Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Find the cheapest Amazon for your books

piranhas.co

21–29 of 29 posts

Re: Show HN: Find the cheapest Amazon for your books

#21
post #20
post #4

"We can't search for anything if this is empty :-(" It's not empty though... it says "chad fowler". I understand this is just a placeholder, but for those who aren't developers and may not appreciate the difference, clicking search when the input field is empty should perform a search for the placeholder text.

Huh, never considered this before. If I had a placeholder username/password on my login box, should just clicking "login" take the user to a demo/guest account, or should it bounce them and tell them to fill it in? What would be more expected there?

The general principle here is that if your field has a placeholder which is descriptive such as "Enter search here" (or just "Search") then it's a bad user experience if submitting the form does a search for the literal text "Enter search here". However, if the placeholder is a valid example such as "Isaac Asimov", then it's a good user experience if submitting the form does a search for that actual text, especially where trying out the search is a primary means of demonstrating the product as is the case here.

Another example might be a flight search service where the placeholders for "Departing" and "Arriving" contain "Los Angeles" and "New York" plus valid leave/return dates. If you're trying to show people (who may not be actively looking for a flight at the time) how awesome your service is, clicking on the "Show Flights" button should use those values because the whole point is to demonstrate your service's unique selling proposition.

For a login/demo where your goal is to get people to try the demo and convert into a signup, I suspect you will find it more effective to offer trying a demo account via an obvious, in-your-face call to action rather than dual-purposing your customer login form.

Re: Show HN: Find the cheapest Amazon for your books

#23
I tried it with the first several suggested books, and they all showed .com as the cheapest. You might want to consider hand-picking a few that will show up for [country] users as cheaper from [other country] store, to better demonstrate the utility of the service.

Re: Show HN: Find the cheapest Amazon for your books

#24
post #21
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Huh, never considered this before. If I had a placeholder username/password on my login box, should just clicking "login" take the user to a demo/guest account, or should it bounce them and tell them to fill it in? What would be more expected there?

The general principle here is that if your field has a placeholder which is descriptive such as "Enter search here" (or just "Search") then it's a bad user experience if submitting the form does a search for the literal text "Enter search here". However, if the placeholder is a valid example such as "Isaac Asimov", then it's a good user experience if submitting the form does a search for that actual text, especially…

Dual-purposing your customer login form in addition to the blatant CTA might not be a terrible idea, though.

Re: Show HN: Find the cheapest Amazon for your books

#25
post #4

"We can't search for anything if this is empty :-(" It's not empty though... it says "chad fowler". I understand this is just a placeholder, but for those who aren't developers and may not appreciate the difference, clicking search when the input field is empty should perform a search for the placeholder text.

Not to mention that you might be able to get a couple of dollars from whomever's name or title you put in there. That's a nice unobtrusive way to get some ad money.

Re: Show HN: Find the cheapest Amazon for your books

#28
post #18
post #17

This is great! As someone who moved from London to Sydney it is just what I need, I never know whether to order from the .com store or the .co.uk store.

You might find http://booko.com.au/ useful

Hey that's my site - thanks for mentioning it! There's also a UK, NZ and US site( http://booko.us/ ) now.

Re: Show HN: Find the cheapest Amazon for your books

#29
post #28
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You might find http://booko.com.au/ useful

Hey that's my site - thanks for mentioning it! There's also a UK, NZ and US site( http://booko.us/ ) now.

Wow. Thanks for saving me umpteen bucks over the last few years.
Post reply on HN