Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Remove backgrounds from images online

clippingmagic.com

111–120 of 148 posts

Re: Show HN: Remove backgrounds from images online

#111
post #54
post #49

I actually wrote my honours thesis on this topic. In academia it's called Alpha Matting/Image Matting. There's a great website http://alphamatting.com/ that provides a benchmark dataset and a comparison of a lot of influential methods. I applaud your work in making a real time and interactive matting algorithm! One day it might be also as accurate as state of the art methods. You guys should write a paper about your…

(I'm one of the devs.) Thanks for the link! Real time is a pretty big constraint, and the input for those results is a much more complete labeling than we expect (only 22 to 44 pixels around the ground truth boundary are left uncertain). But I'll definitely read the paper and hopefully we can gain some insights from it!

You should read Jue Wang's 2007 survey paper which groups and puts all the techniques in context, then a handful of the top performing papers from recent years on alphamatting.com

http://www.juew.org/publication/mattingSurvey.pdf

Re: Show HN: Remove backgrounds from images online

#112
This is really nice, it would be cool to add a rotate button - the image I picked at random to upload I think was rotated via EXIF.

Also, it'd be really cool to have a "simplify lines" type feature, I was using a fairly dark photo and the lines were a bit jagged - but generally the foreground item will have smooth edges.

Re: Show HN: Remove backgrounds from images online

#113
post #16
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I copied the marks in the example and besides needing to tell it to include the cream color under the strap, it worked exactly as shown on the homepage, so maybe just add that extra red there in the example. Unfortunately it is freezing up on me using an image with a gradient at about 90% of the initialization.

Yeah, we're getting some null pointers in the worker. Not entirely clear why that's happening (it of course wasn't happening an hour ago...). I think I stuck a race condition in there somewhere and it's getting exposed for the first time. Please try uploading the image again :-/

Could be related to the image color profile. Noticed the same issue when I uploaded a jpeg image with a CMYK color profile, with RGB images it worked normally. I've had the same trouble when using Java's ImageIO to read images. There were some workarounds, but I didn't find a robust one. Ended up using a preprocessor to normalize images before reading them with Java. Would love to know if someone knows a better solution.

Re: Show HN: Remove backgrounds from images online

#114
This is seriously great and very intuitive to use. Two small improvements : it would be great to be able to change brushes (at least size). The workaround is zoom/draw/unzoom which is a bit awkward. The second thing is to add an example on the landing page. I didn't take the time to try it on a picture of mine until I read the comments (and saw screenshots) here. HTH, keep up the good work!

Re: Show HN: Remove backgrounds from images online

#116
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I just gave it another shot with the same results in all browsers. Edit: I'm in Japan and going through a http proxy, if that makes a difference.

May do. I think it uses websockets and they are a little temperamental over proxies.

I already wrote that a little further down in my other comment. The web sockets are using port 9006. Maybe this is an issue on certain networks.

Re: Show HN: Remove backgrounds from images online

#117
post #54
post #49

I actually wrote my honours thesis on this topic. In academia it's called Alpha Matting/Image Matting. There's a great website http://alphamatting.com/ that provides a benchmark dataset and a comparison of a lot of influential methods. I applaud your work in making a real time and interactive matting algorithm! One day it might be also as accurate as state of the art methods. You guys should write a paper about your…

(I'm one of the devs.) Thanks for the link! Real time is a pretty big constraint, and the input for those results is a much more complete labeling than we expect (only 22 to 44 pixels around the ground truth boundary are left uncertain). But I'll definitely read the paper and hopefully we can gain some insights from it!

A bit off topic, but I'm working on a video interviewing startup and one of the things we'd looove to offer is (semi-)automatic Chrome Keying / green screening to show just a person's torso and face.

Might (one of) you know what's the state of the art in research on this topic as well?

Re: Show HN: Remove backgrounds from images online

#118
post #100

I get "Your Browser Is Out Of Date... Terribly sorry, but your browser appears to be missing key feature(s) required to use this website: Data URL Support Please try the latest version of one of these browsers instead: Google Chrome, Firefox", however I'm using Safari 5.1: data URL support has been in Safari since 3.1 (according to http://caniuse.com/datauri ).

I get the same message for FF 21.0 on my phone ... it's the current beta release, so I'm not sure how to run anything newer without building it myself... 😓

Re: Show HN: Remove backgrounds from images online

#119
post #100

I get "Your Browser Is Out Of Date... Terribly sorry, but your browser appears to be missing key feature(s) required to use this website: Data URL Support Please try the latest version of one of these browsers instead: Google Chrome, Firefox", however I'm using Safari 5.1: data URL support has been in Safari since 3.1 (according to http://caniuse.com/datauri ).

[deleted]
Post reply on HN