Live data from Hacker News

A bill in Congress legalizes cell phone unlocking and fixes the DMCA

fixthedmca.org

41–50 of 108 posts

Re: A bill in Congress legalizes cell phone unlocking and fixes the DMCA

#41
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Perfect is the enemy of good.

This is a dumb saying. Refusing to settle for anything short of perfect is often a bad trait, sure. But if you don't have a "perfect" goal to aim for, what you end up with is going to be worse than it could have been.

> Refusing to settle for anything short of perfect is often a bad trait, sure.

And that's what the saying means...

Especially important for technologists and entrepreneurs.

Re: A bill in Congress legalizes cell phone unlocking and fixes the DMCA

#43
post #4

If you want this to pass, don't sign the petition, and don't email or write your congresscritter. Call them . Interact with a human being in their office. Anecdotally, that has a much greater impact. (Source: my cousin and his wife were congressional staffers for several years.)

Agreed!

Congressmen value usable research and testimony. If you can hand them a credible argument for your point, well-condensed, well-organized, well-researched, and give a solid political bottom line (they are all about getting elected, you know) then you're ten miles ahead of the pack.

Re: A bill in Congress legalizes cell phone unlocking and fixes the DMCA

#44
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is a hidden agenda in saying that this "fixes the DMCA." It has a morass of serious issues untouched by these modifications.

Such as..? Not disagreeing, but you're begging the question.

Raising the question, maybe. However, for instance, in the eventuality that this bill passes, it will still be illegal to link to certain content. It only touches sec. 1201.

Re: A bill in Congress legalizes cell phone unlocking and fixes the DMCA

#45
post #4

If you want this to pass, don't sign the petition, and don't email or write your congresscritter. Call them . Interact with a human being in their office. Anecdotally, that has a much greater impact. (Source: my cousin and his wife were congressional staffers for several years.)

Or, better yet, do both: call your representative's office _and_ sign the petitions/send emails.

Re: A bill in Congress legalizes cell phone unlocking and fixes the DMCA

#46
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a dumb saying. Refusing to settle for anything short of perfect is often a bad trait, sure. But if you don't have a "perfect" goal to aim for, what you end up with is going to be worse than it could have been.

> Refusing to settle for anything short of perfect is often a bad trait, sure. And that's what the saying means... Especially important for technologists and entrepreneurs.

I realize that's what the saying is supposed to mean but it doesn't really say that.

I detest speaking in platitudes when plain english will do fine.

Re: A bill in Congress legalizes cell phone unlocking and fixes the DMCA

#47
post #31
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Is there a website where we can easily find our rep's phone number?

FightForTheFuture's CISPA page has a good tool for this: http://cms.fightforthefuture.org/cispa/

I'll actually throw a link up to this on the post-email modal so that people can call if they want to.

Re: A bill in Congress legalizes cell phone unlocking and fixes the DMCA

#48
post #15

This legislation doesn't entirely fix the DMCA. It fixes some problems but more remain. Copyright is some seriously fucked up shit right now. It has been dominated by big money interests for the last 50 years.

Forward progress is still forward progress.

Absolutely, and I'm glad for it. I was taking issue with the claim that it "fixes" the DMCA.

Re: A bill in Congress legalizes cell phone unlocking and fixes the DMCA

#49
post #4

If you want this to pass, don't sign the petition, and don't email or write your congresscritter. Call them . Interact with a human being in their office. Anecdotally, that has a much greater impact. (Source: my cousin and his wife were congressional staffers for several years.)

For someone who has never called a politician to lobby for something, what do you say when you call them up? Is it as simple as "I'd like for you back this bill?" Honest question.

Re: A bill in Congress legalizes cell phone unlocking and fixes the DMCA

#50
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The reason this is, BTW, is that calling isn't scalable. Any idiot can fire off emails or print petitions or print and mail letters (albeit with a budget). Fielding calls is a huge pain in the ass and can be linked - via area code+prefix, among others - to a specific district.

Ah, a budget ... what I would give to have one of those :). More seriously though, I have definite plans to build a click-to-call tool in the next couple of weeks, but this news was sprung on my late yesterday, leading to a mad rush to get that page ready in time for this morning. Next time there's an action like this for FixtheDMCA, there'll definitely be a way to call. And if I build it I'll almost certainly open s…

> More seriously though, I have definite plans to build a click-to-call tool in the next couple of weeks

I'm not sure how you do this on Android, but for the iPhone it couldn't be much simpler[1]. Also, most mobile devices will detect and enable any phone number they find on the page, so just putting it there and easy to find is often enough.

[1] http://developer.apple.com/library/ios/#featuredarticles/iPh...

Post reply on HN