article (and many others like it) miss out an incredibly cheap and healthy source of food, growing your own vegetables.

Given that most people nowadays live in towns or agglomerations ...

I live in the suburbs but with a very small backyard. I have about 60 sq ft of space that provides 90% of my vegetables throughout the year. When I lived in an apartment I had two tomato plants and two squash plants on my deck and it would give me pounds of food a week (squash grows really quickly, tomatoes grow abundantly).

It's not impossible by any means for most people to do so, even in small quantities.

Re: Actually eat healthily for £1 per day

#17
The same triple constraint nature of the project management triangle exists, I think, with food intake. Quality, cost, and ease/speed of preparation -- pick two.

Every two days, I cook up 2 lbs ground beef, boil 4 cups beans, and 4 cups rice. I let it cool off, and throw it in Tupperware, and into the fridge. I take from that whenever I'm hungry. It doesn't taste the best, but it fills you up, is cheap, and is good for you! If you're feeling the need for some extra veggies/fruit, avocado, frozen blueberries, and frozen kale offer the most nutritional content at the lowest price and least preparation time.

Like work, I don't think this will ever be 'optimal', but it's good for now, in that it saves me time, money, and waistline. Can tweak it as I go.

Re: Actually eat healthily for £1 per day

#18
post #7

This article (and many others like it) miss out an incredibly cheap and healthy source of food, growing your own vegetables.

c1u: You're hellbanned.

But in any case, if you can trade a few hours for $500 at will, you probably can spend more than £1/day in food. Most people can't just work a few more hours (if they have a job at all) though.

Re: Actually eat healthily for £1 per day

#20
If you want to save some money, save some time and eat healthy, try this:

Go to the grocery store, buy these 3 items:

1 bag of frozen vegetables.

3 chicken breasts

1 bag of dried lentils.

Sunday night:

Cook lentils in water, don't add anything Slice chicken breasts down the side, add seasoning, no oil, just seasoning, don't bread it etc. Bake the chicken breasts

Monday for lunch:

Microwave a bunch of the vegetables, grab your chicken breast, and precooked lentils mix lentils in with vegetables and throw the chicken breast on top, cook together.

Repeat that 4-5 days a week. Your energy will be higher, you will start loosing weight, and you will save money. Its the only meal I have found that does all three.

[it should go without saying, but there is no dressing added, no butters, oils etc. once you start adding that stuff you might as well just grab a burger or some Chinese food]

[ADDED] I am not advocating this be your only meal. Its just a meal that replaces the normal garbage that I would eat if I didn't have a good, low-cost, delicious alternative.

If you are fully aware of your diet and are in good shape, then by all means, add whatever you think you want to make it taste better, but this meal really doesn't need it.

My comment about not adding butters/oils etc. is aimed at people who think they are eating healthy by having a salad with blue cheese dressing.

Also, for those of you in your early 20s who think you know how to eat well, prepare yourself. Once you get to your late 20s, early 30s, it starts getting much tougher.

Post reply on HN